- Joined
- Jul 15, 2014
- Sythe Gold
- 1,649
- Messages
- 29,604
- Location
- Everywhere
- Discord Unique ID
- 178395186253004800
- Discord Username
- andrew7548
If i close my eyes, the problem goes away. Case closed.
You can sail in a circle on a disc if north points to the center of the disc
I think if you are being asked to prove that the earth is round you would not get away with assuming the sun is 8 light minutes away. This is assuming the initial point. You'd need to prove this before you could use it.
Recombination of the same two incorrect methods does not produce a third correct method. Read previous reasons addressing these.
Can I also say that even with access to the internet you are all really bad at logically analysing experiment design. In this case there's just two things to look at: 1) what would the experiment yield on the surface of a sphere 2) what would it yield on the surface of a plane. Most of you were unable to logically think past point 1.
You can't alter the intellect of your fictional characters to suit your purpose, there's no point in arguing in that case because it's not real-world logic, it's sythe-is-the-admin-and-a-college-graduate-logic.
For example, you discount the method Eratosthenes used to accurately measure the Earth's circumference because you choose to have your fictional characters believe the big ball of death that's impossibly far and impossibly hot be a regular old spot light a few meters off of a flat surface.
Not to mention, by the time Eratosthenes provided this evidence that the Earth is round rather than flat, the time was between 300 and 100BC, and they knew full well that the sun wasn't a lamp of some sort near the surface of the earth.
Additionally, there was no such thing as a spot light back then. Their main source of artificial light was torches, and flames can't produce a steady or focused enough light source to match the sun.
Yes, maybe with fairly-land scenarios, real world logic can ignore a perfectly valid observation, but then the point isn't worth arguing because you'll just make up whatever little nuance or rule as you go
In short, gtfo
It is an open ended question. There is not one correct answer. There is one answer I came up with, but I'm sure there are others. It is actually quite difficult to prove the spherical shape of the earth without traveling around it at several latitudes and comparing distances, or flying high enough (very high) to observe noticeable curvature. This explains why the flat earth was such a popular model right up until the 1950s.until we telepathically pick your brains for the exact answer you yourself would've provided.
8 light minutes and 5800 K is not impossibly far or impossibly hot lol. In fact you could reach the sun on the space shuttle traveling at its maximum speed wrt earth in about 2/3rds of a year. Also I can make temperatures vastly exceeding 5800 K here on earth with almost any sort of spark generator.
How does the fact that humans couldn't make a spotlight invalidate the argument that the same results could have arisen from a slightly diverging local light source?
By your argument we don't have fusion therefore the light from the sun can't be made from fusion. It'll only be when we develop a consistent source of hot fusion that the sun will be allowed to be fusion powered.
Imagine if you had an experiment that "proved" mobile phones cause brain cancer. But an equally valid interpretation of the results were that they also don't cause brain cancer.
Would you 1) devise an experiment which can actually prove or disprove the hypothesis or 2) continue to claim your experiment proves that mobile phones cause brain cancer?
Imagine if history had taken a different turn. Imagine for example that it was hypothesized that the earth was flat and the sun was a local spotlight, then this experiment was conducted afterwards. They would have concluded that it is a local spotlight... the experiment shows it, does it not? They set out to test their hypothesis with this experiment and it returned a positive result.
I don't know how else to explain to you that this experiment is just a form of confirmation bias. Whatever default hypothesis you held (round or flat) it will confirm that hypothesis. Taken alone is not proof of either position.
It is an open ended question. There is not one correct answer. There is one answer I came up with, but I'm sure there are others. It is actually quite difficult to prove the spherical shape of the earth without traveling around it at several latitudes and comparing distances, or flying high enough (very high) to observe noticeable curvature. This explains why the flat earth was such a popular model right up until the 1950s.
When I said the words "impossibly..." it was actually a joke about your fictional character's level of ignorance, I would have figured you would have picked up on the tone when I also said "big ball of death", but the humor was apparently lost so I digress.
I didn't say the inability to make spot lights invalidated your argument. What I'm saying is that you expect me to explain every aspect of my argument leading up to my final argument, and yet you're not held to the same standards,
such as explaining to me why your characters are ignorant to astronomy facts to which they were historically privy to in the timeframe that I suggested in my last message.
My point isn't that your argument is invalid, but that you're attempting to assert your logic as the supreme logic to this scenario without support of your own, and I believe this is fallacious. It's an appeal to authority, and more egregiously, you're asserting yourself as the authority.
I am glad that you will say your answer isn't the only one. I truly believed that you were dismissing all answers as wrong if they weren't your own answer.
free jim
"To dramatically illustrate this, here’s a time-lapse photo of the Sun’s path through the sky taken during the winter solstice in Fairbanks, Alaska."
Thanks to all the valleys, mountains, etc., the earth is not in fact round. Thus, Jim is doomed.
Well the sun is a big ball of death? That part is perfectly accurate. Trying to approach it without really significant shielding will almost certainly result in death.
This is actually how logic works. The person making the non-intuitive / non-default claim bears the burden of proof. The earth looks flat. From the perspective of people on the ground with limited ability to travel either laterally or vertically there are very few ways to prove that it is not.
In otherwords you're actually attempting to shift the burden of proof. But even if the burden were allowed to be shifted it wouldn't prove a round earth.
Is this unbelievable? From the perspective of a person who has not done any scientific experiments to prove any scientific datum all internally consistent stories that are told to them appear equally plausible. Without actual application of the scientific method, everything is just a competing opinion. You strongly believe the scientific 'consensus' about astronomy, but that is because you were indoctrinated to it. For example had you been educated during the 1800's there's a fair chance you believed the sun ran on coal, ran on fission or was simply a cooling ball. Because you were educated in the 21st century you believe it runs on fusion. But you have no way of verifying this.
Elevating an opinion or a competing model to the status of fact by the coincidence that many other people also believe it is not science. And in fact this is one of the two basic problems we still face in science: confirmation bias and a 'consensus' or 'politically correct model' constantly trumping the scientific method.
Rather than calling it fallacious reasoning you would do better to actually point out fallacies as they are committed. I do not believe I put forward any fallacies. The default position is that the earth is flat, until proven otherwise because this is the direct evidence of the senses. It is up to the person who is proposing the round model to prove everything including any celestial model and respective angles and distances. If you want to test your argument imagine telling it to a 5 year old without using the phrases "because I said so" or "because many people/scientists believe it" or "because someone else did an experiment which proved it". These are argument from authority fallacies.
Poor Jim he was unable to prove to his overlords that the earth is a sphere.
What Jim should have done is thought carefully about the fictional forces produced by a rotating spherical body.
Since Shité is equatorial some of the country is in the northern hemisphere and some is in the southern hemisphere.
If he had built a Foucault pendulum in the north, and one in the south he could demonstrated with that the precession is always reversed across the equator line. After demonstrating this in his first week he could then built an arbitrary number in each hemisphere to demonstrate that it is always the case.
There is no way to explain the opposite precessions across the equator line on a flat earth. The "equator line" on a flat earth is not special, it is just half radius. It would be difficult if not impossible to produce this effect on a flat earth even if you could put whatever machinery you liked under the plane.
[emphasis added]What I'm arguing is that the burden of proof shouldn't be on me to reprove what we understand of history, but for you to prove why we may be mistaken about what people of that age did already understand correctly about the sun as it pertains to this situation. Common knowledge in rhetoric must be proven false if claimed to be false, as I've always learned in my debate classes. I assert the claim that it's common knowledge and widely accepted that astronomy was advanced enough for people of the suggested age to know those facts about the sun which I've stated earlier, validating my experiement
But Jim is so dumb he has yet to know that the Sun is not a spotlight. Why do we get to assume he knows about the "fictional forces produced by a rotating spherical body?"
Like MohtasaUnique was saying, you seem to give yourself the power to dictate this world to fit your answer while with that same power denying that the evidence for others argument is sufficient.
[emphasis added]
These are still fallacious arguments from authority. "Other people believe it" "it's common knowledge" "it's written in a textbook". None of these fallacies would allow you to shift the burden of proof.
If a model or theory differs from the default naive position (evidence of the senses position) then it's always upon you to prove it. Even if its considered common knowledge by everyone around you.
With respect to the spot light, this isn't presenting an alternative model without proof, rather this is presenting an alternative hypothesis which would also fit the data provided. There's an important difference. You were asked to devise a conclusive test. If your results can be interpreted in favour of an alternative then you either have to find a way to disprove that alternative in addition to your test OR find a different test.
I'm not shifting burden of proof with respect to a textbook or because someone said so, there's primary sources to prove the level of education people of the age had about astronomy. These aren't appeals to authority, these are reasonable conclusions I've gathered and can be supported with original documents from those of that time.
Again, my point isn't proving myself from the viewpoint of a person of that time. My point is proving they had their own beliefs that are accurate enough to the truth that it's more reasonable to assume your character's opposition is aware that the sun is in fact a star, and its known properties can in fact prove surface curvature, as opposed to hypothesizing that one could possibly believe the sun was an electrical light, bright enough to illuminate the entire country, located a few meters off the ground.
The alternative hypothesis is discredited with present proof that the sun is not a spot light.
A primary source is exactly an appeal to authority. You are even giving a qualitative assessment of the authority as a prime authority.
Appealing to "primary sources" is not science. The only primary source in science is experiment.
No one said it was electrical. But also can you prove that the sun is 8 light minutes away?
Here's your sticks in the ground method with the alternative local-sun flat plane hypothesis:
![]()
This gives a solar distance of approximately 3000 km. If you were starting from the default null hypothesis that the earth is flat, seeing this experiment would, as I pointed out earlier, confirm your hypothesis. The conclusion that the sun is 5000 km up and 50km wide is quite plausible for a flat plane model.
I don't understand your criticism that they should have "known" the sun was 8 light minutes away. They don't know that anymore than they know the earth is round. The only way to show them is with a conclusive experiment.
The flat earth is particularly interesting as a thought problem because it is such a good test of critical thinking. You are not able to simply "cite sources"/rely on authority. Personally I think science graduates should be required to take some sort of critical thinking test before being allowed to graduate.
I've repeated this multiple times. Your characters SHOULD be privy to enough astronomy to know the sun isn't a spot light, so there's no point in arguing further because you are intent on maintaining that your alternative universe unreasonably believes the sun is a spot light. If that's the case then you win, and your earth is flat, and the sun is a spot light
They're not part of western culture. You haven't explained why they would believe western astronomy when they don't even believe the earth is round.
You're arguing about the plausibility of the level of skepticism the fictional race of the communist Shiteians have for western thought. lol.
Go to the flat earth society website (there's actually quite a few but I'm sure you'll find one by googling) and argue with them for about 10 minutes then come back here and tell me that this mindset is unrealistic given that these people "are privy to enough astronomy to know the sun isn't a spotlight."