"Transgender" = mentally ill

At 1st I was like "who is this kiro guy and how could he have been a sectional mod" and then I read "previously known as ghast".

Seriously, you are so out of touch with reality that it's scary. Your replies are no more than a monkey thowing his shit around and claiming that he won the debate. Try to remember that some people read these topics to get some relavant information and please try to avoid from posting 2 pages of shit just to argee with the argument you were argueing against. I wish a mod gave you a warning for this load of spam that you created.

The whole idea behind genders is stupid. People who argue for genders of any sort should be dismissed on sight. Let's just stick with sex and be done with it. Knowing someones sex gives us a lot of info about that person, knowing someones gender is just a waste of time and resources. Yes, transgender or any other gender = mentally ill.

Well first off, no one has claimed or announced they have won this meaningless debate over symbolism. Secondly, you're doing the same thing you're seemingly irate over. Lastly, just because you think the term gender is stupid, doesn't give validation to your opinion. I could get into the list of non-binary genders, but your brain might explode, as it probably does regularly, just from a glance at the way you type. If you want to discuss the topic at hand, I'll be glad to reply.

 

[Logic]

Well first off, no one has claimed or announced they have won this meaningless debate over symbolism. Secondly, you're doing the same thing you're seemingly irate over. Lastly, just because you think the term gender is stupid, doesn't give validation to your opinion. I could get into the list of non-binary genders, but your brain might explode, as it probably does regularly, just from a glance at the way you type. If you want to discuss the topic at hand, I'll be glad to reply.

Please do tell me how we benefit from knowing a person's gender. Sex, weight, race etc are very useful in medicine for example. I just don't see a need for knowing someone's gender.

 

Please do tell me how we benefit from knowing a person's gender. Sex, weight, race etc are very useful in medicine for example. I just don't see a need for knowing someone's gender.

Gender and sex are interchangeable for the most part, at least in regards to this bathroom situation. There are only two genders in this instance, male and female.

You're basically asking, "How do we benefit from knowing a person's sex?".

 

[Logic]

Gender and sex are interchangeable for the most part, at least in regards to this bathroom situation. There are only two genders in this instance, male and female.

We were talking about gender, don't change the subject. If you need to ask why doctors need to know someone's sex then you are either stupid or stupid. Stick to gender.

 

We were talking about gender, don't change the subject. If you need to ask why doctors need to know someone's sex then you are either stupid or stupid. Stick to gender.

The subject hasn't changed. This thread is about allowing transgenders to use whichever bathroom they feel they most identify with. Read the original post of this thread and you'd understand. It's funny because you were the one who was irate about this thread going off topic when it actually hasn't.

To branch off that, gender refers to constructed roles, behaviours, activities, and attributes that a given society considers appropriate for men and women.

 

[Logic]

The subject hasn't changed. This thread is about allowing transgenders to use whichever bathroom they feel they most identify with. Read the original post of this thread and you'd understand. It's funny because you were the one who was irate about this thread going off topic when it actually hasn't.

To branch off that, gender refers to constructed roles, behaviours, activities, and attributes that a given society considers appropriate for men and women.

For me gender is basicly a pile of horseshit. I asked you, what do we benefit from knowing a person's gender. If you don't know then say so. Stop beating around the bush and answer the question. I argue that sex is enough for bathrooms and everything else that's related to the sexes.

 

For me gender is basicly a pile of horseshit. I asked you, what do we benefit from knowing a person's gender. If you don't know then say so. Stop beating around the bush and answer the question. I argue that sex is enough for bathrooms and everything else that's related to the sexes.

The question itself is weird and somewhat of a conundrum. If you know a person's sex, what benefit is there to knowing their gender? Gender is pretty much self-identification, it has no biological purpose as I've said repeatedly, it's more superficial in comparison to sex. Gender roles do play a significant part in today's society however.

 

[Logic]

The question itself is weird and somewhat of a conundrum. If you know a person's sex, what benefit is there to knowing their gender? Gender is pretty much self-identification, it has no biological purpose as I've said repeatedly, it's more superficial in comparison to sex. Gender roles do play a significant part in today's society however.

Why not call them sex roles? Sounds about right and gets things done. Gender just confuses the shit out of people and has no real value. A better way to say it is that I have not read or heard any arguments to why we need all these genders other than to sue people for not using the correct gender pronouns (which is fucking insane).

 

Why not call them sex roles? Sounds about right and gets things done. Gender just confuses the shit out of people and has no real value. A better way to say it is that I have not read or heard any arguments to why we need all these genders other than to sue people for not using the correct gender pronouns (which is fucking insane).

Because sex doesn't refer to the social constructs of a male and female.

 

[kmjt]

Because sex doesn't refer to the social constructs of a male and female.

Uh yeah it does. You are blind if you can't see that society influences how a male and female act.

nvm thought you said gender

 

[Logic]

Because sex doesn't refer to the social constructs of a male and female.

Why can't sex refer to a social construct? Pretty sure I have read about studies made on newborns where scientist claim that the differences between sexes kick it without outer influence.

 

[Xier0]

Well first off, no one has claimed or announced they have won this meaningless debate over symbolism.

Absolutely nothing about this is symbolic. It is strictly practical - real Male and Female bathrooms.

Because sex doesn't refer to the social constructs of a male and female.

There's no reason for bathrooms to be separated by social constructs. I provided the reason bathrooms are separated by sex, and you agreed. So I don't know why you keep using this term "Social construct" to decide how bathrooms are separated since they are separated by the biological construct of sex.

Gender is pretty much self-identification, it has no biological purpose as I've said repeatedly, it's more superficial in comparison to sex. Gender roles do play a significant part in today's society however.

They don't play any part in bathrooms. Those are sex segregated, not gender segregated, because there is no reason to have bathrooms segregated by self identification.

 

Why can't sex refer to a social construct? Pretty sure I have read about studies made on newborns where scientist claim that the differences between sexes kick it without outer influence.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blo...erence-vs-gender-difference-oh-im-so-confused

Absolutely nothing about this is symbolic. It is strictly practical - real Male and Female bathrooms.


There's no reason for bathrooms to be separated by social constructs. I provided the reason bathrooms are separated by sex, and you agreed. So I don't know why you keep using this term "Social construct" to decide how bathrooms are separated since they are separated by the biological construct of sex.



They don't play any part in bathrooms. Those are sex segregated, not gender segregated, because there is no reason to have bathrooms segregated by self identification.

A sign isn't symbolic?

Who said bathrooms are separated by social constructs?

Again, either you're trolling, have short term memory, or really dense. You're repeating the same arguments I've responded to over and over again, hoping the response changes so you can further a discussion which already ended. If you want an answer, read the thread over. If you want to discuss something that hasn't been discussed already, I'll happily reply.

 

[JSand]

I think this thread has clearly taken a turn that was unintended in my opinion. The OP posted a link to an article where the Doctor depicted transgenders as mentally ill.... Instead everyone is talking about bathroom rights...

 

[Xier0]

I think this thread has clearly taken a turn that was unintended in my opinion. The OP posted a link to an article where the Doctor depicted transgenders as mentally ill.... Instead everyone is talking about bathroom rights...

Please read the OP before posting.

http://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2015/06/15145/

Personally, I agree with everything stated. Being "transgender" is indeed a mental illness, and should be treated as such, not appeased, as we've been seeing lately in the media with the "transgender" bathrooms.

 

[JSand]

Please read the OP before posting.

Did you read the entire sentence or cherry pick what you wanted or found relevant like you do with....... Everything?

Clearly the focus of the entire post OP made was regarding the article.... It's even in the title and i bet neither of you even clicked on the article.

 

[Logic]

Did you read the entire sentence or cherry pick what you wanted or found relevant like you do with....... Everything?

Clearly the focus of the entire post OP made was regarding the article.... It's even in the title and i bet neither of you even clicked on the article.

Public bathrooms play a huge role in the whole trans movement/discussion so it's more than justified to discuss it. I'd argue that it's the main issue that "trans" people have atm.

 

Personally, I agree with everything stated. Being "transgender" is indeed a mental illness, and should be treated as such, not appeased, as we've been seeing lately in the media with the "transgender" bathrooms.

and I agree with you.

Notice how you won't address my claim that the state of being a male is having a penis, and the state of being a female is having a vagina

I like your defnition man and agree with you.

 

To be "transgendered" implies a certain detachment from reality. A mental illness would be one way to put it certainly.

I'm not going to hate someone because of what they do with their own body, but I won't be going out of my way to facilitate their fantasies either.

Spot on

I think it's completely fucking madness to appease this bull-shit. I dont give two fucks what you identify yourself as. If you started with a penis then use the fucking men's room. Ill give you guys a true life example. One of my best friends brother is gay/transgender. He moved to California and started doing drag shows. My buddies family is ok with it and even proud of him to some degree I believe. The problem only occurred when Anthony's brother came back home. In celebration they all went out to eat. (whole family, granny included) The grandma decides she needs to use the restroom and Anthony's brother goes with her. In shock they watched as he walked into the women's restroom right behind the granny... How in the fuck is that okay? How is a man supposed to watch his older brother take a piss with his grandma? It goes against nature. Needless to say a huge fight erupted and Anthony broke his brothers nose. I personally dont think it's okay for men to use women's bathrooms or vice versa. You can dress like a woman, chop your dick off and, suck dick. Just stay the fuck out of the women's bathroom. Some how I blame this on the Kardashians and what they turned Bruce Jenner into. Giving a world class MALE athlete the woman of the year award. Way to go America...

 

[PremiumGold]

Transgender is totally a mental illness. I have no hatred towards gays or anything of the such I just think it's a bit retarded to go full force and throw in a transgender restroom.. I mean come on dude. I think the bathrooms should be labeled "Penis" "Vagina"