• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Why is Suicide illegal?

If they want to, sure. Yet, I thought you were against suicide?
Click to expand...

I am against just killing yourself.
My mate hung himself and noone knows why - its that type of suicide that im against.
However, if you have a cronic illness and your in alot of pain, injecting needles, etc. then I think that death could be the best way to put you out of pain.

I believe in an afterlife - sorry - so im ok with death.
We put dogs down because they are injured, why not put a human down because they will suffer for the remainder of their life?

Death cures nothing. What if the cure for AIDS is five years away? It very well could be, you know.
Click to expand...

Yes, there is the possibility that a cure could come along, but my mates dad has been holding on for maybe 8 years maybe more now.
He hasnt got aids, he has a lung or liver problem - im not sure.
He was going to just die because he didnt want to put his family through it all anymore, the financial stress added to the emotional stress, and he felt his family should go through it all.
The biggest break through they had was when he had a surgery to make him live another 4-6 years and that was a major thing (because he got to see blake go into highschool, etc.)

But seriously, 8 years or something, and no cure.
There are some things that medical science just cant cure.

I dont know how to put my thoughts into words now, Im sorry if i repeated myself, etc.
 
My mother-in-law killed herself a while back. She and my dad had a fight and he slept in the car. When he went back inside the house, he found her.

From this point of view, there is a part of me saying how wrong killing yourself is, and how many people she hurt by doing that.

Then there is the logical/rational part of me saying the opposite. If I had not had that experience then I would most likely say "Suicide is a choice".

I therefor, will have to side with reason. Although there can be major side-affects, I believe that it is your own desicion and that no body should take that from you.

THIS IS ALSO THE MOST SELFISH THING YOU CAN DO if you know people care for you.
 
assassinX09 said:
tehe if their stupid enough to try they deserve it prob or their just looking for attention not sure why its illegal
Click to expand...

first off try not to leave half-assed posts,

the arguement is that a person should have the right to do what ever he/she wants to there body

and the oposing argument is to put it bluntly that murder is muder and that there is no way around it
 
im sorry i was tlaking about the for suicide being legal because according to some religions the body you have is gods n that kinda stuff
 
assassinX09 said:
im sorry i was tlaking about the for suicide being legal because according to some religions the body you have is gods n that kinda stuff
Click to expand...

so that would make it even more of murder?

but bringing in religon into the equation would make it even more interesting considering you have a right to religeon expression in america.
 
They own the country, i think they have the right to be able to do what they desire and if they are worried about people feeling insecure, they might suggest for you to go to a psychiatrist but most of all they won't force you to NOT do anything you want so the point still remains that they shouldn't tell you what not to do, if you feel ready for it.
 
Yadkef said:
They own the country, i think they have the right to be able to do what they desire and if they are worried about people feeling insecure, they might suggest for you to go to a psychiatrist but most of all they won't force you to NOT do anything you want so the point still remains that they shouldn't tell you what not to do, if you feel ready for it.
Click to expand...

No government owns the country. It merely governs over it. The country always belongs to the people. Always.
 
Generally speaking there is no 'law' that prevents you from killing yourself, it would be foolish to classify attempted suicide as a crime (unless you recklessly endanger others) since it would only exacerbate the person's problems.

In the United States of America it is not illegal to commit suicide. None of the fifty states has a law which makes suicide illegal. No federal law prohibits suicide.

You cannot get arrested, fined, or whatever else you might think. Rather, the police have the right to place you in protective custody and they have the right to prevent a suicide.
 
government can be taken away, and also given.

no one owns the land besides people, and if they wanted the land, they coulud easily take it from government.
 
it is illegal in a lot more places then just the US and it is illegal beacus as state in the official law, anyone who has the ability to kill them selves is not in their right mind and therefore does not have the right to make desicions for them selves, and it isn't like you will go to jail just therapy.
 
GhostEntity said:
it is illegal in a lot more places then just the US and it is illegal beacus as state in the official law, anyone who has the ability to kill them selves is not in their right mind and therefore does not have the right to make desicions for them selves, and it isn't like you will go to jail just therapy.
Click to expand...

People who want to commit suicide aren't necessarily insane. It is possible to be perfectly sane and want to end your own life.
 
It is not illegal to attempt suicide.

GhostEntity said:
it is illegal in a lot more places then just the US and it is illegal beacus as state in the official law, anyone who has the ability to kill them selves is not in their right mind and therefore does not have the right to make desicions for them selves, and it isn't like you will go to jail just therapy.
Click to expand...

Read my post.

Dorito said:
Generally speaking there is no 'law' that prevents you from killing yourself, it would be foolish to classify attempted suicide as a crime (unless you recklessly endanger others) since it would only exacerbate the person's problems.

In the United States of America it is not illegal to commit suicide. None of the fifty states has a law which makes suicide illegal. No federal law prohibits suicide.

You cannot get arrested, fined, or whatever else you might think. Rather, the police have the right to place you in protective custody and they have the right to prevent a suicide.
Click to expand...
 
Originally Posted by Dorito View Post
Generally speaking there is no 'law' that prevents you from killing yourself, it would be foolish to classify attempted suicide as a crime (unless you recklessly endanger others) since it would only exacerbate the person's problems.

In the United States of America it is not illegal to commit suicide. None of the fifty states has a law which makes suicide illegal. No federal law prohibits suicide.

You cannot get arrested, fined, or whatever else you might think. Rather, the police have the right to place you in protective custody and they have the right to prevent a suicide.



http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Why_is_it_illegal_for_people_to_kill_themselves

KUDOS for copying from wiki.answers bro without researching it yourself. Suicide is illegal in both Dakotas, Washington, New Jersey, Nevada, and Oklahoma.
 
Translash said:
Originally Posted by Dorito View Post
Generally speaking there is no 'law' that prevents you from killing yourself, it would be foolish to classify attempted suicide as a crime (unless you recklessly endanger others) since it would only exacerbate the person's problems.

In the United States of America it is not illegal to commit suicide. None of the fifty states has a law which makes suicide illegal. No federal law prohibits suicide.

You cannot get arrested, fined, or whatever else you might think. Rather, the police have the right to place you in protective custody and they have the right to prevent a suicide.



http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Why_is_it_illegal_for_people_to_kill_themselves

KUDOS for copying from wiki.answers bro without researching it yourself. Suicide is illegal in both Dakotas, Washington, New Jersey, Nevada, and Oklahoma.
Click to expand...

Actually I did change a few words and maybe add a sentence, anyways, that's besides the point.

Kudos? Kudos to you for sourcing my information...wait, who cares again? Right...

You tell me to research my own information, yet can't even source your own?
 
Im not positive, but I do believe that in some european countrys (Holland perhaps?) assisted suicide is legal.

don't quote me on this, you could prob find a better answer on google.
 
Where is euthanasia and assisted suicide legal?

Only three places besides Oregon openly and legally authorize assisted suicide:

The Netherlands:


Introduced specific legislation to legalize assisted suicide and active euthanasia in 2002, but the country's courts have permitted them there since 1984.
The Dutch laid out narrow guidelines for doctors: The patient, who must be suffering unbearably and have no hope of improvement, must ask to die. The patient must clearly understand the condition and prognosis and a second doctor must agree with the decision to help the patient die.

Belgium:


Legalized euthanasia in 2002, but the laws seem to encompass assisted suicide as well.
Two doctors must be involved, as well as a psychologist if the patient's competency is in doubt.
The doctor and patient negotiate whether death is to be by lethal injection or prescribed overdose.

Switzerland:


Has allowed physician and non-physician assisted suicide since 1941, but prohibits euthanasia.
Three right-to-die organizations in the country help terminally ill people by providing counselling and lethal drugs.
Death by injection is banned.
Click to expand...

Source : http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/assistedsuicide/

Personaly, I have never experienced anyone who commited suicide, but if it was someone I knew I believe I might feel responcible. If it's extreamly unexpected I think it's wrong. But if someone is in so much pain they don't want to live anymore, Like they're going to die anyways - I would be okay with that. I just don't think that people should be offing themselves for attention thats all.

So pretty much I would agree with the method of The Netherlands.

Edit: I appoligize for the double post.
 
statistically in america more women try to commit suicide... but more men actually succeed (since they often will use weapons as opposed to women who more often use pills)
 
Is it really illegal though? I mean how are you going to get punished by the authorities after you have committed it lol?

Don't say god will punish you. Thanks
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Runescape Gamblingrunescape gambling
Back
Top