Okay, as promised, here is my review and short summary of this memoir.
Rating: 9/10
This was an absolutely delightful read. Dibbell starts as a normal player, much like most of us, and eventually becomes fascinated with the trade of virtual goods. Throughout this memoir, Dibbell talks about his life as a writer for Wired and his brief, yet deeply insightful, journey into the bizarre and incredible world of real money trade that all of us at Sythe are so familiar with. Throughout this journey, you will learn about some of the history of real money trade in Ultima Online and some other games back before 2004 including stories about Chinese gold farms (some perhaps mythical and some indeed real including one mentioned in a New York Times article
here), lots of botting and the intense drama between competing gold farmers, major glitches, some major gold store owners (including Brock Pierce of IGE, once one of the largest virtual goods dealers in the world), as well as insight into the academic world of analyzing these games.
Dibbell’s goal is to make more money in a year trading virtual goods on websites like EBay and his website Play Money than he has ever made as a professional writer. He does not achieve this goal, but he comes pretty far. He does pretty darn good considering he started from scratch and eventually ended up among some of the best traders. I’ll leave it to you to read the book and see just how it all plays out.
The memoir is concluded with a rather amusing recount of Dibbell’s conversations with IRS people as they try to figure out just how virtual games should be handled when it comes to taxes. Spoiler alert: the IRS was completely baffled.
There are some tangents that Dibbell goes on where he explores philosophical implications of what he is experiencing and pondering along his journey. In my opinion, some of these are good and some would have been better left out. If you don’t like this sort of stuff, don’t worry about it. You will still enjoy the majority of the book.
Overall, this book is great. Definitely worth reading! It definitely makes you think about the relationship between work and play (a central theme in his book), something I'm sure many of us have pondered at one point or another.
To clarify, Dibbell did not lose his wife because of his trading business. This unfortunate event just happened to occur at the same time as this project of his.