• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

[DENIED] 1Year Account responsibility

Status
Not open for further replies.
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
6 months, take it or leave it. 1 month isn't long enough nor is 3 months personally, and 1 year is too long. 6 months is the middle ground of all of these. That's what I got for this.
6 Months is still a lot better than what we have right now. The reason why I have chosen 1year instead of 6 months, is because paypals chargeback period is 180 days, and a lot of resold accounts are bought via paypal. So after 180 days seller knows nothing will happen to him, which still puts this period in the "risk zone".
 
Last edited:
Shuppet
Starmie
Pidgeotto
Wurmple
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Pokémon Trainer
March Madness
Poképedia
Discord Verified
Nitro Booster
Easter 2023
The Glizz
Two Factor Authentication User
Easter 2025
Valentine's Day 2025
Halloween 2024
St. Patrick's Day 2025
Christmas 2024
Heidy
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Lawrence
Tons of Damage
Summer 2025
Easter 2022
Verified Ironman
6-12 months is quite a lot honestly. I don't think a certain amount of time can be set for just any account. I think there are two types of accounts that are sold:
1. Ex-personal accounts. These accounts were mostly played by the original owner. The OO often has his email already connected to the account and might even have some payments made with real life money.
2. Accounts made for sale. These accounts were just trained to a certain point and then put up for sale. They often have no email connected and the membership is often redeemed by bonds.

Account number one is, as good as, always recoverable.
Account number two is often much hard to recover. In my personal experience the time that has passed since the new owner has the account and what the new owner has done on the account has a huge impact here. If the new owner has made real life payments and changed the passwords a couple of time, there is new information added to the account that the OO has no access to. Just a few weeks or maybe up to a few months the OO can often still recover, but as time passes there's a point where the new owner is considered the OO by Jagex.

I have sold accounts to user over a year ago that are now (nearly)impossible to recover.

I think the main problem right now is that users buy accounts from random people and then resell them and hope it won't get recovered the first month. I haven't seen a report about account recovery from a trusted seller since Azie.

What I propose is that customers are given an option. They can either get their own email attached to the account and accept that the seller is no longer responsible for it, or they choose that the seller will keep his/her email attached to the account ( the seller will only receive a link to change the password and can set up Authenticator ). In this second case, a seller should offer a lifetime warranty ( or at least a very long period of time ).

I hope this information helps and I appreciate everyone thinking of a good solution.
 
Brawlhalla Champion
Nitro Booster
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
I support. I think a year is to long but I do think we could increase it from a month.
 
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
Account recoveries are almost impossible to police. This is an issue with Jagex's recovery system, not with Sythe, and I don't think changing the seller responsibility period will fix things.

That said, I wouldn't mind increasing it a bit (3 months?), but if people are willing to buy accounts with a shorter guarantee, I don't see why Sythe should prevent them from doing so. We are, after all, a platform for connecting people.
 
Pool Shark
Verified Ironman
I haven't read the whole thread, just your post.

I support the 1 year time frame however sometimes its hard to get a recovery on an account that you started sometimes its just difficult i know people who are original owners and sometimes cant get an account back.

1 Year should only stand if there has been one transaction and all recovery responsibility should be dropped if the purchaser sells the account on, because quite frankly you don't know where what or who's hands it has gone to and you also don't know if the purchaser wants to just get onto the account to raid it after reselling.

I believe the caveat should be as above if it was to extend.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Discord Verified
Christmas 2018
Gohan has AIDS
I agree that 1 month is to short.

However I do not support the 12 months,
For example I made an account for a worker to train only last month, I noted the first password and the creation date and did not use a VPN as it was only a couple accounts I was making, unfortunately the worker got the account banned, it took me 10+ attempts to recover the account and that was using the same info everytime, it just so happened one of the attempts finally worked, jagexs recovery system is abismal, from my own personal experience its as if the recovery goes through 2 stages, 1) an automated denial response, 2) it passed the 1st stage then goes onto manual rewiew, now that manual review (from my experience) is either accepted or declined by the Jmod reviewing it.


I completely agree that one month is too soon, I was good friends with someone who was recently banned who used to buy accounts then sell them off and he definitely abused this 1 month responsibly rule indeed not intentionaly but even he knew those accounts could be recovered at anytime.


The only accounts I am now selling are accounts with false email logins (never had a registered email). Now customers buying those accounts know that the accounts only ever had one password and they can easily check the creation date with hans, if we changed this rule too even 4 months+, what is too stop a customer from wanting the money ney back and submitting a false claim that the account has been recovered? In jagexs view this guy has been paying, he knows the first password, creation date and is the only person to know ANY transaction Id's ect. I mean we can't even buy the bonds with a Cc on an acc with no registered email it won't go through, I think this is something that needs to be thought about carefully as to not fuck over account sellers in the future.
 
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Two Factor Authentication User
Discord Verified
Toast Wallet User
May the 4th Be With You
HamSanta
Halloween 2025
Valentine's Day 2025
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Community Development Team Member
Community Participant
Top Striker
Pool Shark
Battleship Champion
March Madness
Rust Player
Sandbox Participant
Donor Lounge Participant
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Valentine's Day 2026
Christmas 2025
No support, it's fine as it is.

The probability of a seller successfully recovering an account decreases over the time, so you have to take into accounting that sellers will fail to recover more accounts on average.
When you increase the minimum recovery responsibility, some sellers will either quit the market, or increase the price (to cover for the increased refund rate).
When there's less, let's say "honorable sellers" the safety of the account market will go down, because you only take away "honorable sellers", but the number of "scum sellers" is not affected.
Furthermore, because of higher prices of "honorable sellers", more buyers will be inclined to buy from "scum sellers", who really couldn't care less about increased recovery responsibility, because they don't plan to stick around that long.

Conclusion: Overprotecting the account market will not get you your desired outcome, quite the opposite.
 
Charizard
Poképedia
Pokémon Trainer
Summer 2025
Tier 1 Prizebox
Tier 2 Prizebox
May the 4th Be With You
Hoover
Verified Ironman
Homosex
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Pizza Muncher
Doge
Torchbearer 2016
Easter 2020
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
I support this 100%. The claims that recovery become less each month that goes by is false. Proven by a banned seller in my facebook group, even with the change of ip and location the account can still 100% be recovered by the owner as long as they have the right details regardless of time it was gone from them. He was able to yank back accounts sold over 1 year ago on first attempt from his new house 500 miles away from account creation IP. Allowing only 1 month opens a door to scamming. With stricter guidelines and more enforcement, it could 100% be done to create a truly safe market.

I would add that recovery test are a must and selling of an account without login email should not be allowed. (unless unregistered to a fake domain) And yes the login email matters. As if you spam request to get account locked the system 110% will default the account to login email as a safety net. I have been able to get my accounts i buy back 100% of time due to owning the login email.
 
I feel like increasing the amount of responsibility time would increase the cost of accounts. I don’t know how dramatic the increase would be however.

One year might be a bit to long while 1 month might be a bit short. I really think it should remain the same for now but perhaps maybe increase the punishments for recovered accounts etc.
 
Shuppet
Starmie
Pidgeotto
Wurmple
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Pokémon Trainer
March Madness
Poképedia
Discord Verified
Nitro Booster
Easter 2023
The Glizz
Two Factor Authentication User
Easter 2025
Valentine's Day 2025
Halloween 2024
St. Patrick's Day 2025
Christmas 2024
Heidy
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Lawrence
Tons of Damage
Summer 2025
Easter 2022
Verified Ironman
I feel like increasing the amount of responsibility time would increase the cost of accounts. I don’t know how dramatic the increase would be however.

One year might be a bit to long while 1 month might be a bit short. I really think it should remain the same for now but perhaps maybe increase the punishments for recovered accounts etc.
I agree with this as well. As @BlackBlasses already said, legit sellers will have to increase their prices to compensate for the % of accounts they can not recover. Scammers on the other hand don't care about the recovery period, as they would have planned on taking back the account anyway.
 
WoW Classic
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
I agree with this as well. As @BlackBlasses already said, legit sellers will have to increase their prices to compensate for the % of accounts they can not recover. Scammers on the other hand don't care about the recovery period, as they would have planned on taking back the account anyway.
You're right,

What would happen is #1 people would buy accounts to bot farm, claim account was hacked once recovered the user would claim you got it banned yada yada.

#2 people get bored quick sometimes and will go "I can't access the account the user recovered it I dont feel safe" then youd be stuck having to refund because they had buyers remorse.

#3 a year long worry that at any point a client can bust your balls.

However if you're an honest provider even 1 month wont matter too much you'll do what you can to help unlock, recover etc if a client needs the help.

Even if you aren't able to do so you tried at least.

Yellow Hat
 
why is it ok to recover accounts that have been sold at all, no matter how long its been?

1 month, 1 year. Why are they not responsible?

Nobody said it was. Also, the sellers are held responsible up until X amount of time stated in their ToS.
 
Gohan has AIDS
Snowflake
Verified Diamond
Trole
Two Factor Authentication User
Voluntaryist
Why can't I hold all of these feels?
Dunce
Lawrence
Hey... this isnt a fun rank
Carrot
Halloween 2013
Valentine's Singing Competition Winner
Hoover
Homosex
Friendship is Magic
Nitro Booster
Potamus
Cook
Village Drunk
Gooby
Gracious
Cool Kid
Pokémon Trainer
STEVE
Spyro
Candy Man
Account sales are inherently risky. As long as the buyer and seller agree to terms, Sythe is going to a provide a market for people to trade even if the goods being traded are high-risk.

The one-month recovery period rule is in place as a minimum requirement; users are allowed to go above and beyond that if they so desire.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top