Honestly updating would be very worth it. No more waits for custom code since everything is already in a mod, plus regular updates and support for those mods. My Activity hasn't worked for years and it took a long time to get NextGen off its feet too. Honestly, losing traffic for a week or so and pruning some of the useless shit we've already got would be worth it.
Think of it this way: you're working with a programmer who refuses to use anything but VB6. It's outdated, deprecated, and just about useless. You have to custom-write everything to be compatible with modern systems.
If Matthew feels like dedicating the time to write a thanks mod and an alternative to iTrader, I really do think it should be done. Otherwise, we should go back up the updating tree.