• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

[SYTHE / N4N0] Decision on restitutions please

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dial

Experienced Web Developer

$200 USD Donor New
Pirate
PHP Programmers
Joined
Jul 12, 2010
Sythe Gold
126
Messages
5,739
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
Hi Richard,

I was just informed that even though I specifically asked about this before my pardon, and then was pardoned for it, I am still expected to pay the restitution to N4n0 of $250 or can face being banned on Sythe, again. I would like to ask for this to be re-considered as I do not find that anything I did resulted in $250 worth of damages to N4n0. I was not involved in the hacking or the sharing outside of the chat, merely in the discussion.

This is getting a bit ridiculous with this restitution. Why did no one have to pay it before you did the carousel results? Why was it placed all of a sudden at that time? Why was I successfully pardoned without having to pay it?

I will not be paying my restitution. I tried to fight it, and I thought that's exactly what my pardon was for. If I am forced to pay it by either N4n0 or yourself, then I will unfortunately just have to accept the ban, though that is not what I want.

I feel that N4n0 is using this against me and it almost seems like blackmail ("we can settle your debt in private" and "I'll think about dropping it, not sure yet"). I was obviously unbanned for a reason, and was successfully pardoned, so why is this still being held against me?

I know you support double jeopardy in real life, why not on here as well? As a matter of fact... In real life if you are pardoned for a crime or found not guilty, must you still pay the restitution?

Pardons are also not allowed to be conditional per the pardon rules (unless you are overruling them - which obviously is up to you). I am currently being given the condition of an unban only if I pay now.

[2014-06-13 8:43:00 PM] Mike Mersereau: oh
[2014-06-13 8:43:09 PM] Mike Mersereau: you think if YT buys Twitch it'll go to shit?
[2014-06-13 8:43:17 PM] Rye: I think that was a rumor
[2014-06-13 8:43:20 PM] Mike Mersereau: oh good
[2014-06-13 8:43:40 PM] Rye: I doubt that'll happen, and if it does, there will probably be some legal recourse slowing it down
[2014-06-13 8:44:22 PM] Rye: No doubt there will be some monopolization claims put into play
[2014-06-13 8:44:54 PM] Mike Mersereau: mhm I suppose
[2014-06-13 8:45:41 PM] Mike Mersereau: Anyway, going to buy some supper. Ttyl.
[2014-06-13 8:45:51 PM] Rye: Peace out man
[2014-06-13 8:45:55 PM] Mike Mersereau: also
[2014-06-13 8:46:03 PM] Mike Mersereau: my recent posts in feedback and shit
[2014-06-13 8:46:28 PM] Mike Mersereau: don't take to heart. I'm trying to post constructive stuff now and not attack anyone, just debate professionally instead.
[2014-06-13 8:46:41 PM] Mike Mersereau: still have a few slip ups where I might say something hurtful here and there
[2014-06-13 8:46:44 PM] Mike Mersereau: but I'm trying. (worry)
[2014-06-13 8:47:17 PM] Rye: Nah man, all good
[2014-06-13 8:47:24 PM] Rye: Though that reminds me
[2014-06-13 8:47:55 PM] Rye: In regards to the restitution, sythe's told me I'm still entitled to such. And to let you know now, it's a though that still lingers in the back of my mind.
[2014-06-13 8:48:24 PM] Mike Mersereau: I thought the pardon meant that I was relieved of the debt?
[2014-06-13 8:48:46 PM] Rye: Richard thinks otherwise.
[2014-06-13 8:48:51 PM] Mike Mersereau: Okay
[2014-06-13 8:49:40 PM] Rye: Me: Which speaking of, Dialatic was pardoned w/o paying compensation
Richard : I'd go chase him up for that
[2014-06-13 8:50:49 PM] Mike Mersereau: I was under the impression that the pardon was me being forgiven for my actions, therefore no restitution. I was unable to pay that before, and still am. So unfortunately I'd take the ban for it if it came to that. (worry)
[2014-06-13 8:51:16 PM] Rye: Well, it's something that we may be able to work out on private terms.
[2014-06-13 8:51:44 PM] Mike Mersereau: As I said, I thought it was worked out. I can't pay that man.
[2014-06-13 8:51:54 PM] Mike Mersereau: If you have to re-ban me then I understand but like, I thought this was over. :/
[2014-06-13 8:56:29 PM] Mike Mersereau: Ryan, I respectfully ask you to either please pardon the "debt", or ban me if you so choose. I can't have this keep being brought up into the future. I still don't think I did anything wrong worth $250 other than what we talked about, and will not be paying it. If I am required to pay it, then I refuse.
[2014-06-13 8:59:00 PM] Rye: Understood, I'll get back to you on it soon. I still want to think on it a little. This discussion w/ sythe just took place yesterday so it's something that I haven't put a lot of attention towards just yet, though I'll probably end up just overlooking it.
[2014-06-13 9:00:12 PM] Mike Mersereau: Okay. I would like a response soon please so I don't have to keep worrying about it. If you pardon it, please do it through Richard and have him PM me saying that I am not in debt with you and it has been pardoned. Otherwise I will know you are keeping it if I see a ban screen.
[2014-06-13 9:01:07 PM] Rye: Go have your supper man. I'm gonna go lay back down and prep myself for a 24 hr stream.
[2014-06-13 9:01:18 PM] Mike Mersereau: Alright see ya. I'll message you later.
[2014-06-13 9:28:59 PM] Mike Mersereau: back btw
[2014-06-13 9:40:37 PM] Mike Mersereau: I'd like you to make a decision please. I'm not going through this again dude.
[2014-06-13 9:41:20 PM] Mike Mersereau: It's not fair, and just seems like blackmail that you hold it over my head.
[12:00:44 AM] Mike Mersereau: gonna go right to Richard with this because it's ridiculous man

Please re-consider this restitution on any of us - we were not responsible for the leaking of his images.

Note that the topic was brought up by Ryan as I was talking to him about completely unrelated things (a normal conversation).
 
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe RSPS Player
Two Factor Authentication User
In Memory of Jon
Christmas 2015
Doge
Halloween 2013
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Off Topic Participant
Gohan has AIDS
Heidy
Lawrence
PHP Shit Show 2k26
I agree this is a ridiculous situation, he was told he was allowed to pardon and have it accepted without paying the arbitrary $ amount in restitution. He's jumped through hoops to get unbanned, and it should stay that way. If you have a problem with that tell off your staff..

N4N0 is just fucking money hungry "ooh its all up to richard" and then basically begging for the money.
 
Though Richard never gave his final input when you asked him before you made your pardon, you were pardoned for which you were cleared of all your wrongdoings...

You shouldn't have to pay.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
Though Richard never gave his final input when you asked him before you made your pardon, you were pardoned for which you were cleared of all your wrongdoings...

You need to have paid all restitution before you can be pardoned. In my pardon I specifically said it had to be cleared with Richard before I was unbanned. I was pardoned anyway, giving me the assumption that I was cleared of all wrongdoing and no longer had to pay a restitution.
 
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Sythe Awards 2010 Winner
Gohan has AIDS
Discord Verified
Discord Voice
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Rust Player
Shitting Rainbow
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
pay him or your ass is grass homie, real talk

shouldnt be like it is, but it do
 
Did Richard post his response on your pardon? Seeing as though the mods, globals, Roary and N4n0 messaged Richard. Did that response from Richard get added to the thread of your pardon prior to you getting unbanned?

The restitution/carousel was Richard's idea, not N4N0's.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
Did Richard post his response on your pardon? Seeing as though the mods, globals, Roary and N4n0 messaged Richard. Did that response from Richard get added to the thread of your pardon prior to you getting unbanned?

The restitution/carousel was Richard's idea, not N4N0's.

No he didn't. I was hoping he'd get to it in the USL - I have no idea what his take on it is.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Should have been a precondition of pardon to square your debt (if any) with n4n0.

I don't know the particulars of your case so I can't comment directly. I suggest you work it out with him directly (or provide evidence of having already done that.)

Regarding restitution and pardons: It is the same principle as in scamming. If you are pardoned for a scam without repaying your victims (assuming they can be found) then the pardon is void. Repayment is a condition of a pardon. Of course if the victim simply forgives you (which was my understanding of what's happened) then there is nothing to repay.

You are correct that you shouldn't be on trial twice. But the issue is whether or not you've fulfilled the proper requirements of your pardon, not whether or not you should be retried.

As I said, it sounds like you two are on pretty good terms so I was expecting this to go away of its own accord. Talk it out some more. Come back to me if you can't agree.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
Should have been a precondition of pardon to square your debt (if any) with n4n0.

I don't know the particulars of your case so I can't comment directly. I suggest you work it out with him directly (or provide evidence of having already done that.)

Regarding restitution and pardons: It is the same principle as in scamming. If you are pardoned for a scam without repaying your victims (assuming they can be found) then the pardon is void. Repayment is a condition of a pardon. Of course if the victim simply forgives you (which was my understanding of what's happened) then there is nothing to repay.

You are correct that you shouldn't be on trial twice. But the issue is whether or not you've fulfilled the proper requirements of your pardon, not whether or not you should be retried.

As I said, it sounds like you two are on pretty good terms so I was expecting this to go away of its own accord. Talk it out some more. Come back to me if you can't agree.

I actually decided to block him after this because I don't generally trust him much. I doubt he will be forgiving me after making this thread.

I do not owe him a thing. All I did was discuss in a chat and invite people to it - I did no harm to him, nor did I cause any damage.

I was only pardoned BECAUSE every other staff member seemed to agree that I don't owe him. If it were not for that, I would still be banned.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
I actually decided to block him after this because I don't generally trust him much. I doubt he will be forgiving me after making this thread.

I do not owe him a thing. All I did was discuss in a chat and invite people to it - I did no harm to him, nor did I cause any damage.

I was only pardoned BECAUSE every other staff member seemed to agree that I don't owe him. If it were not for that, I would still be banned.

Invite people to the chat where the pictures were being discussed?
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
I would rather if you made a judgement as I respect your decision much more than his. I would like it if you could consult with other staff though to get the entire picture, not just what he wants to share. As I said, I was unbanned for a reason - the majority clearly thinks I'm innocent and/or believe I don't owe him.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
Invite people to the chat where the pictures were being discussed?

Yes. It was a big Skype chat and I invited 2 people in I think (one of them being the moderator that reported us all to n4n0).
 
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Wubba Lubba Dub Dub
The Mortyest Morty
Discord Verified
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Le Kingdoms Player
Two Factor Authentication User
Spam Forum Participant
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Signature of the Month Winner
Discussing and having a laugh about the pictures, while of poor taste, is a very minor ripple in the giant tidal wave of shit that enveloped Ryan. In this instance majority of the users were in this situation and did not do anything further. What is occurring here is collective punishment since practically nothing you do will actually affect those who are truly to blame for the misdemeanors. Instead of interpreting the severity of each individual's involvement, a blanket punishment is given to everyone which is definitely unfair. Remember, in a court case an accomplice does not receive as harsh a punishment as the murderer themselves. The same principle should be applied here. An hour or more of giggling over some pictures should not translate to $250 USD.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
I'm not sure if you're able to do a judgement on it and decide if I owe him or not, but we'll see.

Inquiry about Pardon: http://www.sythe.org/dispute-ban-twc/1715182-sythe-n4n0-question-about-my-pardon.html
Failed Pardon #1: http://www.sythe.org/dispute-forum-archive/1664457-dialatic-pardoning-trin-incident.html
Failed Pardon #2: http://www.sythe.org/dispute-forum-...sideration-pardon-december-31st-incident.html
Successful Pardon: http://www.sythe.org/dispute-forum-archive/1717571-dialatic-requesting-pardon-trin-incident.html

The staff lounge would also have the chat logs from the incident I assume.
 
PHP Shit Show 2k26
This is absolutely disgusting and shows just how money hungry the administration is. It is clear that n4n0 agreed there was no need to pay $250 and now he's going back on that after he realizes he could've made a quick buck.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
Did you share the documents on any site?

No I did not. I may have re-linked once or twice in the chat that already had the links posted hundreds of times, but I never posted them on any forum or in any chat other than that.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
I don't think Dialatic should have to pay if the majority of the staff supported his pardon and agreed to let him back. (I believe his pardon process was before I was promoted).

If monetary compensation is a must prior to pardon/restitution (I'm against it completely), then it should for those that were the cause and instigating factor of said issues. I.e, those that hacked the emails/uploaded and distrusted the images on different sites/sent them to n4n0s family etc. I personally wouldn't unban those users regardless of monetary compensation anyway. AFAIK, none of those users were Sythe users anyway.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
No I did not. I may have re-linked once or twice in the chat that already had the links posted hundreds of times, but I never posted them on any forum or in any chat other than that.

Well assuming what you've said is true I would agree in your case you owe no actual damages and you've already paid punitively through your ban time. So I would say, again assuming what you've said is true, that the pardon is valid and remains.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
MushyMuncher
Member of the Month Winner
Easter 2015
Discord Verified
Well assuming what you've said is true I would agree in your case you owe no actual damages and you've already paid punitively through your ban time. So I would say, again assuming what you've said is true that the pardon is valid and remains.

Everything I said is 100% true and can be verified through Roary (who probably knows the chat logs off by heart at this point).

I respect your decision, thank you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top