• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Do you want commission staking?

Do you want commission staking to be on Sythe?

  • Yes

  • No

  • Other?


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
I support 100%. I'd love to be a commission host honestly. The rules would have to be strict though. I would like to see things like, proving the account isn't blacklisted, that you HAVE TO with no exceptions stream the stakes in some way, something along the lines of if the hosts internet goes out because of anything besides a ddos would be on him and not the bettor. I'm not sure if you can prove that you've been ddos'd or not but it's just a thought, also something like if RS goes down it's not the hosts fault etc. Just some thoughts, sorry for being everywhere. :P

Thinking about it, the ddos thing I don't know how well that would be received, but in the grand scheme of things the host wants nothing more than to win so he can get his commission. I don't know, it was just a thought that appeared and I typed it out. If it's dumb just ignore it XD.
 
Verified Hardcore
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Twitter
Writing Competition Winner
Community Participant
Paper Trading Competition Participant
Detective
Facebook Promoter
In Memory of Jon
Le Kingdoms Player
Christmas 2020
Christmas 2023
Easter 2024
HamSanta
March Madness
May the 4th Be With You
PHP Shit Show 2k26
St. Patrick's Day 2024
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
I think this would be really unsafe for the staker. You get a decent risk to get both banned for RWT and for Commision Staking.
 
This comes with a few problems. It's a safe haven for scammers. Unless it gets streamed, there will be no real evidence and the scammer will always win (innocent until proven guilty). If it gets streamed it has to be private, otherwise people could exploit this fact maliciously (reporting these accounts on twitter etc.). There has to be a clear rule for the event that the account gets banned while in the hand of the comission staker. Who will be responsible for the account and who will be responsible for what what's on the account at the time?

I support it, but this will undoubtedly lead to a lot of scamming and banned accounts.
 
Voted no, if allowed everything needs to be recorded and readily available upon client request.
 
Extreme Homosex
Potamus
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Verified Ironman
Could it be a section where you either a) have to be verified b) pay a deposit to Sythe.org that is their equivalent to how much they can accept to stake on behalf of the customer.
 
Could it be a section where you either a) have to be verified b) pay a deposit to Sythe.org that is their equivalent to how much they can accept to stake on behalf of the customer.
Richard has stated before that for legal reasons we cannot and we will not be taking deposits to help prevent scams in any way shape or form.
 
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
I'd rather not see it being on Sythe, but there is a market for it and it'd probably be a less risky alternative to account rentals, so I wouldn't be against it replacing that market.
 
almost a 60/40 split, quite a controversial one tbh.

I voted no because at the end of the day I see it being another nightmare for staff.
 
In Memory of Jon
Phanpy
Donphan
Rakashrug
Gooby
Detective
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Valentine's Day 2015
Halloween 2015
Christmas 2015
Easter 2016
Paper Trading Competition Participant
<3 n4n0
Verified Bronze
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Pokémon Trainer
Nitro Booster
Verified Ironman
Poképedia
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Former OMM
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Extreme Homosex
Commission staking is easily exploitable and there are clans who have long-standing reps where people who want to commission stake can do so safely. The benefits of bringing it here do not outweigh the large chance of scamming occurring from doing so
 
Two Factor Authentication User
SytheSteamer
Signature of the Month Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Christmas 2016
Christmas 2019
Easter 2016
Former OMM
In Memory of Jon
Member of the Month Winner
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
St. Patrick's Day 2018
Summer 2019
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Toast Wallet User
Verified Overwatch Diamond
Commission staking is easily exploitable and there are clans who have long-standing reps where people who want to commission stake can do so safely. The benefits of bringing it here do not outweigh the large chance of scamming occurring from doing so


Do we think its a safer alternative to account rentals?
Because its going to cannibalize that market if we decide to add commission staking
 
Commission staking is easily exploitable and there are clans who have long-standing reps where people who want to commission stake can do so safely. The benefits of bringing it here do not outweigh the large chance of scamming occurring from doing so
So you're saying that you don't want it because it's easy to scam? This is the most pointless argument. You say there's already clans with reputation - that's like saying people on sythe should only trade with well established people like Bogla because they are already have a long standing rep.
 
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
In Memory of Jon
Dragon Claws
Former OMM
So you're saying that you don't want it because it's easy to scam? This is the most pointless argument. You say there's already clans with reputation - that's like saying people on sythe should only trade with well established people like Bogla because they are already have a long standing rep.

And that's what people do say. Pay a bit more so you're guaranteed your product, or a bit less and risk losing your money altogether
 
In Memory of Jon
Phanpy
Donphan
Rakashrug
Gooby
Detective
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Valentine's Day 2015
Halloween 2015
Christmas 2015
Easter 2016
Paper Trading Competition Participant
<3 n4n0
Verified Bronze
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Pokémon Trainer
Nitro Booster
Verified Ironman
Poképedia
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Former OMM
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Extreme Homosex
Do we think its a safer alternative to account rentals?
Because its going to cannibalize that market if we decide to add commission staking

Account rentals is probably the most unsafe market section besides account sales and that goes for both the person who owns the account and the person renting it. It is very difficult to prove that an account renter scammed someone for X amount for starters, and on the other hand someone renting an account could very easily get it permanently banned in an hour at the cost of only $3-5. Commission staking is also extremely risky due to the many ways the person on the account can rig/fake the stake. That said, there are trusted people in both markets who are available and safe. As for my opinion, I think the account rental section is cannibalizing itself due to the large number of scams so adding commission staking would certainly speed up that process

So you're saying that you don't want it because it's easy to scam? This is the most pointless argument. You say there's already clans with reputation - that's like saying people on sythe should only trade with well established people like Bogla because they are already have a long standing rep.

Commission staking in particular is especially dangerous because there are a lot of ways to scam someone without them even knowing they got scammed. I am suggesting the well-established clans because (in my opinion) if you are looking to commission stake the fees the clans charge aren't very high to begin with and your risk of being scammed is low. The extra scam risk that opening up the market here would bring is not outweighed by the benefits of competition and lower prices and such, it's just a very scam-heavy market.

I would never say that people should ONLY trade with bogla but there's obviously a reason that he's as successful as he is
 
IMO the reason account rentals have such high scam rates is because most people probably don't think that they can ever be kicked off the account and lose their money, resulting in them looking for the cheapest renter as they don't believe trust means anything.

However, in commission staking you are actually trading your money over to someone, resulting in people only giving their money to people they find very trustworthy, and probably reducing scams as only the very trusted receive people wanting to use them.

Same goes for account purchases, people are quite clueless and think there is extremely slim to none chance the account they buy will get recovered, resulting in them not looking for trust but rather cheap prices.

Commission staking puts someone in a direct position of trust so people will only use trusted people
 
So confused.

Strong amounts of hypocrisy in here all of a sudden.

These are some quotes talking about Sythe being a free market/No restrictions/If you get scammed it's your fault.

I only found these on the first two pages? But I know someone linked me more awhile ago where even Sythe said this same thing.

video said:
We are not banning high-risk trades. blah blah free market buyer beware blah blah

bus said:
Market restrictions have never in history been placed on any section.

Names and accounts are far worse and have no restrictions still, I see no reason why this would change Sythes attitude towards restricting market.

I don't necessarily disagree with you, frankly if I had it my way I would favor restrictions in particular markets, but because I know it wont ever happen(never has) its a no support from me.

broken man said:
No support it's a free market if people are stupid enough to trust someone with no vouches and just fresh sythe account to rent there 07 account and then stake on it and expect them not to scam there fucking retarded ,

It's up to person to check the user vouch's and feedback and join date it's not are responsibility But i would support some new sticky or something with more information :p

tyler said:
Thanks for the suggestion, this wont be approved because blah blah free market blah blah people should only trade people they trust.

Try to think of ways to do it so it wouldnt hinder new users from coming into the marketplace and trying it.

tyler said:
No support as this would restrict the market as richard does not like to do.

dunworry said:
Agreed. It's up to the person who wants to rent the account to gauge who they are renting from. Are they a brand new user? Do they have no vouches? Do they sound sketchy? Etc.

superflous said:
it's a free market, and if people are stupid enough to trust people renting out accounts, that's on them.

matp said:
There has been multiple suggestions about Account rentals, but they have been denied because, like DD said, who you deal with is completely at your discretion.
If you don't trust the guy, just dont rent his account. Also, It's a free market & it would be too much work for the mods.



Yet all of a sudden because it's easy to scam this shouldn't be added ??? ???


084.png


In that case can we bring up the points discussed in all of the other sections suggestions about regulations and easy scamming --> Name sales, Rentals, Account Sales.

The same arguments being used here against this new addition. Are the same arguments that everyone was shooting down with no discussion.

If I'm allowed to give someone my account to use. Why the hell would I not be allowed to stake for them. I assume everyone is aware that you can already kick people offline if you are the original owner. That money is being trusted wether it's through commission or just straight renting, there is no safety here. The ONLY problem I see is that it would be hard to verify blacklisted accounts. Which means the entire process would need to be streamed from login.

Hello?

Is this a free market or not.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top