I have to agree, with the exception of users that have scammed.
When paying particular attention to the OPs DNT reason, I can't see how this would benefit the wider community.
If a user is DNT'd for a reason such as bad trading practice, I feel like the staff could well look to provide an insight into how their decision could be reversed (whether it's time or good on-going business outside of Sythe).
However, where a user has scammed, the only benefit I see is their return of the scammed amount to the Community Repayment. In extreme circumstances I fail to see how allowing a user to trade again benefits anyone, other than the scammer. Why are they all of a sudden keen to do legit business?
Now I am relatively new to Sythe, however I've been about on similar markets for a stupidly long time, the general rule of thumb was once a scammer always a scammer - many of them would never allow people back into the community at all.