• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

[DENIED] 1Year Account responsibility

Status
Not open for further replies.

tigeris

Not Buying/Selling Anything Don't Dm Me

$200 USD Donor New
Joined
Dec 2, 2015
Sythe Gold
4,642
Messages
7,791
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
Suggesting minimum responsibility after selling account to be changed to 1 year.
Current 1-month responsibility leaves too much space for abuse, as people are reselling accounts with ridiculous recovery rates hoping they would pass the 1-month mark so they can avoid all responsibility.
1 Year sounds like a very solid time frame, and it shouldn't cause any problems for legit sellers
 
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Verified Ironman
I saw Matthew
Member of the Month Winner
Detective
Discord Verified
Toast Wallet User
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
March Madness
May the 4th Be With You
Nitro Booster
Two Factor Authentication User
Staff of the Quarter Winner
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poképedia
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
no support.. beginner accounts like 60 60 60 with being oo original ip etc, are 50/50 recovery after 2 months .. never mind 9 months

year too long.. 1 month too short
 
Last edited:
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
no support.. beginner accounts like 60 60 60 with being oo original ip etc, are 50/50 recovery after 2 months .. never mind 9 months
If an account has 50/50 recovery it shouldn't be sold on sythe. Or please put this on your topic "Your account has 50% chance to be recovered after purchase"
 
Last edited:
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Verified Ironman
I saw Matthew
Member of the Month Winner
Detective
Discord Verified
Toast Wallet User
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
March Madness
May the 4th Be With You
Nitro Booster
Two Factor Authentication User
Staff of the Quarter Winner
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poképedia
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
If an account has 50/50 recovery it shouldn't be sold on sythe. Or please put this on your topic "Your account has 50% chance to be recovered after purchase"
after certain amount of play time buyer just has recovery power it's the reason the rule was brought in the first place ...
 
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
after certain amount of play time buyer just has recovery power it's the reason the rule was brought in the first place ...
While they do have a slight recovery power, it will always be overturned by an original owners recovery. If an original owner can't recover the account back he is either lying about being original owner or he doesn't want to help.
 
Last edited:
Two Factor Authentication User
<3 n4n0
Christmas 2025
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2025
HamSanta
Homosex
March Madness
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poképedia
Potamus
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Summer 2022
Summer 2024
Ursaring
Verified Ironman
There's already a thread about this in this section - you have also posted in this thread. Does not appear this thread is needed:
Revamp account sale rules


While they do have a slight recovery power, it will always be overturned by an original owners recovery. If an original owner can't recover the account back he is either lying about being original owner or he doesn't want to help.

Bolded above is actually not true. I, as well as numerous other people who posted on the thread above, have ran into scenarios where us as an OO (with all information) are unable to recover an account. I've had a worker get two accounts locked - I was able to unlock one but not the other but yet they were created recently, with the same information, on the same IP. I've also had an IRL friend that I gave a pure to a while back lose information & we went to recover this with no success.

The system is not 100% to say it can always be overturned. It's a somewhat flawed system. This is why a year would be too long. I do support that 1 month is simply too little though.
 
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
There's already a thread about this in this section - you have also posted in this thread. Does not appear this thread is needed:
Revamp account sale rules




Bolded above is actually not true. I, as well as numerous other people who posted on the thread above, have ran into scenarios where us as an OO (with all information) are unable to recover an account. I've had a worker get two accounts locked - I was able to unlock one but not the other but yet they were created recently, with the same information, on the same IP. I've also had an IRL friend that I gave a pure to a while back lose information & we went to recover this with no success.

The system is not 100% to say it can always be overturned. It's a somewhat flawed system. This is why a year would be too long. I do support that 1 month is simply too little though.
There are many variables when it comes to recovery, and every account seller should figure those out themselves. But i've never had a case where i couldn't recover an account no matter how much time has passed, altho it took several tries sometimes. But that's the sellers problem if he can't figure this out not the buyers
 
Last edited:
Christmas 2024
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
OG Club
Christmas 2013
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Winter Olympics 2022
March Madness
Easter 2020
Christmas 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2022
Halloween 2022
Christmas 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2023
Valentine's Day 2023
Summer 2023
Easter 2023
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Poképedia
Christmas 2023
Halloween 2023
HamSanta
Easter 2024
PHP Shit Show 2k26
No support.

as people are reselling accounts with ridiculous recovery rates hoping they would pass the 1-month mark so they can avoid all responsibility.

Where are all of these people you speak of that are abusing their trust to rip people off? Can you give us more info on the accounts they sell with "ridiculous recovery rates?"
Feel free to link their profiles, I'm curious.


If an account has 50/50 recovery it shouldn't be sold on sythe. Or please put this on your topic "Your account has 50% chance to be recovered after purchase"

You took what he said and manipulated it to fit your argument. You know what he meant.

While they do have a slight recovery power, it will always be overturned by an original owners recovery. If an original owner can't recover the account back he is either lying about being original owner or he doesn't want to help.

This, unfortunately, is not always the case. You posted a blanket statement with zero evidence to support your claim.


I agree with ABM in that 1 month is too little, 1 year is too long. However, at the end of the day, sellers are required to notify the buyer on whether they are the OO/who is. A buyer can choose how they want to spend their money from there. It's no different than the rest of the BST sections.


Not trying to be difficult.. but, I like suggestions that have been researched, thought out, and have evidence to support the why. This does not appear to check those boxes. This is also a duplicate of Poat's suggestion from earlier this month. I'm not sure why you created this, considering you've posted in his (so you're aware of its existence)?
 
Two Factor Authentication User
<3 n4n0
Christmas 2025
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2025
HamSanta
Homosex
March Madness
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poképedia
Potamus
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Summer 2022
Summer 2024
Ursaring
Verified Ironman
There are many variables when it comes to recovery, and every account seller should figure those out themselves. But i've never had a case where i couldn't recover an account no matter how much time has passed, altho it took several tries sometimes. But that's the sellers problem if he can't figure this out not the buyers

You are generalizing everybody simply because you have not run into this problem. I'm stating that there is a flaw in the system & have attempted every avenue to assist in the cases I mentioned above. Same with other high end sellers who have stated the same. The system is flawed whether you want to accept this or not.

Who's stopping a purchaser from changing the linked email over to another email of their own & claiming it is "recovered" requesting the money back & the flawed system lets to keep the account a year down the line?
 
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
Who's stopping a purchaser from changing the linked email over to another email of their own & claiming it is "recovered" requesting the money back & the flawed system lets to keep the account a year down the line?
This isn't how this works


Not trying to be difficult.. but, I like suggestions that have been researched, thought out, and have evidence to support the why. This does not appear to check those boxes. This is also a duplicate of Poat's suggestion from earlier this month. I'm not sure why you created this, considering you've posted in his (so you're aware of its existence)?
No one is giving away their research for free, I could write 10 page article on accounts recovery (and I actually released a plain one for free on sythe) but that'd be stupid of me. If sellers can't figure out a way to keep their accounts secure should we lower the standards or get rid of unsafe sellers?
 
Last edited:
Christmas 2024
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
OG Club
Christmas 2013
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Winter Olympics 2022
March Madness
Easter 2020
Christmas 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2022
Halloween 2022
Christmas 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2023
Valentine's Day 2023
Summer 2023
Easter 2023
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Poképedia
Christmas 2023
Halloween 2023
HamSanta
Easter 2024
PHP Shit Show 2k26
No one is giving away their research for free, I could write 10 page article on accounts recovery (and I actually released a plain one for free on sythe) but that'd be stupid of me. If sellers can't figure out a way to keep their accounts secure should we lower the standards or get rid of unsafe sellers?

What are you even rambling on about? Your reply was completely off topic to my post.
 
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
What are you even rambling on about? Your reply was completely off topic to my post.
"I like suggestions that have been researched, thought out, and have evidence to support the why. This does not appear to check those boxes" I thought you wanted evidence of how account recovery works, but ok.
 
Christmas 2024
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
OG Club
Christmas 2013
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Winter Olympics 2022
March Madness
Easter 2020
Christmas 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2022
Halloween 2022
Christmas 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2023
Valentine's Day 2023
Summer 2023
Easter 2023
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Poképedia
Christmas 2023
Halloween 2023
HamSanta
Easter 2024
PHP Shit Show 2k26
"I like suggestions that have been researched, thought out, and have evidence to support the why. This does not appear to check those boxes" I thought you wanted evidence of how account recovery works, but ok.

What..? No, that's not at all wanted I was saying. I was suggesting that you include evidence of a well thought out suggestion, along with something to prove why your suggestion is logical and/or makes the most sense. Again, refer to Poat's post. While I don't agree with all of his suggestions, he clearly spent some critical thinking time prior to firing off his suggestion at the hip.

Edit: Again, not trying to come off strong. I think your head is in the right place. Account sales are the most risky type of trade for both buyers and sellers on Sythe. There needs to be a balance between protecting both.
 
Last edited:
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
What..? No, that's not at all wanted I was saying. I was suggesting that you include evidence of a well thought out suggestion, along with something to prove why your suggestion is logical and/or makes the most sense. Again, refer to Poat's post. While I don't agree with all of his suggestions, he clearly spent some critical thinking time prior to firing off his suggestion at the hip.
Was just trying to make it as simple as possible, which is changing 1 sentence in a rule. I'd prefer Poats suggestion, but I don't expect staff to do more than changing few words in the rules. Basically small step> no step
 
Last edited:
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
In Memory of Jon
Dragon Claws
Former OMM
I thought it was at least 6 months? 1 month is way too short. Support to upping it to 6-12 months definitely. Should still be within the realm of the seller being able to easily help any issues.
 
Christmas 2024
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
OG Club
Christmas 2013
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Winter Olympics 2022
March Madness
Easter 2020
Christmas 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2022
Halloween 2022
Christmas 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2023
Valentine's Day 2023
Summer 2023
Easter 2023
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Poképedia
Christmas 2023
Halloween 2023
HamSanta
Easter 2024
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Was just trying to make it as simple as possible, which is changing 1 sentence in a rule. I'd prefer Poats suggestion, but I don't expect staff to do more than changing few words in the rules. Basically small step> no step
You're still missing the point. Changing the recovery responsibility to a mandatory 1 year is not a small step. It's a change with (potentially) huge implications to the market, regardless of whether or not you're just changing a few words in a sentence. The "ask" in Poat's suggestion was no different than yours. The difference is that he put time and thought into his suggestion before blasting it out.

Also, it sounds like you're saying staff is unwilling/incapable of making any sort of change that is relatively large or difficult? Yikes. I don't agree with that. They undertook a pretty tedious one back at the end of 2019?
[APPROVED] Overhaul of the "OSRS Main Accounts: Level 80+" Sub-Section.
 
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
You're still missing the point. Changing the recovery responsibility to a mandatory 1 year is not a small step. It's a change with (potentially) huge implications to the market, regardless of whether or not you're just changing a few words in a sentence. The "ask" in Poat's suggestion was no different than yours. The difference is that he put time and thought into his suggestion before blasting it out.

Also, it sounds like you're saying staff is unwilling/incapable of making any sort of change that is relatively large or difficult? Yikes. I don't agree with that. They undertook a pretty tedious one back at the end of 2019?
[APPROVED] Overhaul of the "OSRS Main Accounts: Level 80+" Sub-Section.
It's basically the same but he's asking for more things to be done. I'm not saying staff isn't capable of changes, i just doubt they know how account market works or will bother to research/test it for big changes, so i made a suggestion that wont take more than 10 brain cells to comprehend
 
Last edited:
Christmas 2024
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
OG Club
Christmas 2013
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Winter Olympics 2022
March Madness
Easter 2020
Christmas 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2022
Halloween 2022
Christmas 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2023
Valentine's Day 2023
Summer 2023
Easter 2023
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Poképedia
Christmas 2023
Halloween 2023
HamSanta
Easter 2024
PHP Shit Show 2k26
It's basically the same but he's asking for more things to be done. I'm not saying staff isn't capable of changes, i just doubt they know how account market works or will bother to research/test it for big changes, so i made a suggestion that wont take more than 10 brain cells to comprehend


So let me get this straight.

You aren't saying staff is incapable of making relatively large or difficult changes, but you doubt they know how the account marketplace works or will bother to research/test it? So.. you are saying they're incapable. Okay, got it.

To prevent from posting something that belong in SF, I'm going to remove myself from this conversation. What a cluster!

I will end with this;

I support 3-6 months recovery responsibility. No support to this suggestion.
 
Extreme Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Christmas 2020
Gohan has AIDS
Halloween 2020
I saw Matthew
May the 4th Be With You
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Summer 2020
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Toast Wallet User
Valentine's Day 2021
So let me get this straight.

You aren't saying staff is incapable of making relatively large or difficult changes, but you doubt they know how the account marketplace works or will bother to research/test it? So.. you are saying they're incapable. Okay, got it.

To prevent from posting something that belong in SF, I'm going to remove myself from this conversation. What a cluster!

I will end with this;

I support 3-6 months recovery responsibility. No support to this suggestion.
Thanks for your input, it's a very niche market it's not expected for everyone to know how it works. It's like saying you're incapable of driving a car unless you know how it's made, wasn't meant to offend anyone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top