his attitude probably didn't help either. He bragged a lot about the whole thing, even after having his twc removed.
I doubt he cares. He's got like $10k+ irl because of that gold
Indeed, Just un dude is using the logic that because no one on Sythe was locked / banned for the glitch, that he should get off scott-free. On the flipside, he is indirectly admitting that if people did lose their accounts due to him lying, he would have seriously screwed people over. Does Just un dude have any control over what actions Jagex takes against this duped gold? No. It was a crap-shoot. Yes, people got off fairly scott-free. However, he still put everybody in harms' way.
Furthermore, to lie and say only Roy did the dupe is silly. Just un dude's account is the second one listed in the ban-sweep. 2college is universally known as his main, and he attracted so much attention that it was posted on the ban list. He obviously was duping insane amounts, and used his own accounts.
I will admit I am biased against this Dutch fellow, because of past issues with each other. But I also know that were the situation reversed, he would be calling for bans on any major gold seller who replicated his behaviour in this circumstance. He also demonstrated a complete lack of character by constantly boasting about how he duped gold, made tons of money, etc. Be more modest, quit trying to get people to kiss your feet, and the odds are this situation would never have gotten so out of hand. If you hadn't bragged all across Sythe after the dupe was over, and attracted swarms of attention on the subject, this likely never would have gained any steam.
As for a perm-ban, I think this is actually overboard. Yes, he lied and acted impulsively, but he has also earned his stripes as a trader on the site. He should be TWC'ed 1 year, market-banned 3-6 months. Such punishment should serve as a strong enforcement that his activity was unacceptable, but allows him to slowly return and learn from his actions. We should know that in this world, people do make mistakes, and should have the chance to make up for them in time. Any losses incurred from his lies should be repaid fully, of course, but from what I understand there are none.
EDIT: Just checked out his last post before his ban -
http://www.sythe.org/showthread.php?p=11334739#post11334739
The guy seriously just camps our threads waiting for any reason to report. Total douchebag.