http://www.sythe.org/showpost.php?p=11303287&postcount=96 = no punishment (doubt they told anyone its duped until after it was patched.)
matkes (bulkmillseller) = no punishment (lied)
Even you showed interest in the dupe because you were looking to pay up to 10bil for it. If you duped the gold I know you weren't going to hold the gp you would have off loaded it at a cheaper price.
The only wrong thing he did was lie and to be honest where he lied he did tell the truth. The gold wasn't crucible duped as he stated. If somebody was going to be banned for selling duped gold it should have been from this point:
http://sythe.org/showpost.php?p=11303826&postcount=14 or as soon as that guy came on here selling at 0.35/mil. The guy who offloaded bils on PA denied ANY duping of his gold whereas Just Un Dude denied duping through crucible.
Forgot to mention those claims against his gold being duped all stated "crucible duped", its no different than the WoW gold sellers who say this gold was hand farmed or not hacked. For those who don't know Blizzard in most cases removes gold that was botted/ hacked from another person.