• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Do not ban for offsite activities...

Status
Not open for further replies.
1. Yes, definitely. He is probably here to scam.
2. I think a mod vote should determine this one.


I do agree as for the first one, if they've scammed and there's proof etc.

#2
Lol, scamming in Runescape and they should be banned? That's retarded. It's pixels. you aren't paying for a RS account. It's like banning someone for Luring someone in RS2...

Personally I dont think anyone will be happy with what rules are Implemented So It will always Remain a grey area .

and this^
 
Okay. Think about these cases.

1.

Leecher comes to Sythe and starts trading. Someone does a background check and finds that they were banned from greattrades.com for scamming. Should this user get banned from Sythe because of that? What benefits would a ban have?

2.

A highly trusted member who is an OMM and moderator admits to scamming people on Runescape like 6 years ago. Should he be banned? Why?

Yes & Yes.
Edit: Didn't really read #2. Nevermind it.
 
Tier 1 Prizebox
1. Yes, definitely. He is probably here to scam.
2. I think a mod vote should determine this one.

I agree with you on the first one.

But on number two do you really think a mod vote is necessary? It was on runescape 6 years ago. Maybe it was for luring? that's technically scamming. Do you really think someone who lured in runescape 6 years ago is of any risk to the users here at sythe?
 
Tier 1 Prizebox
I do agree as for the first one, if they've scammed and there's proof etc.

#2
Lol, scamming in Runescape and they should be banned? That's retarded. It's pixels. you aren't paying for a RS account. It's like banning someone for Luring someone in RS2...



and this^


Excellent point Tmoe ;)
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
While this analogy is unrealistic in regards to sythe; technically since i've decided to condone all hacking period... Yeah you should. :)

Its actually the truth. Under the current, kinda unwritten rules, I should be banned.

Where do you draw the line between what hacking should be considered harmless and unrelated to sythe and what hacking poses a threat? and get a clear rule from it?

or are you 100% in favor of anyone who has scammed/hacked ect. in the past be allowed to be on sythe?

I believe that anyone that is found to have done things that are against Sythe rules before they came to Sythe and have not done any of those things on Sythe they should not be banned.

I don't see why people are banned for offsite actions, UNLESS it occurs offsite while they are active on Sythe. If they scam on another site while they own an active Sythe account, then their Sythe account should receive the same punishment as scammers on Sythe should.

That makes perfect sense as its a danger to allow them to have an account on Sythe that can get trusted, as their character shows that they will just scam.

As for a time offense, that really just depends. It's hard to determine how it should be handled, because it really is based on a case by case scenario.

You mean like past?

For hacking/cracking/etc, I don't think it should be a bannable offense unless the user shows intent to use it against a Sythe member. Scamming is slightly different, however, as it shows what they're interested in, and what they're capable of.

Current or past? I'm confused. Maybe I should have made two threads. Ohwell.

Not true, if you get in a fight outside of school, but it is causing drama in school. The school can suspend/expel you from their premises for disrupting learning etc.

Real life analogies suck. Honestly. Lol.

As for the suggestion itself, I support it to a decree. If someone is phishing, ddosing, hacking, etc. on another site they should be banned here.
They can Phish people through PM's.
They can gather Msn's and get a person's IP.

Phishing through PM's is a bannable offense. Just wait for them to do it here. It takes like 3 seconds to make an account to do it on. Guests can gather MSNs.
 
Yes & Yes.

People can "change" but does it really excuse their past actions? Does it matter if it was 10 years ago, it still happened and nothing will change that fact. However, if the person refunded Double what they scammed to the person then it could be excused. (That would only qualify for actions committed in the past, and not for scamming sythe members which would result in a ban either way.)

I'm not going to lie.. You annoy me to no end.

#2
They aren't stealing any real money. They're pixels. It isn't a trading site and if someone was dumb enough to get lured, or not check the 2cd trade screen; it's their fault.

Phishing through PM's is a bannable offense. Just wait for them to do it here. It takes like 3 seconds to make an account to do it on. Guests can gather MSNs.

It is, but if someone falls for it it's simple as deleting the PM.
Yes, guests can gather Msn's, but 95% of the time the person that was added asks for the Sythe name. Random people that aren't part of Sythe don't often add you.

Edit: Also, what Deacon said.. Bannable offense, different site, during time on Sythe, still be banned for it.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
For case 1, I meant that they scammed maybe a year or two ago. Sorry I wasn't clear.

Does that change anyone's opinions?
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
It is, but if someone falls for it it's simple as deleting the PM.
Yes, guests can gather Msn's, but 95% of the time the person that was added asks for the Sythe name. Random people that aren't part of Sythe don't often add you.

People get banned for spreading phishing links all the time. No one would risk a trusted Sythe account for it. Gathering MSN's is easy. Just look at Sythe and add them.
 
For case 1, I meant that they scammed maybe a year or two ago. Sorry I wasn't clear.

Does that change anyone's opinions?

Depending on how big this scam was.
If it's a pin, I can see them coming to Sythe with a TwC.
While if it was a big trade,($400 for Blue Phat etc.) and just took the hat and ran, they shouldn't be able to come. That shows they don't really have morals on stealing $400 from someone.

People get banned for spreading phishing links all the time. No one would risk a trusted Sythe account for it. Gathering MSN's is easy. Just look at Sythe and add them.

Yes, people do often get banned for spreading Phishing links, but why risk Sythe members being phished when they're already known phishers.

As for the Msn's I said this originally for a person to get IP's. In order to grab an IP you either use an IP grabber, or someone along those lines. You can do this via Msn Games, sending a file, etc.
 
I'm not going to lie.. You annoy me to no end.

#2
They aren't stealing any real money. They're pixels. It isn't a trading site and if someone was dumb enough to get lured, or not check the 2cd trade screen; it's their fault.

I didn't read that correctly, I had thought he meant scamming over forums not as a method of luring/other trade scams. Hell i'll admit I used the Needle GP stack scam back in classic on other people.

Second: Annoy you? I don't really give a fuck.
 
NVM...
I thought it meant out of runescape accounts
I once did that scam on rs where u get 2 guys 1 on one side of the bank 1 on the other and u take a junk item no one has heard of that looks rare and sell it for a mill and the other guy says he is buying for 2 mill.

SORRY
Didn't read the "on runescape" part
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Depending on how big this scam was.
If it's a pin, I can see them coming to Sythe with a TwC.
While if it was a big trade,($400 for Blue Phat etc.) and just took the hat and ran, they shouldn't be able to come. That shows they don't really have morals on stealing $400 from someone.

What is banning them going to do? They are a leecher. Not trusted. They will just make another account, and they will get smarter and won't get caught this time.

I didn't read that correctly, I had thought he meant scamming over forums not as a method of luring/other trade scams. Hell i'll admit I used the Needle GP stack scam back in classic on other people.

Second: Annoy you? I don't really give a fuck.

You can apply it to a $200 account trade scam if you wish. 4-6 years ago. By a highly trusted staff member.
 
What is banning them going to do? They are a leecher. Not trusted. They will just make another account, and they will get smarter and won't get caught this time.

I see your point; I just don't see why they should be allowed into the community either way.

I didn't read that correctly, I had thought he meant scamming over forums not as a method of luring/other trade scams. Hell i'll admit I used the Needle GP stack scam back in classic on other people.

Second: Annoy you? I don't really give a fuck.

Youmadbro?
O, and I meant annoying :).
 
I see your point; I just don't see why they should be allowed into the community either way.



Youmadbro?
O, and I meant annoying :).

Off topic entirely: Yes mad, raging hardcore broham.

On topic: With SuF's new proposal that it scammed $200 yeah my first post before the edit stands.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
I see your point; I just don't see why they should be allowed into the community either way.

The thing is, you have to take a step back to see what a ban really accomplishes. Why ban someone if it will make no difference? If the leecher is a scammer, they will vade and scam someone. Banning the first account made no difference. If they are no longer a scammer, then they could go on to be a great member. There really isn't a point to banning them.
 
Tier 1 Prizebox
I believe that anyone that is found to have done things that are against Sythe rules before they came to Sythe and have not done any of those things on Sythe they should not be banned.

Again i feel it depends on the situation, if they were banned from powerbot tuesday for scamming 200$ then came to sythe wednesday what's to stop them from scamming?
 
The thing is, you have to take a step back to see what a ban really accomplishes. Why ban someone if it will make no difference? If the leecher is a scammer, they will vade and scam someone. Banning the first account made no difference. If they are no longer a scammer, then they could go on to be a great member. There really isn't a point to banning them.

They could but it doesn't mean they will, does it? At least if they vade there is a chance you'll catch them again, and just ban them again.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Again i feel it depends on the situation, if they were banned from powerbot tuesday for scamming 200$ then came to sythe wednesday what's to stop them from scamming?

I mean not like a day. A day before Sythe basically equals during their time at Sythe.
 
Tier 1 Prizebox
The thing is, you have to take a step back to see what a ban really accomplishes. Why ban someone if it will make no difference? If the leecher is a scammer, they will vade and scam someone. Banning the first account made no difference. If they are no longer a scammer, then they could go on to be a great member. There really isn't a point to banning them.

By this logic there is no point in banning scammers who scam present day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top