I fail to see how velocity can be negative. If an object is moving, it's movement should be presented as a positive factor regardless of direction.Assume they are velocities, not scalar measurements.
It makes sense then.
I fail to see how velocity can be negative. If an object is moving, it's movement should be presented as a positive factor regardless of direction.Assume they are velocities, not scalar measurements.
It makes sense then.
Actually, I've googled a bit since we started discussing this, and all I see is hypothetical equations on paper and subjectively assigning negative numbers to entities.You're committing the argument from laziness fallacy. http://www.don-lindsay-archive.org/skeptic/arguments.html#laziness
Nevertheless, since you probably don't care, I'll get the professors opinion on this within about 3 hours, give or take.
I fail to see how velocity can be negative. If an object is moving, it's movement should be presented as a positive factor regardless of direction.
Oh, I thought you meant velocity as speed alone.Velocity is a vector, it measure both speed and direction.
From a starting point, if you move backwards, you will have a negative velocity.
Oh, I thought you meant velocity as speed alone.
Anyway, as I was saying, subjectively assigning negative numbers. Now, I agree that it can be practical to do so, but I still stand on the claim that if something is moving it is moving at an objectively positive speed.
We agree then.Yes, speed is always positive.
Since we have come to the agreement that speed is always objectively positive, can't we just agree on the hypothetical nature of negative speed as well? And thus, it's inability to prove physically how multiplication by a negative is possible?"moving backwards at 3 m/s" is a velocity of -3/s though.
I'm just going to give up because I don't think I will be able to make you grasp the concept via an Internet forum. A lot of people have the same opinion of negative numbers as you do though, I tutor GCSE maths and it comes up a lot.
Since we have come to the agreement that speed is always objectively positive, can't we just agree on the hypothetical nature of negative speed as well? And thus, it's inability to prove physically how multiplication by a negative is possible?
If I walk sideways like a crab, am I standing still?His speed is not negative.
He is walking BACKWARDS, he has ended up behind his starting point so his velocity is -3m/s.
If you rewind a tape, you are at a point behind that which you started. In this case, 4 seconds behind the point at which you started. -4 seconds from the start.
The proof if fine and it works. You are just not allowing yourself to follow it properly.
If I walk sideways like a crab, am I standing still?
If I rewind a tape 4 seconds, I would say that I am 4 objectively positive seconds away from where I was. This can be assigned a fictional negative number to describe which direction I've taken, but to me that doesn't make it objectively negative.
Yes, because movement in a negative direction does not exist outside your subjective vector.You're being deliberately obtuse.
Let's take the scenario with the tape. Let's say the tape normally moves from left to right. If I rewind it 4 seconds, the tape moves the distance equivalent to 4 seconds of tape to the left. Let's use seconds as a length measure to keep it simple. I don't deny that the amount of tape to the left of the player is now 4 seconds less than before (x-4=y), but the actual movement of the tape is positive.Your method of using "objectively positive" numbers is even more hypothetical than negative numbers. You're simplifying reality to suit your own simple understanding of it.
Lovely. Nothing better than understanding each other and agreeing. There's only been one religious remark since this started, but the topic can finally get back on track now.:laugh:Oh I see now.
Negative numbers are hypothetical and abstract so they can;t be explained in the real world.
I agree with you.
Dr.Math said:Debt is a good example of a negative number. One common form of debt is a mortgage in which you owe the bank money because the bank paid for your house. It is also common for an employer to deduct a mortgage payment from an employee's paycheck to help the employee keep on schedule with the payments.
Suppose $700 is being deducted each month to pay the mortgage. After six months, how much money has been taken out of the pay for the mortgage? We can figure out the answer by doing multiplication.
6 * -$700 = -$4,200
This is an illustration of a positive times a negative resulting in a negative.
Now suppose that, as a bonus, the employer decides to pay the mortgage for one year. The employer removes the mortgage deduction from the monthly paychecks. How much money is gained by the employee in our example? We can represent "removes" by a negative number and figure out the answer by multiplying.
-12 * -$700 = $8,400
This is an illustration of a negative times a negative resulting in a positive.
If one thinks of multiplication as grouping, then we have made a positive group by taking away a negative number twelve times.
Damn, it was so close to getting back on track.Schnell, here's a middle school math lesson for you:
I can't believe i'm arguing about this...this is ridiculous.
Thats all nice but you clearly do not understand what actual omnipotence is. a part of Omnipotence is being able to be at all places at all times. In another time he could alter himself and be able to pick the stone but at the same time creating a stone in another time. its complicatated but is no way is omnipotence a paradox.
No this isn't my position... I'm saying that there is no way in hell that a human is ever going to be able to create anoter human with any disorders the scientific way. Why? Because we're already thousands of years living all together on this planet and we've been constantly seeking to the reason off life and how to make life by ourselves *putting stem cells together and we still didn't find any solution to make a human without disorders.
First of all I'll just say I don't think God exists, so don't take this as an argument about God, this is just about the omnipotence statement. I think using omnipotence as an argument either for or against God is ridiculous.
Omnipotence is power without limit.
Making up a sentence that says "Could an omnipotent being create a stone so heavy that even that being could not lift it?" creates a paradox to our minds.
Does making up this sentence say anything about the omnipotent being, whose power is limitless? No, it's just a sentence we don't have an answer to.
The whole nature of omnipotence means the omnipotent being can do anything, even if it seems to be impossible for our minds to understand.
1. Please define pariothipical, righon, and bi-opular, as according to the multiple dictionaries I've checked, such words do not exist.
It's slang.. It's not in the dictionary. Spend some more time outside, socializing with real people, and you might know what they mean.