• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Sythe.org Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 10, 2007
Sythe Gold
198
Messages
14,172
Location
USA
Discord Unique ID
777373911821713408
Pool Shark
Village Drunk
<3 n4n0
Battleship Champion
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
In an effort to combat the continual ban evasion, scamming, and hackings, I decided to draft up the beginning of something which may prove to be useful.

By re-implementing some code that has already been written by Matthew, I've created the basic template for a Sythe.org Trade Center. There may certainly be some drawbacks from this, but I will try to do my best in explaining what I'm wanting to accomplish with this suggestion, and how useful/helpful this can be to current users and newcomers alike.

Please understand these pages were generated in a couple hours due to the fact suggestions are not always approved.

Front Page
User Look-up #1: http://i.imgur.com/PZvBnqc.jpg
User Look-up #2: http://i.imgur.com/wCmZg7k.png
Trade History #1: http://i.imgur.com/iM1s5Ki.png​
  • Looks up user entered in the text box and asks for confirmation before proceeding
  • Loads trade request form if "Yes" is selected
    • If the user is banned, the process will not proceed
    • If either user has an active trade, the process will not proceed (important)
    • If Skype is on DNTL, the process will not proceed
    • *Potential rule: Posting/PM'ing of Skype ID without use of Trade Center is against the rules (if used for the purpose of trading).
  • Includes trade history on first page for quick, ease of access
Trade Form
Trade Request Form (blank): http://i.imgur.com/36aJLWb.png
Trade Request Form #1: http://i.imgur.com/OhmOK6s.png
Trade Request Form #2: http://i.imgur.com/wDsc29U.png​
  • Extremely basic form generated - Can always be improved
  • Needs Skype ID's to be included somewhere
    • Can potentially code something in to cross-reference with the DNTL to warn users.
  • "Monetary value of goods" can include RSGP or any other type of currency
  • Payment methods can be further defined (PP/WU are only included)
    • "Other" option can be included &#8594; Reveals a hidden box on the form
    • If PayPal/WU/etc is chosen, the details can be requested through the Trade Center in the case of a scam
  • "How will the trade be performed?" has 3 options
Extra(s)
Automated Private Message: http://i.imgur.com/zTiaGEz.png​

--
Reasons this may be useful: ^_^
  • Only allowed 1 transaction at a time
    • Hard to scam multiple users if someone is hacked if utilizing the Trade Center
  • Most information can be relayed through the Trade Center (in time), which could potentially help users in (auto?) generating scam reports.
  • A trade feedback system can potentially be added in.
  • Newcomers can potentially learn how to trade more safely (FAQ / Info added in to front page)
Reasons this can present a problem: :(
  • Users may not "complete" the trade afterwards
    • Can be slow and would need to be cleared manually by a Staff Member
  • Uses storage on the server, which may affect forum load times
Any advantages or disadvantages posted can be added to the lists.

This is a very rough draft of an idea I've had for a while.
It may be a lot to read, but I'm interested to see thoughts of Community Members and Staff.

Thank you.
 
Heidy
Le Kingdoms Player
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Extreme Homosex
Gohan has AIDS
Green eggs and spam
In Memory of Jon
Le Monkey
Lumpy Space Princess
MushyMuncher
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
This looks like a project that's gonna take quite some time to develop. At the moment it looks like Matthew is the only guy with server access and he doesn't seem to have much time. This really needs to change before these kind of projects can be started.

The trade center will only be useful if payment information can be logged.

I think this project has potential but it needs further elaboration.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
UWotM8?
Village Drunk
People will just trade somewhere else if this is implemented.

I think a much simpler fix would make it a rule to get a PM before each and every trade.
 
People will just trade somewhere else if this is implemented.

I think a much simpler fix would make it a rule to get a PM before each and every trade.

There is already a rule in place, what needs to happen is a rule that states how long before each trade. For example; A pm over 24hrs is invalid and can't be used as evidence, or something like that.
 
Baby Yoda
Heidy
Hoover
Extreme Homosex
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Rio 2016
Summer 2016
Paper Trading Competition Participant
Member of the Month Winner
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Lift the trades at a time rule and I would support! This could scan skypes for hacked ones, prevent trades with users with open disputes/bans, offer an ability to log all information done on site.

Hell you should have it to where its a built in instant PM system, so that users can converse on the site rather thann skype!
Like this: http://www.vbulletin.org/forum/showthread.php?t=191448

EVerything could be a lot more secure!
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
I really don't see people taking up time doing this, so it makes it pretty ineffective overall - if not all people use it then the one trade at a time thing doesn't really help.
 
There is already a rule in place, what needs to happen is a rule that states how long before each trade. For example; A pm over 24hrs is invalid and can't be used as evidence, or something like that.

I'd support this but in the same time i wouldn't for one reason.

User A is selling 500M Eocgp.
User B Buys 100M, asking for a pm before the trade

User B goes to buy off him 400m EOC gp, but doesn't ask for a pm before the trade
User A scams him and claims to get hacked .

Just because the pm wasn't before the trade, and the "i got hacked" excuse is used doesn't mean it's invalid.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
I like it, we just have to enforce it. This wouldn't even take more than 1 minute to fill if both traders know what they want. Everyone needs to stop being lazy and start playing safe.

No safer than just requesting a PM - which takes no dev work yet achieves the same thing
 
With options to 2fa your Skype now traders could be held responsible if their account gets hacked. If you choose not to 2fa then it's not our problem.

PM before every trade works as well.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Oh god.. I knew someone was gonna come up with that defense. Look where that got us. You can also look at the CK case. This would also protect users from hacked skypes which is important.

So does a PM
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Not a bad idea, but not what a market place such as Sythe needs; more so, users wont utilise it and it will just be a waste.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
UWotM8?
Village Drunk
I like it, we just have to enforce it. This wouldn't even take more than 1 minute to fill if both traders know what they want. Everyone needs to stop being lazy and start playing safe.

People arent going to use it. People go for ease of use before safety 9 times out of 10, otherwise everyone would use OMM's and practice safe trading to begin with. People are negligent because they are lazy.

If we implement this people will just use another site with less bs involved. I know I would if I were a market member, fuck filling out a form a dozen or more times a day.
 
Not a bad idea, but not what a market place such as Sythe needs; more so, users wont utilise it and it will just be a waste.

This. No one is going to use it, I mean I can already make a super fast and easy trade with a pm. Also, say the site is down or experiencing errors, no one could trade then if you had to use the trade center.
 
Baby Yoda
Heidy
Hoover
Extreme Homosex
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Rio 2016
Summer 2016
Paper Trading Competition Participant
Member of the Month Winner
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
PHP Shit Show 2k26
it wouldnt be any worse than talking on skype/ requesting a PM on here. It would consolidate it all
 
Enforce it.. Make it known. A pm sounds like an option, not an obgligation. Before entering the market, have users read what it's about and how it can protect them.

How would you enforce it? I mean how many stickies are there saying to request a pm and trying to enforce that, yet barely anyone requests a pm. If you could enforce anything, enforce a pm and we don't need any extra work.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top