• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

[SYTHE / N4N0] Decision on restitutions please

Status
Not open for further replies.
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
It is a copyright issue in the US more than anything else. If I am given the documents I am not being given stolen goods. I am being given a copy of stolen goods. Whether or not I can publish them without a copyright claim really comes down to whether or not their is a public interest that outweighs your right to copyright.

If documents are classed as property and they are stolen then dealing in them (receiving, distributing etc.) is dealing in stolen goods. Where common law courts consider intangible property to be a real form of property I think they would tend to agree.

I would err on the side of caution and consider it to be illegal everywhere.
 
If documents are classed as property and they are stolen then dealing in them (receiving, distributing etc.) is dealing in stolen goods. Where common law courts consider intangible property to be a real form of property I think they would tend to agree.

I would err on the side of caution and consider it to be illegal everywhere.

I'd like to say that anything done on Sythe would never be brought up in court. It is far too embarrassing too bring someone too court over pixels. I've been in a courtroom where a Maplestory lover of about 300 lbs perfect typical nerd complained that his room mate stole his items. It was embarrassing and the whole courtroom about died laughing.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
I'd like to say that anything done on Sythe would never be brought up in court. It is far too embarrassing too bring someone too court over pixels. I've been in a courtroom where a Maplestory lover of about 300 lbs perfect typical nerd complained that his room mate stole his items. It was embarrassing and the whole courtroom about died laughing.

Yet dozens of cases involving pixels in the form of copied movies have gone to court and been won by major studios against average folk like yourself.
 
Yet dozens of cases involving pixels in the form of copied movies have gone to court and been won by major studios against average folk like yourself.

That's different. They have Great lawyers and Look professional.
 
Rofl ok buddy. Line up to get your bar certificate. You've passed.

This pleases me.

On a side-note I was there with the whole N4N0 Mess. I didn't participate but I did see basically everything that went down and honestly
if I was N4N0 I would have done way worse. This whole compensation thing in my opinion +1. Don't stir a pot if you can't handle the ingredients.

I'm not much of a poster I generally lurk.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Gohan has AIDS
The fundamental issue that's bothering me with this story is that N4n0 is participating in the council responsible for providing justice. There's no way anything resembling justice can be achieved so long as he is permitted to interact with pardons and disputes as an official figure.

That means that the only posts he should be able to make are identical in nature and content to those made by any other user, and that he should not make decisive statements regarding what he will or will not allow and refrain from passing judgement or making an opinion on the judgement he wishes to see carried out.

Assuming these conditions are met I expect a fair trial of all users involved would be permissible.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
If documents are classed as property and they are stolen then dealing in them (receiving, distributing etc.) is dealing in stolen goods. Where common law courts consider intangible property to be a real form of property I think they would tend to agree.

I would err on the side of caution and consider it to be illegal everywhere.

The US can not stop media outlets or websites from publishing stolen emails. Freedom of speech and freedom of the press. The only way they can is basically through a copyright claim.
 
Heidy
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
The US can not stop media outlets or websites from publishing stolen emails. Freedom of speech and freedom of the press. The only way they can is basically through a copyright claim.

This might be an interesting SFA thread.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
This might be an interesting SFA thread.

Sure thing but it really shouldn't be about law because that is just pointless for non-lawyers. Still not relevant here I do not believe.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Two Factor Authentication User
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
UWotM8?
Village Drunk
In this case it may be illegal depending on your jurisdiction. The images were stolen goods and inviting people to the chat was a form of passing the stolen goods on..k



Infracted. Keep your god awful opinions to yourself.

Thats ridiculous. Opinions arent illegal.

As someone who seems to enjoy a good debate and value opposing views, I implore you to think about what you said. Im entitled to my opinions and will voice them if I please.

Also inviting people to a chatroom is not illegal in any way shape or form regardless of jurisdiction (save the elusive internet police)distrubution of stolen/hacked pics/info ect may very well be, but that is irrelevant as that is not the point being argued.

So if someone doesn't agree with the situation it's a god awful opinion, based on which their post should be infracted? Trin is CONSTANTLY upsetting everyone with her approach and the comments she makes and you keep on defending her. Why? It was all her and Ryan who started this - things got out of hand, right. I agree with the consequences in certain cases, but the fact she is still being arrogant and stuck up and you STILL defending her is beyond me.
This.

This might be an interesting SFA thread.
Im inclined to disagree.
Infracted. Keep your godawful opinions to yourself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top