Megadeth vs. Metallica

[s3vered]

A conflict that has been around for ages. The battle of two bands, Megadeth and Metallica. How did this conflict start? Well, it all started when Metallica was first formed, when they had the original [aka the best] lineup, this included Dave Mustaine, who is now in Megadeth. How this happened? Well, he was commented as a drug addict, as well as fucking around in recording sessions, including the time when he spilt his drink on the bassists guitar. Which pissed him off, after several more incidents, Dave was fired. After a few months, he formed his own band. Which is known as Megadeth. After recording a few albums, Metallica started more conflicts, this included James Hetfield (lead vocalist of Metallica) complaining about Dave's song writing, this was especially targeted at the song 'Mechanix', which had very simular styles to Metallica's 'The Four Horsemen', but the truth was, Dave co-writed that song before he was fired. Anyway, goto metal-archives.com for more.

I prefer Megadeth, their early material was fast and purely legendary, their new stuff is good, but they changed style, which is still OK.

Metallica, I'd have to say no. Their first release was awesome, but as time went on, they changed to modern styles of rock/metal. Which got the label on their album 'Death Magnetic' the 'Worst Album of 2008', according to last.fm users.

Dave Mustaine vs. James Hetfield = Dave kicking James' little ass.

MEGADETH FTW!

 

[Kiabin]

Metallica. Only because my dad loves them and I take a lot after him.

 

[MegaMatt]

Megadeth >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Metallica
I just simply like their style better

I got my name from Megadeth

 

[7ouch]

Megadeth wins, by miles
It is sad how metallica started an entire genre of metal (with mustaine) and then stopped making it themselves.
In my opinion, i prefer Mustaines voice to Hetfields and Mustaines guitar work to Hammets.

 

[chooby lion]

Dave is just a better guitarist, I do like metallica's vocals better though. But overall Megadeth pwns..where is the poll for this?

 

[MegaMatt]

Added a poll.

 

[Kanrook]

kirk guitar rob bass james vocals and lars drumming?

how can that come 2nd to like anything?

METALLICA ALL TEH WAY

 

[7ouch]

kirk guitar rob bass james vocals and lars drumming?

how can that come 2nd to like anything?

METALLICA ALL TEH WAY

Rob looks like a gorilla, Lars is a whiny bitch, and James sucks.
Ive got something its second to IRON MAIDEN

 

[Rko0128]

Pretty much all Metallica songs, are over 7 minutes in length, and they all sound the same. What's so great about that? I don't know about you all, but I prefer some uniqueness in the music that I listen to. And if anybody replies to this disagreeing, it's probably some 10 year old whose parents bought him Guitar Hero Metallica for his Birthday.

 

[!!! TIM !!!]

In the words of The Simpsons bus driver OTTO, METALLICA RUUUUUUUUULES!!

But at the same time so does Megadeth, bit of a double edged sword.

Yet im going to say Metallica is better, just because i simply prefer the sound of their music and the length of their solos.

 

[Beliar]

I vote for Metallica, I don't really like Daves voice. Their new releases are not that good as old ones, but I don't know a band which would keep 'great' state all the time.

 

[Mistajack]

Metallica all the way. The band helped me get out of depression through its music. Also I love to play Guitar Hero Metallica on Xbox Live lol

 

[neschn]

Megadeth definitely. I love their style of Thrash more than Metallica any day.

 

[rob.//BANGGG]

Megadeth.

But who beats Megadeth and Metallica?
Who could this possibly be?!
Pantera hands mother fucking down!

 

[shadow trad3r]

Tough choice, I'd go with Metallica though because of the vocals as well as their style.

 

[Pure_Evil]

I am going to have to say Metallica, But mainly everything before "The Black Album". I still love Megadeth, i mean who could not bang there head when listening to "Holy Wars" or "Symphony of Destruction"??

Anyways, Metallica beats Megadeth in my book(by a very small string).

 

[Infernal Dave]

I don't like to compare them. I listen to them equally and I like both of their earlier styles of music.

 

[FusionGTX]

They both stink.

Listen to For The Fallen Dreams.

 

[Datsyuk4242]

They both stink.

Listen to For The Fallen Dreams.

Mediocre garbage ftw, eh?

 

[Harped]

They both stink.

Listen to For The Fallen Dreams.

You suck at life. No, but come on, how could you say that?

I say Metallica. "Metallica" also known as "The Black Album" and "Ride the Lightning" are the best 2 CD's I've ever bought, no doubt.