Well shit, I'm going to just dive in. I have no self control for abstaining.
Yeah we've had this discussion before. The problem with road building is that it isn't easy or cheap. To have a business only pay for the road they need you wouldn't have half the interstate and highway system we have now. As far as unemployment benefits goes it wouldn't really work like that. I can assure you from personal experience.
I disagree. Obviously major cities are going to need a way to provide access to them. Either the businesses decides to pay for it to bring in revenue, or a private contractor builds it and sells people a pass to drive on it like a toll road. Naturally smaller roads will spawn from the highway to bring people into town.
As far as 'unemployment benefits' go, if you're receiving more from unemployment than from what you could save on your own you're just benefiting from the system of theft. Someone's property was forcefully seized for your benefit. Just because you 'pay taxes' doesn't give you any moral right to anyone elses money, regardless of what the state says about it. A severance or injury plan would be set up with your employer, or you would need something else to fall back on (family, another job, a church, saved money, etc).
I'm not implying you did anything wrong because you paid into the system, you should receive the benefits, but imo its quite a broken system.
Because SuF didn't elaborate, I'll give you an example.
Consider a town with no road system. Now consider everybody who would benefit from a road system. (Most of the people). Suppose that if everybody who would benefit puts in $10, that a road can be built. Otherwise, to build the road on your own, it would cost you $100.
What will happen? Well, evidently, putting in $10 to have a road is beneficial to everybody. But suppose there was nobody to take the $10 and spend it on the road? Well, nobody would end up wanting to contribute the $100, so there would end up being no road, a situation where everybody is worse off.
Not really how it works.
More like you put in $10, and someone else puts in $1000 against their will. There are plenty of "greater good" arguments. Personally I don't believe that I am morally obligated/should be forced to always consider the greater good. If the something is truly has utility, instead of just being for the ;greater good', it will exist of its own merit. Either people, or businesses will organize to have it built because of how necessary it is, or some entrepreneur will try and front all the money and then just sell access to it for $20 for people that actually want it, no theft involved. If you can't convince people to do it, the answer isn't to force them.
There are plenty of things "for the greater good" that I don't subscribe to. Why not just take every cent of my money and give it to homeless shelters? Would it be nice, yes. Would it be for the greater good, yes. That doesn't mean that some politician 100's of miles away in a suit should have any damn say in the matter.
Anyways, my own point -
The real question here is what rights do we have? Why is a right to live on our own with nobody bothering us a right? Animals don't have that, and if we lived in a state of nature, we wouldn't have that, so it's naive to think that you should be able to get some land and have everybody leave you alone. Just because you wish that were the case doesn't mean it is your right.
I find the state of nature argument disagreeable. Hobbes' basically thought that anything that the state said was just/moral, obviously that isn't true.
There are alternatives built on 'social contracts' that aren't reliant on an overwhelming central force to accomplish.
It's the reason they can afford to offer the programs, but it isn't fair. Hence what you said earlier, if everyone got from the government as much or more than they put in. The upper class pays the majority of the taxes and receive few of the benefits.
As for whether or not taxes are justified, the short answer is 'No'. I never signed a contract with the government saying I would pay them anything, I never agreed to that. But you have to consider the alternatives.. No taxes = No government = Anarchy.
Anarchy isn't such a bad thing, being without rulers is preferable in my opinion. Google minarchism, seems you might fall into that camp?
How are you going to get anywhere if there is not a public path there? Trespassing is illegal and violates others rights. Have fun starving to death.
MUH ROADS, HOW WOULD WE LIVE WITHOUT THE GOBERMINT ROADS?!
Obviously trespassing on someone's land is illegal. Do you really think without the government we'd be like, "well shucks, guess I can't drive anymore!" No, probably not.