• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Counter Scamming

Status
Not open for further replies.
Person A is a scammer. If we have the ability to take back scammed goods, then we should do so.

Yes, but you can't just take advantage of someones trust for an OMM in order to steal the item. Defeats the purpose that OMMs serve.
 
There is one problem; if a scammer sees the scammer report and knows about this rule, the scammer would not use an OMM.
 
No, this isn't the same thing. Police have a different situation. The thief knows police are going to be looking to get the bike back (they do not give any trust to the police officer).

What you're suggesting is similarto entrapment, which in the real world is illegal. Note, I say similar because it isn't the exact same thing.

Entrapment is basically when a member of law enforcement goes undercover and tries to lure a person into committing a crime by establishing trust (ie, undercover agent tries to get someone to sell them drugs).

I do not believe mm's should have the ability to do this, this defeats the whole purpose and ideals that mm's serve (you are essentially the most trusted users on the forum). It isn't your responsibility to return scammed items, it is to ensure trades are completed without scamming. If person A is selling something, it is person A's responsibility to use common sense to ensure that they are not scammed (taking the necessary precautions that are available to them). If you would like to help and prevent people like person A from being scammed then you should create more awareness.

I understand where you are coming from with your idea, and it is noble that you want to return someones stolen item; However, it is wrong.

No it's not at all. You're making it sound as if a crime hasn't already occurred. This isn't related to 'luring someone into committing something'. And it's not hard to still get scammed whilst using an official middleman. You can take all the 'necessary precautions' and still lose.

You're right that it's not my responsibility to help recover items. Although that is the whole point of this suggestion... make it so I'm able to.

Difference is.. if they scammed it.. and they are trying to scam money.. I doubt they will use a OMM especially with this little "rule" in place.. This is something that should of been discussed in the Moderator lounge or Moderator forum? Discussed pirvately, no offense to you Nick.

I do like this idea.. But if you think of it, I doubt they would accept a OMM knowing this rule can be in place. More of a hassle.

That is entirely possible, yes, but if someone refuses to use an official middleman it raises a ton of suspicion.

If person A gets his account scammed then how exactly are you going to get it back? "Hey person B, Can I go on that account you just scammed, I want to make sure everything works" ?

Pretty much. I would assume it's not hard.

No. Horrible idea. If the guy who gets scammed didn't take the necessary precautions, it is not the staff/OMMs position to regain it for them. The guys punishment for scamming is a permanent ban, that's all you're supposed to do.

And you know a permanent ban does absolutely nothing... A person can take all the 'necessary precautions' and still get scammed.

Yes, but you can't just take advantage of someones trust for an OMM in order to steal the item. Defeats the purpose that OMMs serve.

You're not understanding the concept. It's not stealing; we are only recovering.

There is one problem; if a scammer sees the scammer report and knows about this rule, the scammer would not use an OMM.

Refer to above. Refusing to use an official middleman/staff member raises a lot of suspicion.
 
[N]ick;5702052 said:
You're not understanding the concept. It's not stealing; we are only recovering.

I understand the concept perfectly.

The method you use to recover it, is stealing. Why is it stealing? Because the aim is to get the person who is in possession of the item to trust you, and convince them that your aim of the trade is to help it be completed successfully.

You cannot give OMM's this right, it would contradict the whole purpose that they serve. That purpose, is being the most trusted members on the forum, who do not break trust.

If you really want to do this, then you can introduce a counter scamming rank, where members of said rank are undercover (rank is hidden but have staff privledges) and try to scam back scammed items but do not involve OMMs in the trades (because then it would have to be a legitimate trade).
 
Pool Shark
Village Drunk
<3 n4n0
Battleship Champion
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
I remember the situation and I think you made the right decision.

However, I wish to confront this.
If the recovered items cannot be returned to the original owner, the items will be sold and all funds donated to Sythe.org
Contact should be made with the original owner before attempting to recover said items and/or it should be made evident that contact can be made with the original owner. In selling the items and having the funds donated to Sythe, both Users A and B would have been scammed by Sythe.

Besides that, I support.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Yes, but you can't just take advantage of someones trust for an OMM in order to steal the item. Defeats the purpose that OMMs serve.

Scammers do not deserve the right to trust OMMs.
 
This is the reason I do not trust anyone but myself and a select few from sythe.org....

Scamming is bad. No. Bad suggestion.

I definitely will never consider to use an OMM ever again.
 
Nick, I understand where you're coming from. Scammers are scum. They are lowlifes completely undeserving of sympathy or privilege. However, I still think we shouldn't tarnish the golden image of OMMs and Staff. Even if we call it "recovery", there is still lying involved. Who knows, lying once can convert people.

I understand why people would readily support this suggestion because it yields results that immediately satisfy your desires. We all need to realize that this would be complicated to setup and would be one more responsibility for the staff. Think of how many people get scammed a day. There are dozens of reports that aren't answered because the staff is busy. Will it help if they need to spend helping you trick a scammer into giving you your account back?

I personally believe the solution is education, awareness, and a personal sense of safety. We all get tricked sometimes. By being smart and reading peoples' personalities, we can minimize risks and losses. We should take responsibility upon ourselves as members to reduce the amount of scammers who are successful each day. This will lighten the load on the mods and perhaps they will consider participating in "recoveries" for the extremely dire issues.

Just my two cents, off the top of my head.
 
I understand the concept perfectly.

The method you use to recover it, is stealing. Why is it stealing? Because the aim is to get the person who is in possession of the item to trust you, and convince them that your aim of the trade is to help it be completed successfully.

You cannot give OMM's this right, it would contradict the whole purpose that they serve. That purpose, is being the most trusted members on the forum, who do not break trust.

If you really want to do this, then you can introduce a counter scamming rank, where members of said rank are undercover (rank is hidden but have staff privledges) and try to scam back scammed items but do not involve OMMs in the trades (because then it would have to be a legitimate trade).

It's not considered stealing if the person got his account stolen and wants the official to recover it back for him?

So your trying to say that OMM can't gain anymore privileges? Please tell me who are you to say that just because an OMM were started off as only to be allowed to make sure trades go successful that they can't gain anything that's all there allowed to do? That's like saying if you start off a police officer as a traffic guard that you can't get promoted you have to stay a traffic guard forever ?

I Support This Idea 100%...
 
I'm still not clear on this.

I trade an account to somone, they scam me by recovering the account somehow.

So how does "staff/OMM" get it back by saying I'll buy the account from you for whatever, and use a trusted MM and then the MM gets the account back for me?

How obvious is that?
 
So your trying to say that OMM can't gain anymore privileges? Please tell me who are you to say that just because an OMM were started off as only to be allowed to make sure trades go successful that they can't gain anything that's all there allowed to do? That's like saying if you start off a police officer as a traffic guard that you can't get promoted you have to stay a traffic guard forever ?

You didn't understand at all what I was saying, your analogy also doesn't apply to OMMs.
 
[N]ick;5702052 said:
Refer to above. Refusing to use an official middleman/staff member raises a lot of suspicion.

That is true, but then people will want to use an OMM for every trade as there is a possibility that the account got be scammed and this will stop people from using ordinary MM's and then people will not be able to complete their applications or whatever.
 
No. Horrible idea. If the guy who gets scammed didn't take the necessary precautions, it is not the staff/OMMs position to regain it for them. The guys punishment for scamming is a permanent ban, that's all you're supposed to do.

Perfect point.. It is there own responsibility to use an OMM, if they are not there risking there own account or whatever.. So it's there fault in the end.. They are responsible for it.. End of..

Maybe if an OMM is used and account is recovered by the person selling the account, and this is proven the OMM is allowed to attempt to recover the account for the buyer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top