Yes. You're not allowed to take back more than you got scammed for, that would just make you a scammer. Although I don't believe you should have to pay them back for any levels they gained on the account, then we're just getting into something pretty trivial IMO. If you sold someone a level 3 skiller, and they charged you back, and then you recovered the account and it was level 200, I think that you shouldn't have to pay your scammer for the time they put into the account. But any gold they had wasn't yours to begin with. This was longer than I meant it to be, in conclusion, repay the gold, don't repay for levels gained/time put into the account