• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Re: Prize boxes

  • Thread starter Thread starter S
  • Start date Start date

Option 1 or Option 2

  • Option 1

    Votes: 14 63.6%
  • Option 2

    Votes: 8 36.4%

  • Total voters
    22
Status
Not open for further replies.

S

noobies

Retired Global Moderator
You Shall Not Pass
Crabby
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Sythe Gold
3,618
Messages
15,907
Two Factor Authentication User
Thread for reference: http://www.sythe.org/sythe-org-news/1707915-sythe-prizeboxes.html

I'm open to the idea of giving some prizeboxes to existing donors so they don't miss out. Maybe make a poll/thread in the suggestion section so it can be discussed.


What I suggest is make it so all existing $200+ Donors receive prize boxes above the initial required $100 Donation. This would also act as an added donation benefit/perk, as there are not that many at current, for $200+.


Option 1:

I.e, $400 Donor now = 6 prize boxes (300/50), $300 Donor now = 4 prize boxes. Etc.

Hopefully it would appease higher donors as well, as they would receive increased prize boxes.



Option 2:

If that seems to generous, then make it for every second $100 amounted donation.

I.e, $400 Donor now = 4 prize Boxes ($100-$200 = 2 and $300-$400 = 2) etc.
 
even though It won't benefit me it would seem fair for the donators that donated over 100$.
edit; Second one seems a bit more fair, because with the first option people like arcus will get 50 random miniranks which seems a bit excessive, in my opinion.
 
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Maybe one box per $50 donated after 100 for a maximum of 5 boxes? Show appreciation for past support but not flood the market.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Halloween 2013
Christmas 2013
Option two is fair I think.

At the end of the day, they donated before it was introduced. Just because of previous donations, that doesn't mean they are entitled to anything which comes out as an update.

Option 2 presents a happy medium for me, you acknowledge their prior contributions by giving them Prize boxes also, but don't flood the market by handing certain users 3-4+ Boxes.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Prize boxes just released and you make a thread about this already.

What about option 3: Remove prize boxes entirely.

I find it interesting you hide your donation rank to avoid comments supporting bias.

Requesting lock.


I suggest you actually read what's written and why, opposed to jumping the gun.

I'm open to the idea of giving some prizeboxes to existing donors so they don't miss out. Maybe make a poll/thread in the suggestion section so it can be discussed.


I've had my Donor rank hidden for close to 1 year now. What on earth are you spewing? Go webcache my posts from the past months to a year, you won't see my Donor rank.

Jesus Christ, for an Ex-Moderator you sure are a moron.
 
Maybe one box per $50 donated after 100 for a maximum of 5 boxes? Show appreciation for past support but not flood the market.

This, we have donators who sit at $2100, $2500 ect, if they get 1 for every 50 after 100 that is going to be 40+ miniranks for each donator coming into this new addition..
 
SOTMx5
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
In Memory of Jon
When the new donor ranks came out, did they say to old donors : You cant get the new donor ranks because you donated before the update. No they told the donors that they can have it if they want to or keep their old donor rank. Same thing here.. Saying that the donors cant have prizeboxes because they didnt donate after the update isnt fair. We should reward them because they are the most loyal people on Sythe! :)
 
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
Maybe one box per $50 donated after 100 for a maximum of 5 boxes? Show appreciation for past support but not flood the market.
I think this is the best solution. Can you add it to the op? If we flood the minirank market with hordes of miniranks, they won't be worth enough to encourage people to donate in $50 chunks in the first place.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Option 3? None? where's dat. Poll doesn't fulfil the role of a poll if it's bias.
 
Pool Shark
Village Drunk
<3 n4n0
Battleship Champion
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
I've had my Donor rank hidden for close to 1 year now. What on earth are you spewing? Go webcache my posts from the past months to a year, you won't see my Donor rank.
Failure to disclose this fact suggests bias. Furthermore, before an official poll can, or rather should be made, a suggestions thread gathering input from the community for probable changes or updates should be made.
Jesus Christ, for an Ex-Moderator you sure are a moron.
I didn't know the rank suggested E-genius. You are too kind.
I'm aware. This post (and a more detailed one above) was in response to my initial questions.

Chill out. Relax.

Just make a thread where users can post suggestions first, collect the results, and move on to creating an (un)official poll.
There's no need to expedite the process. Good points and reason(s) behind those points will need to be discussed before implementation is considered.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Poképedia
Cool Kid
Le Kingdoms Player
Jake the Dog
Green eggs and spam
Rupee
RsProd
OG Club
Tom Black
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Bojack
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Oktoberfest 2013
Pizza Muncher
Dunce
Le
DIAF
Le Monkey
We Are Legion
Easter 2013
Village Drunk
Ninja
Brony
Dragon Ball
420 yolo swag blaze it fuck the popo legalize it anyone got some chips
Discord Verified
Voted, I don't understand why ya'll think it's fair for people who have already donated hundreds of dollars to not receive the prize boxes that they're qualified for.
 
Detective
Trole
Pool Shark
Le Kingdoms Player
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
This, we have donators who sit at $2100, $2500 ect, if they get 1 for every 50 after 100 that is going to be 40+ miniranks for each donator coming into this new addition..

What's your point? Users who have freely donated thousands of dollars of their own money deserve the same treatment, dont you think?
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Supporting Business
In Memory of Jon
Top Striker
Think about it, if you're against this you're trying to justify penalizing people simply because they donated hundreds or thousands of dollars of their own money to this website before they even had an incentive to donate so much.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
MushyMuncher
Pokémon Trainer
St. Patrick's Day 2013
Easter 2013
Lumpy Space Princess
Sythe RSPS Player
Halloween 2013
Christmas 2013
Gohan has AIDS
<3 n4n0
Tortoise Penis
Heidy
UWotM8?
Shitting Rainbow
Discord Verified
Extreme Homosex
Former OMM
Hey... this isnt a fun rank
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Potamus
Spyro
St. Patrick's Day 2014
Supporting Business
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
I think symbolic 1-3 prize boxes for $200+ donors up to #1 donor wouldnt hurt tbh, but defintiely not prize box every $100 donation like it's stated in option 2
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
The only people who care about miniranks are the community active members, most have which have donated big sums. The likes of you and I (all of you participating in this and other community matters) and if everyone just gets a bundle of miniranks off the bat then it just nullifies the whole thing IMO.

Regardless of justification or reasoning, a fair poll still needs to cover all (or most possible) grounds to reflect the community's thoughts. If you say "oh look 100 people want X" when in fact most don't but it was closest to none, it's not really a fair poll or result.
 
Christmas 2013
Just make a thread where users can post suggestions first, collect the results, and move on to creating an (un)official poll.
There's no need to expedite the process. Good points and reason(s) behind those points will need to be discussed before implementation is considered.

Regardless of justification or reasoning, a fair poll still needs to cover all (or most possible) grounds to reflect the community's thoughts. If you say "oh look 100 people want X" when in fact most don't but it was closest to none, it's not really a fair poll or result.

I agree with both of these points. This poll doesn't represent enough of the community's thoughts. Because the poll was made upon thread creation, it reflected only Sellerman's views, initially, until or unless he edited his OP and the options underneath it. And, with this ability to edit the poll options in the OP, the votes users cast for option 1 or 2 may not agree with new versions of the poll options that lists certain situations per the OP because it was edited.

I, personally believe that individuals who have made large donations should receive some number of prizeboxes or certain display of thanks just as new donations will. I do not know what would be fair in relation to the minirank market and its condition, so I won't comment on a particular number per $50 donations made.
 
What's your point? Users who have freely donated thousands of dollars of their own money deserve the same treatment, dont you think?

It's not that it's not fair, but looking at the large amount of people who would be getting miniranks could "flood" the minirank market if not ruin it completely.
 
No to everything. No need to be "Fair" these are donations. This is incentive to donate, if one has already donated before now, shit happens. This is an unprofessional poll/thread also.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top