- Joined
- Jan 15, 2006
- Sythe Gold
- 0
- Messages
- 6,989
I do not know the reasons behind the bans issued to certain users who raised discussion about an admin, nor do I care, and neither am I disputing them.
However, the way the staff manages situations reflects strongly on the site, and the recent situation seems to have been handled rather poorly: first, in hiding such a heated topic after most of the community viewed it, with no public response; and second, by encouraging users to speak freely on the topic, only to have several of the more outspoken ones banned afterwards with no public disclosure of their ban reasons. Consciously or not (and true or not), you've made the situation worse by filling the image of unjust censorship perfectly. The only things these actions accomplished are suspicion and whispers propagating the same information the site tried to suppress: a fact evident by the queries posed in a staff member's intro thread, "where did [username here] go?" thread, requests for answers in this forum, etc, and which I'd hazard a guess led to the subsequent actions of the members who were banned. (Unlike Cfrey, I don't imagine Tyro drawing up drama merely for drama's sake; rather, as a former admin, I would assume he merely felt an obligation to speak out against what he perceived to be a significant problem - something I myself might do - and which only escalated when his concerns were summarily dismissed without a response. Significantly, the fact that he initially asked for Sythe's permission and posted from his account, as opposed to a decoy leecher, suggests his original intent was not malicious at all.)
I know the staff well enough to believe the bans were warranted, since the outcry from individual staff members would have been thunderous, otherwise. However, I'd hazard that the bans would not have been necessary if the situation were handled more delicately in the first place. More generally, the site needs to be more aware of the image it presents, especially when it comes to such sensitive issues: my confidence in staff is derived only from the time I've served on it. The majority of users are not in the same position.
I do not support full transparency, but there are times when at least limited transparency is appropriate. I would argue this situation - accusations against an admin that have been dug up time and time again - is one of them.
However, the way the staff manages situations reflects strongly on the site, and the recent situation seems to have been handled rather poorly: first, in hiding such a heated topic after most of the community viewed it, with no public response; and second, by encouraging users to speak freely on the topic, only to have several of the more outspoken ones banned afterwards with no public disclosure of their ban reasons. Consciously or not (and true or not), you've made the situation worse by filling the image of unjust censorship perfectly. The only things these actions accomplished are suspicion and whispers propagating the same information the site tried to suppress: a fact evident by the queries posed in a staff member's intro thread, "where did [username here] go?" thread, requests for answers in this forum, etc, and which I'd hazard a guess led to the subsequent actions of the members who were banned. (Unlike Cfrey, I don't imagine Tyro drawing up drama merely for drama's sake; rather, as a former admin, I would assume he merely felt an obligation to speak out against what he perceived to be a significant problem - something I myself might do - and which only escalated when his concerns were summarily dismissed without a response. Significantly, the fact that he initially asked for Sythe's permission and posted from his account, as opposed to a decoy leecher, suggests his original intent was not malicious at all.)
I know the staff well enough to believe the bans were warranted, since the outcry from individual staff members would have been thunderous, otherwise. However, I'd hazard that the bans would not have been necessary if the situation were handled more delicately in the first place. More generally, the site needs to be more aware of the image it presents, especially when it comes to such sensitive issues: my confidence in staff is derived only from the time I've served on it. The majority of users are not in the same position.
I do not support full transparency, but there are times when at least limited transparency is appropriate. I would argue this situation - accusations against an admin that have been dug up time and time again - is one of them.





































