Even though I play both sports to a good extent, I'd have to say baseball is an overall better sport than soccer. Reasons:
Baseball requires you to hit a 90+ mile/hour ball with a slender bat, which isn't as easy as it seems. The ball also will be altering its path to throw you off as a better, so you have to have great hand-eye coordination.
On the field and off, you need to keep your head in the game, thinking about what you are going to do if the ball comes to you.
Baseball has infielders make fantastic defensive plays from hard, volatile, ground balls, and make a good throw to first in time to get the out. All those parts of a play added together will just get ONE out, just one. Pitchers as well have to throw speedy and accurate pitches, which requires great strength and athleticism.
I've also seen from this thread that the judgment about baseball players is that they are fat, well, tbh, most aren't. A lot come from the Dominican Republic and they put in their own sweat and blood to make it to the MLB and they don't make it looking like Fat Albert.
In soccer, from what I've seen and done, the main skills of the game are exercised from your legs and hips. You don't even focus much on your arms or torso, when baseball players do. The main aspect of it is running, and running also occurs a lot in baseball too.
In soccer, the game often ends up tied 0-0, no winner, as it is a very hard game to score in, while in baseball, the average score in a game is 5-3.
In soccer, you just kick the ball around back and forth, while in baseball, you do a combination of hitting, fielding, running, throwing, and thinking.
For these reasons, baseball > soccer