• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Character Traits

And this is why I don't post in the SFA section lol. I suppose you are right.

He makes everybody look bad lol.

Certainly.

Honesty, integrity, and courage are the three core most values. You might as well not exist without those three, for all the happiness your life without them will bring you.

Wouldn't none of those traits exist without motive power?
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
He makes everybody look bad lol.
No, I just hold people to the standards they pretend to support.

If you claim X is an honest judgement, and I ask for you reasoning and you can give me none then I'm going to accuse you of intellectual fraud. If all you have to back your claims is "well thats my opinion" then this is just a waste of time. No one wants to hear prejudice repeated 1000 times over, it advances no cause but its own.

Wouldn't none of those traits exist without motive power?
I considered that. You might be right, however it is probably possible to be virtuous without actually doing very much acting. Although I suppose force of will factors into the steadfastness of non-action or passive action.

I suppose I would consider it to be less important because it tends to manifest of its own accord from the first three, which you definitely have control / choice over.

True, which do you feel are least important?

In my opinion the least important vitures are the superficial ones: Charm, liberality, temperance, majesty. Someone who is not charming or generous with his time, who has a tendency to excess (say in his work) and does not care that his work is not of greatness to others (although I think it is important that his work be of greatness to himself) may still be an entirely virtuous person.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
I don't think that's a virtue per se. I guess it could be a character trait. But it sounds more like a combination of the first four.

To clarify: virtues are those things which denote the preferable or 'good' direction of a choice or category of choices. It isn't a choice to respect yourself or respect others; if it was then everyone would just respect themselves and there would be no mental illness or shame or guilt.

The virtue lies between the two extremes, which respect does have. Too little I already mentioned, and too much would also work. Respecting yourself too much may make you seem self concerned or cocky, and respecting others too much might diminish your self worth.

There is a choice to respect yourself and others as you control what you do. You may need to have the force of will to be able to, but that makes sense as you are not virtuous unless you have all the virtues.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
My first inclination is to add compassion, steadfastness, and patience.
Define "excellence in deeds" as it doesn't strike me as a virtue, but rather a result of exercising these virtues.

I added it as a bit of an after thought, referring to attention to detail / quality of work. Which I am not sure is covered under any other category.

For example you might undertake a great work: such as a grand building. And the building may be honest, as in build on solid foundations. And you may also have applied considerable integrity in its design. But aesthetically, is what you have created simply another building or is it an excellent building. Excellent in both its form and its function?

The virtue lies between the two extremes, which respect does have. Too little I already mentioned, and too much would also work. Respecting yourself too much may make you seem self concerned or cocky, and respecting others too much might diminish your self worth.

This was certainly Aristotle's argument for how virtues come about. But I would quickly point out that its the golden mean fallacy to suggest anything that sits between two extremes is a virtue. For example: halfway between benevolence and murder would be randomly poisoning people; and I don't think anyone would agree that this is a virtue.

There is a choice to respect yourself and others as you control what you do. You may need to have the force of will to be able to, but that makes sense as you are not virtuous unless you have all the virtues.

This, I don't think so. If you refer to "respect for yourself and others" as a form of self-discipline, then this is not true respect, but mere compliance. Respect, like love, is an involuntary response to those traits you value when exhibited in yourself and others. If another person simply lacks virtue then there is no way to respect that person. The best you could do is counterfeit respect, which is much worse than none at all because it compromises your own honesty and integrity.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
This was certainly Aristotle's argument for how virtues come about. But I would quickly point out that its the golden mean fallacy to suggest anything that sits between two extremes is a virtue. For example: halfway between benevolence and murder would be randomly poisoning people; and I don't think anyone would agree that this is a virtue.

Very true. I missed that.


This, I don't think so. If you refer to "respect for yourself and others" as a form of self-discipline, then this is not true respect, but mere compliance. Respect, like love, is an involuntary response to those traits you value when exhibited in yourself and others. If another person simply lacks virtue then there is no way to respect that person. The best you could do is counterfeit respect, which is much worse than none at all because it compromises your own honesty and integrity.

I looked up respect and Wikipedia stated:

Respect denotes both a positive feeling of esteem for a person or other entity (such as a nation or a religion), and also specific actions and conduct representative of that esteem.

I missed the first part in my thoughts and that presents a problem for me, as I have been exposed to Quaker values through my schooling which say that you should treat everyone with the same amount of respect.

Socially, the feeling you have for a person does not seem to matter in terms of respect, such as with teachers in many schools. You are told from a young age that you must respect your teacher, who you may hate, and if you do not you get in trouble. So it seems to me that socially it is better for you to respect people, no matter your feelings for them and if you do dislike or hate someone and still are able to respect them that is a higher form of respect if its not just an act.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Socially, the feeling you have for a person does not seem to matter in terms of respect, such as with teachers in many schools. You are told from a young age that you must respect your teacher, who you may hate, and if you do not you get in trouble. So it seems to me that socially it is better for you to respect people, no matter your feelings for them and if you do dislike or hate someone and still are able to respect them that is a higher form of respect if its not just an act.

Right, but this is not a virtue, it is just a survival strategy. Unless you are really psychologically screwed up this type of respect is always counterfeit respect for the purpose of compliance.

And of course it's worth pointing out here that virtue is only possible where there is choice. As a second class citizen stuck in a state enforced "school" with "teachers" there is no choice for the student, so the situation is amoral, since morality only applies where it can be reasonably argued that there is free choice (that is: decisions made under duress are not subject to moral analysis since they are not free choices).
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Right, but this is not a virtue, it is just a survival strategy. Unless you are really psychologically screwed up this type of respect is always counterfeit respect for the purpose of compliance.

Do you feel that there is a place in between respect and disrespect where you are more neutral?

And of course it's worth pointing out here that virtue is only possible where there is choice. As a second class citizen stuck in a state enforced "school" with "teachers" there is no choice for the student, so the situation is amoral, since morality only applies where there is reasonably free choice.

You still have the choice to respect the teacher or not and face the punishment just like something like murder. You have the choice, only with one you still have a punishment.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Do you feel that there is a place in between respect and disrespect where you are more neutral?

Well sure, most people fall into that category. Why are you asking me, just look at your own disposition toward people. At least when I look at people I assume everyone is neutral tending toward good unless there is evidence to suggest otherwise.

You still have the choice to respect the teacher or not and face the punishment just like something like murder. You have the choice, only with one you still have a punishment.
Well this isn't free choice. There is still the capacity to choose under duress, but it is usually considered that morality doesn't apply. Ultimately you aren't calling the shots, someone else is.

So the typical example is that someone gives you a gun, points a larger gun at you, and says "kill this innocent person X, or I will kill you."

Philosophically and legally speaking we generally do not consider this act (murder under duress) to be the action of the person who pulls the trigger, but rather the action of the person holding the larger gun. I think it would be quite unjust of you to suggest that the one pulling the trigger should have given up his own life to save the life of the other. I certainly would not give up my life to save the life of the other. If you suggest that I should then try reversing the roles: The gunman takes the gun from me and gives it to innocent X, and then tells him to shoot me. Should he now be shot, whereas before he should not have been?

The answer is: it's a state of nature. Action under duress is a state of nature, morality does not apply. Morality can only apply where there is free choice.
Also: Since each human's life is necessarily worth more to him than the lives of those others around him, it is counter-natural to expect of him to sacrifice his life for others. It is each in our nature to go on surviving, and this is one of the core purposes of ethics. So again, it would be in contradiction with the reason for maintaining a code of ethics if ethics dictated that we must die; In that event I would rather have no ethics; Often summarized as "no one is asking you to starve for your ethics." Again: state of nature.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Well sure, most people fall into that category. Why are you asking me, just look at your own disposition toward people. At least when I look at people I assume everyone is neutral tending toward good unless there is evidence to suggest otherwise.

If there is a middle ground between respect and disrespect where you do not respect them and do not disrespect them, then I will agree that it isn't a virtue as you can just be neutral.

Well this isn't free choice. There is still the capacity to choose under duress, but it is usually considered that morality doesn't apply. Ultimately you aren't calling the shots, someone else is.

So the typical example is that someone gives you a gun, points a larger gun at you, and says "kill this innocent person X, or I will kill you."

Philosophically and legally speaking we generally do not consider this act (murder under duress) to be the action of the person who pulls the trigger, but rather the action of the person holding the larger gun. I think it would be quite unjust of you to suggest that the one pulling the trigger should have given up his own life to save the life of the other. I certainly would not give up my life to save the life of the other. If you suggest that I should then try reversing the roles: The gunman takes the gun from me and gives it to innocent X, and then tells him to shoot me. Should he now be shot?

The answer is: it's a state of nature. Action under duress is a state of nature, morality does not apply. Morality can only apply where there is free choice.

Oh, that does make sense. I have never really studied ethics, though I will next fall, so I do not greatly understand the underlying concepts to base an argument on.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
If there is a middle ground between respect and disrespect where you do not respect them and do not disrespect them, then I will agree that it isn't a virtue as you can just be neutral.

As I said earlier: respect is an involuntary response to certain types of virtue, not a virtue in itself.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Ah. That's actually a good point, I should've picked up on it. Maybe "conscientiousness" or "diligence" would be a more appropriate articulation, but I'm not sure.

Yeah, although both of those imply functional adequacy. Excellence is more about building it to a higher and moreover unique standard set by one's own ambitions.
 
Majesty (greatness of presence)

Most people who I meet that have that sort of 'majestic presence' seem to be self-centered. I don't know if that's really a good character trait, as I never seem to meet the people who can control it properly without seeming extremely egoistic.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Majesty (greatness of presence)

Most people who I meet that have that sort of 'majestic presence' seem to be self-centered. I don't know if that's really a good character trait, as I never seem to meet the people who can control it properly without seeming extremely egoistic.

There are many good traits that are present in people with undesirable personalities. Pride is a good trait but arrogance is not. That people who possess pride are sometimes arrogant doesn't mean that pride is inherently bad, it's the person's lack of the virtue of temperance that causes the trait to be expressed in a poor way.

The terms: self-centered, egoistic, arrogant, pride. Both of you please define before using.

In my experience these are no-meaning terms or 'anticoncepts' just projected onto people to express a prejudice (usually jealousy or envy).
 
In the current climate I am valuing honest above all others.

Although I am embracing temperance, humility and motive power aswell.
 
Those traits which indicate good character in a person:
  1. Integrity
  2. Courage
  3. Honesty
  4. Motive power / Force of will
  5. Excellence in deeds
  6. Temperance (aversion to general excess)
  7. Majesty (greatness of presence)
  8. Liberality (soulful egoistic generosity)
  9. Humility (knowledge of one's lack of knowledge)
  10. Gentleness (aversion to violence and incivility)
  11. Charm
(Most from Aristotelian virtue ethics.)

Personally I strive after all of these traits. And these are the traits I look for most in my friends and family.

Discuss their applicability to your life; those which you agree with, those which you do not agree with, any you think should be added.

Some of these traits seem slightly contradictory.
 
Care to elaborate?

In a real life situation I find it hard to believe that a person with majesty would have humility.

When you just state the definition of the words I suppose it makes sense.

However, in a real life context I just don't think that people can really have all of those traits (at the same time) without them conflicting with each other. Unless of course the person in bi-polar.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
In a real life situation I find it hard to believe that a person with majesty would have humility.

Majesty is a trait perceived by others (projected outward), whereas humility is a trait which is very personal (inward). I don't see that they are mutually exclusive, although by some common definitions perhaps they might be.

To be more precise, humility is dedication to the Socratic method, whereas majesty is simply having an awe inspiring reputation -- generally as a result of either being exceptionally well educated and well liked, or as a result of having done great things.

However, in a real life context I just don't think that people can really have all of those traits (at the same time) without them conflicting with each other. Unless of course the person in bi-polar.

Well this would be a problem, if they are all virtues. So maybe you could come up with an example of a contradiction?
 
Back
Top