• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Ironman services

Easter 2021
Extreme Homosex
Homosex
Hoover
Nitro Booster
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Potamus
yeah I totally get that its a shit ton of work especially for all day work, but maybe for like niche work on high level HCIM's or max bank irons etc where it is even more important than usual
I'd have to disagree with this. Every account should be treated with the same amount of care. I personally treat all my clients as if their accounts were HCIM. I play it safe because this is not my stuff - it's theirs. Even if we were to record, who's to say a provider couldn't just take the stuff after recording? Sadly it's not that difficult, plus it's easy to just fake a video. Having been staff on a private server before, I've seen it countless times (both convincing and not!) so I just don't see this working.
 
So, someone I had in an open ticket referenced this, and so i bothered to look into it. Never really posted here, but recently got into doing ironman services AFTER, i paid about 4b to get my ironman a 1.6b total bank.

When i work on an order i make sure it is explicitly clear, only one person at a time is allowed on the account. Worker included. When workers switch, they change the password. There is only one person allowed at a time. The moment the person asks to play during some time, i state explicitly it violates our TOS, If they choose to continue playing on it so long as they note the order will be delayed, and that the server itselfs has no liability for bans or lost items. It is very hard to prove anything. Who took what, you want a player to go to every death mechanic place to prove the items are not hidden there? Zulrah, tob, chambers, vorkath, grotesque guardians,hespori or litierally in some gravestone in BFE.

Ive also noticed a trend when people claim "scamming" regardless whether is actually realistic, the provider will always in some way offer a partial refund. Its impossible to tell what happened in the account. The usual TOS states, they are not liable for literally anything, yet scythe holds them accountable for it regardless of individual TOS. I say this because, one of the workers from an unnamed south american country, (cough cough) was accused of scamming when they phsyically didnt have power/internet. yet they were still refunded.

Regardless of anything else if you want solutions to how ironbanks should be handled. some solutions to consider are: The worker should post screenshots before and after every session they do this should include the last time the account was logged into. It can at the very least give a time frame. The customer should acknowledge they forfit the protection TOS offers if they wish to play on it during that time. And heres a reaally nutty solution. The provider can take full 100% responsibility if the owner of the account choses to let the server enable the authenticator on thier side. So it quite literally can only be the fault of the sever itself for any misplaced item, ban or mute on the account. Idk. This seems to be a place to spitball ideas, so while the latter being very extreeme might be a good solution to say ironmen who have a b+ bank. as its almost impossible to say what that bill is worth in terms of time and cost.
 
Last edited:
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
@whatskraken
Happy first Sythe post. You also mention a couple of interesting ideas for how we can address these issues in the future.

Basically what I'm hoping will happen is:
(1) Staff will provide basic guidance on how to approach these sorts of agreements. This will probably be a sticky, a news post, or both. You correctly bring up that several things could have been done to make the Kash situation safer for both parties involved before the trade was initated, for example not sharing the account between owner and service provider. That said, Sythe will always allow people to conduct risky business agreements, and so...
(2) ToS will stabilize and standardize over time. I've mentioned in the past that I want a "market" for ToS; in other words, competitors would compete on price and ToS (and business practices and things like that) in order to attract buyers and maintain their reputation. It's not too different than issues with RWT bans five or ten years ago. Originally, only a few people knew how to RWT effectively, but eventually everyone caught on. We've started relying on ToS relatively recently in the grand scheme of things on Sythe, and not all service providers are on the same level yet. Hopefully this will change quicker if we achieve point 1 in the near future.

But those are just my thoughts. If there are more actionable things we can do I'd be curious to hear people's ideas.
 
Christmas 2015
Discord Verified
Homosex
Hoover
Nitro Booster
Just food for thought but everyone whose eager to push blame back on the service provider for long video proofs are they also willing to pay the premium for a more expensive service?

People often hunt for the cheapest service they can get when really you need to not only consider the trust worthyness of the owner but also the worker.

Ultimately some level of trust is required between provider and client and as an iron you are entrusting something that can't easily be replaced to another person. Would you choose someone more trust worthy or someone as cheap as possible?

If your wanting the cheapest possible solution I think the client potentially bares some of the risk here as someone who values there time more and is trying to build a bussiness won't throw it away so easily.
 
WoW Classic
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Lately we have seen multiple disputes about ironman services.
The most recent one being Kash
As a service provider who also offers Ironman services, I have many concerns regarding these disputes.
I will be using the dispute linked above as an example for this thread.

TOS
To start with, the user aknowledges the TOS, ( did not say I agree or anything ), however, Kash was told that a HCIM ( or Ironman ) can't really agree to the term ' We are not responsible for any wealth lost or missing'. Ok, so TOS does not realy matter in these disputes.

Proof
The disputer ( buyer ) did not have any proof that the provider got rid of the items. The provider can proof via Automatic Runelite Screenshots, and with multiple confirmations of the buyer, that the items were indeed obtained. Neither the buyer nor the service provider can however proof that the other party got rid of the items. The only proof that's here is that the items are no longer on the account.

Mod replies
Another point from a mod involved is ' If you're responsible for collecting items and those disappear, it seems reasonable to hold the service provider accountable for that loss.'
I'd say Yes and No. It makes sense that because the buyer pays for items, the seller has to deliver them. However, there's proof that the items actually were obtained.

Red Chins ( case specific )
As far as I know, the red chins can not be transferred to another account unless de-ironed ( they don't drop on pvp death and cant be drop traded ). Even if the service provider for some reason wanted to steal like 50$, it would make no sense to drop the chins.

Possible regrets
As an account seller, I do know that people sometimes regret their purchase. Some people buy on impulse. Other people think they will enjoy a specific account build, but find out later that they actually do not enjoy it. And other people buy an account when they have the money, but stuff in real life happens and they urgently need somem money.

This also happens with services. I do very large service oders, which sometimes take up to 6-12 months to complete. It has happened that customers ordered a lot of 99s when they had a lot of interest in the game, but months later quit runescape and asked to cancel the remainder of the service.

Conclusion
Disputes like these are hard to handle in my opinion, as there's no proof of who lost the items.
The service provider could drop trade the items to make some quick extra money.
The buyer could drop trade the items to basically get a full refund from the order. Especially after this case, more and more people will know about the ruling and what is to stop them from claiming the service provider lost the items, when in reality they just wanted a full refund? 1.4b is a lot of money. Maybe because of Covid the customer was tight on money and saw this as the only solution? Maybe he has found someone else who can do the service for much cheaper?

These are just my objective views here. I just think the system is flawed regarding these ironman services. The exact same problem is with Hardcore status lost, or items from the bank gone ( when the service is just skills/quests, not item gathering ). The ruling however seems to always be in favor of the buyer.

Solution
The only solution I see here, is TOS. Something as 'Even though this is an ironman service and you can not remove your wealth, in the event of any items missing, we are not held responsible'.
It might be kinda unfair, as this could then be exploited as well, but I don't see any other solution.

If nothing is done, any customer could just get a full refund by removing wealth themselves...
If nothing is done, I no longer feel safe offering ironman services and until something is done, I will no longer be offering any ironman services on Sythe.

TLDR: IMO the system is flawed where a buyer COULD droptrade items at any given time and claim a full refund from the service provider. Service providers HAVE to have a way to protect themselves from these possible events.

There's 2 options,

#1 He needed the gold and was hoping he could double up on it.

#2 He was a good client and got scammed losing 1.4b.

There's only 2 ways to flip the coin, lets just hope users focus on providers who are actually trusted with tons of ironman feedback from now on.

Yellow Hat
 
WoW Classic
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Also as cheap as gold is now its like .45-.48 I doubt an ironman who spent thousands of hours would trade it for $450 especially when paying more than that for a service < almost the same.

Yellow Hat
 
Shuppet
Starmie
Pidgeotto
Wurmple
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Pokémon Trainer
March Madness
Poképedia
Discord Verified
Nitro Booster
Easter 2023
The Glizz
Two Factor Authentication User
Easter 2025
Valentine's Day 2025
Halloween 2024
St. Patrick's Day 2025
Christmas 2024
Heidy
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Lawrence
Tons of Damage
Summer 2025
Easter 2022
Verified Ironman
There's 2 options,

#1 He needed the gold and was hoping he could double up on it.

#2 He was a good client and got scammed losing 1.4b.

There's only 2 ways to flip the coin, lets just hope users focus on providers who are actually trusted with tons of ironman feedback from now on.

Yellow Hat
Indeed, two options basically.
The problem is there's no proof.

In the example I mentioned before, Kash is actually a trusted Ironman service/account provider with tons of ironman feedback.


Also as cheap as gold is now its like .45-.48 I doubt an ironman who spent thousands of hours would trade it for $450 especially when paying more than that for a service < almost the same.

Yellow Hat
I agree it is indeed unlikely that a customer would do this, in general. But it is also unlikely that a service provider would want a report and lot of problems for just 50$ in osrs gp.


As others said before, I do agree that most people would not want a small compensation for all their money spent on services. However, see how many legitimate people list their ironman accounts for sale, also for a fraction of what it would cost to get it done by a service provider. Some people just lose interest or get in serious money problems, and see this as a way out. Again, I think this is a very small percentage of people who would do this, but still plausible imo.



I'm glad this issue is getting more attention and appreciate everyone taking their time to come up with solutions.
 
WoW Classic
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Indeed, two options basically.
The problem is there's no proof.

In the example I mentioned before, Kash is actually a trusted Ironman service/account provider with tons of ironman feedback.



I agree it is indeed unlikely that a customer would do this, in general. But it is also unlikely that a service provider would want a report and lot of problems for just 50$ in osrs gp.


As others said before, I do agree that most people would not want a small compensation for all their money spent on services. However, see how many legitimate people list their ironman accounts for sale, also for a fraction of what it would cost to get it done by a service provider. Some people just lose interest or get in serious money problems, and see this as a way out. Again, I think this is a very small percentage of people who would do this, but still plausible imo.



I'm glad this issue is getting more attention and appreciate everyone taking their time to come up with solutions.
That's all completely accurate,

The real issue is that people who own 1b+ on an ironman account don't understand the risk when ordering services.

Lets say an ironman spent 1000 hours to get 1b thats less that .05 an hour... A service provider could put a worker on there that only see's 1b+.

Lets be honest most clients don't understand the rules or understand how to scam a provider.

Chances are the worker cleaned it and the client had no idea how to manage a scam.

Most real clients don't even use the forums other than finding a provider, a client, or gold.

We need more sympathy for clients less space for the providers workers to take advantage of the TOS for Sythe.

Either way it is what it is and there's no real way to ever prove a worker scammed an account normal or iron.

If workers were held responsible there would be multiple providers with DNT atm.

Its a sad fact that we are working in a black market with most providers abusing the fact that employees / themselves can scam without any consequence.

Yellow Hat
 
WoW Classic
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
If we blame the provider then the scammers who know how to abuse the system will abuse us all.

However if we allow providers to scam and abuse clients we wont have any clients to deal with in the long run.

Clients need to be more careful and workers need to be better vetted, its all that it comes down to.

It's funny there hasn't been an issue with him until it was worth 1b+...

Either way it is what it is we can't change what this is right now.

Yellow Hat
 
Has it come to the point where every provider should screen record someone acknowledging completion of service?

IMO probably, there is a lot of issues surrounding services (Scam quits, dying on HCIM, etc). It drives me to believe that it's best if all providers just record and entire play session. Of course, that is tedious but seems like it would save tons of time on the providers end dealing with reports, save moderators time, and ensure safety.
 
Easter 2021
Extreme Homosex
Homosex
Hoover
Nitro Booster
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Potamus
There's two big problems with recording that people are failing to realize.

1. Let's say that providers are now required to record. If they fail to and something goes wrong during the service, like Kash's example, he's the one liable because there's no proof he didn't do anything. Think how many clients some of these bigger service providers, like @Limiq or @Baod or something get at a single time. More often than not, their workers work on several things at once. Do you realize how difficult it would honestly be to record that many things at once for literally 15 hours a day? It's unlikely to happen. It's way too hard on a common-person's computer.

2. Storage. People fail to realize how much space these recordings take up, then stack on the fact these have to be stored for who-knows-how-long. Having multiple files that are 15+ hours of recordings just isn't going to happen. And what, you want a moderator who does their work for free to sit and watch a 15 hour skilling video to make sure nothing is taken? Yeah, that definitely won't happen.

Recording, while good in thought, just won't work no matter what.
 
Verified Hardcore
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Twitter
Writing Competition Winner
Community Participant
Paper Trading Competition Participant
Detective
Facebook Promoter
In Memory of Jon
Le Kingdoms Player
Christmas 2020
Christmas 2023
Easter 2024
HamSanta
March Madness
May the 4th Be With You
PHP Shit Show 2k26
St. Patrick's Day 2024
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
I think I read some time ago that one of the bigger service providers got their own client which they work through. This client records all kind of information when a worker is on a customer's account to ensure the customers safety.
 
WoW Classic
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Has it come to the point where every provider should screen record someone acknowledging completion of service?

IMO probably, there is a lot of issues surrounding services (Scam quits, dying on HCIM, etc). It drives me to believe that it's best if all providers just record and entire play session. Of course, that is tedious but seems like it would save tons of time on the providers end dealing with reports, save moderators time, and ensure safety.
Impossible as some services take weeks, and months of 10-16 hours a day fam as well playing multiple accounts at once. <3

Yellow Hat
 
Nitro Booster
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Summer 2026
Two Factor Authentication User
Writing Competition Winner
Services providers can just take their whole bank, when agreed to "not responsible for any items / loss".
They will just say "prove it" that it was me. it's like a free get out of jail card for some service providers here on Sythe.
 
Shuppet
Starmie
Pidgeotto
Wurmple
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Pokémon Trainer
March Madness
Poképedia
Discord Verified
Nitro Booster
Easter 2023
The Glizz
Two Factor Authentication User
Easter 2025
Valentine's Day 2025
Halloween 2024
St. Patrick's Day 2025
Christmas 2024
Heidy
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Lawrence
Tons of Damage
Summer 2025
Easter 2022
Verified Ironman
Services providers can just take their whole bank, when agreed to "not responsible for any items / loss".
They will just say "prove it" that it was me. it's like a free get out of jail card for some service providers here on Sythe.
Yes, and customers can just drop their whole bank and claim a refund.

There is no proof in these situations. Working with a unique password that only the worker knows, does maybe solve these situations. Unfortunately this is just a very risky business.

The same can be said with account sales. If a reputable seller were to recover a high level account, they will only have to recover the account back for the customer. The seller however ( if they were to recover ) would gain access to their full bank and can steal items that way.

However, once many of these reports pop up on one provider, these cases are usually treated differently.

I think all republe account service providers would not at all want to risk stealing a bit of money with their reputation and business on the line. Especially in the report mentioned here, stealing the items would have been maybe 50$ in osrs gp. But a full refund would have been nearly 700$ ( when also profiting from gaining free xp from hunting chins etc ).
 
WoW Classic
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Yes, and customers can just drop their whole bank and claim a refund.

There is no proof in these situations. Working with a unique password that only the worker knows, does maybe solve these situations. Unfortunately this is just a very risky business.

The same can be said with account sales. If a reputable seller were to recover a high level account, they will only have to recover the account back for the customer. The seller however ( if they were to recover ) would gain access to their full bank and can steal items that way.

However, once many of these reports pop up on one provider, these cases are usually treated differently.

I think all republe account service providers would not at all want to risk stealing a bit of money with their reputation and business on the line. Especially in the report mentioned here, stealing the items would have been maybe 50$ in osrs gp. But a full refund would have been nearly 700$ ( when also profiting from gaining free xp from hunting chins etc ).
A unique password link directly given to the worker might be a good way to solve it but then the client can just claim he never rechanged the password etc.

Idk wish there was a real solution just doubt we have one anytime soon with it.

Wish we had official service provider applications like MM style had

Yellow Hat
 
Halloween 2020
March Madness
Poképedia
Summer 2020
Two Factor Authentication User
A unique password link directly given to the worker might be a good way to solve it but then the client can just claim he never rechanged the password etc.

Idk wish there was a real solution just doubt we have one anytime soon with it.

Wish we had official service provider applications like MM style had

Yellow Hat

Only problem is the service provider you buy from almost never is the one on the account its a worker.
 
Last edited:
Discord Verified
Halloween 2020
Rakashrug
Two Factor Authentication User
I feel like the verdict of this report was very well to say the least strange... and now myself who has orders open on ironman accounts right now does not feel safe one bit this just showed that depending on the tos you agreed too right now if a worker read that shit can take my items and run. This most worries me because when I get a service done all I see is time the time it will take but for example a Venezuelan worker who can live off 100$ for a few weeks why wouldnt they just take my gear? Most all service providers have the same tos as the kash report did whats to stop this from happening to me?

A one time password with a recorded log in while I change the password is going to have to be the option for me moving forward.
 
Last edited:
Easter 2021
Extreme Homosex
Homosex
Hoover
Nitro Booster
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Potamus
I feel like the verdict of this report was very well to say the least strange... and now myself who has orders open on ironman accounts right now does not feel safe one bit this just showed that depending on the tos you agreed too right now if a worker read that shit can take my items and run. This most worries me because when I get a service done all I see is time the time it will take but for example a Venezuelan worker who can live off 100$ for a few weeks why wouldnt they just take my gear? Most all service providers have the same tos as the kash report did whats to stop this from happening to me?

A one time password with a recorded log in while I change the password is going to have to be the option for me moving forward.
I'm sure that's okay for some providers to do. Like myself. I wouldn't mind being the one to change the pw so only I knew and recording the login but I got sure wouldn't record my entire session. I could call and screenshare but that's it
 
Back
Top