• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Staff: Be more cautious about Scam Reports.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Edit: Lets not forget that scam quits aren't 1 in a million. Scamquits happen very frequently now. It seems like you're not too familiar with this yourself @Lorenzo

"Scam quits" were always frequent.

It's not fair to single out one report based on the outcome. There are many users who ban evade, get away with it, and scam again. If staff start banning users based off speculation and not concrete evidence, it will create more problems.
 
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Detective
Member of the Month Winner
Tier 1 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
@Seraphic Been a part of the site since 2007. Clearly not someone who takes advantage let's be honest for a moment. I'm not saying scamming is a mistake. I am saying staff members make mistake. Please spare all of us and get off of your high horse.

You are someone who takes advantages of the system. You have been here since 2007 so you've been gathering information on how to do so. You're basically saying for every scam quit that happens which isn't banned sooner its automatically a staff mistake. You've got no logic whatsoever.
 
Former OMM
Pool Shark
Detective
Two Factor Authentication User
Nitro Booster
In Memory of Jon
Rio 2016
Community Participant
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Can the restrictions of VPN's at least be put into the USL for Richard to see then? If that is the case then at least it prevents some ban evaders from getting back onto Sythe. It might not have a massive impact however it is a start.

Ban evaders will only blatantly admit to ban evading once they are caught. Not before. In that case it's too late to act.
You're better off asking Richard directly for something like this.
 
<3 n4n0
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Support Center Participant
Writing Competition Winner
In Memory of Jon
Valentine's Day 2017
Valentine's Day 2016
Pokémon Trainer
Togepi
Penguin
If someone blatantly admits they are going to ban evade and scam, then that's proof not speculation.

As far as an IP restriction on VPNs, that's a question for Richard. We could go around and manually check each user to see if they are ban evaders. As a matter of fact some staff do this, but we have been directed by Richard that we are courts and not police. That's why when a report comes in to the "court" we have to use an innocent til proven guilty mentality and wait until there's concrete evidence to ban.
Applying DNT shouldn't be a punishment, it's a restriction and doesn't state they are guilty just a protection method. So why not just apply the DNT incase.
 
Brawlhalla Champion
Nitro Booster
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
@Seraphic Child how many times were you dropped on your head? Clearly not even close to what I am saying but you honestly seem to be one of those people that attempt to twist words in order to make you feel better about yourself. One of the people without common sense enough to know mistakes happen. If they had multiple people look at it and they felt that there wasn't enough evidence. That is their decision to make not yours.
 
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Detective
Member of the Month Winner
Tier 1 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
@Seraphic Child how many times were you dropped on your head? Clearly not even close to what I am saying but you honestly seem to be one of those people that attempt to twist words in order to make you feel better about yourself. One of the people without common sense enough to know mistakes happen. If they had multiple people look at it and they felt that there wasn't enough evidence. That is their decision to make not yours.

I'm not going to continue responding to you since you are flaming and you've got no good suggestions to make.

You are saying that everyone makes mistakes which is what I agree with. You cannot say however that every scam quit that could have been prevented sooner but wasn't is not a mistake.

If you were a staff member and you were paid to ban someone, that is your decision. That doesn't make it the right decision. To make the decision is one thing but to make the right decision is another.

As for the evidence, you show me how much evidence I should include in one report. If you can show me that then if you get staff before you get banned I'll be sure to send you a 200 page book for every ban evader and why they should bee banned.

Maybe that will be better. You can continue flaming but if you're not going to be civilised then maybe the spam forum is the best place for you.
 
Former OMM
Pool Shark
Detective
Two Factor Authentication User
Nitro Booster
In Memory of Jon
Rio 2016
Community Participant
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Applying DNT shouldn't be a punishment, it's a restriction and doesn't state they are guilty just a protection method. So why not just apply the DNT incase.
We could have yeah and I agree with the restriction. But Mootrucks was more sure than not that there wasn't enough evidence to go forward with his decision. Now if there were more questionable elements to the report, then a TWC or DNT may have been applied.
 
Brawlhalla Champion
Nitro Booster
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
@Seraphic
Not flaming at all actually. But that's okay in an attempt to make yourself look dignified I will leave it at that, also I promise you won't be getting banned ether. Have a great rest of your day.
 
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Detective
Member of the Month Winner
Tier 1 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
We could have yeah and I agree with the restriction. But Mootrucks was more sure than not that there wasn't enough evidence to go forward with his decision. Now if there were more questionable elements to the report, then a TWC or DNT may have been applied.

In that case could there not have been a vote between the globals/admins. Did any admins other than Tmoe read the report?
 
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Detective
Member of the Month Winner
Tier 1 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
@Seraphic
Not flaming at all actually. But that's okay in an attempt to make yourself look dignified I will leave it at that, also I promise you won't be getting banned ether. Have a great rest of your day.

Its not an attempt I am a dignified person. As for suggestions I had right now goes with the VPN restrictions. We will wait on what @Sythe has to say about this.
 
Former OMM
Pool Shark
Detective
Two Factor Authentication User
Nitro Booster
In Memory of Jon
Rio 2016
Community Participant
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
In that case could there not have been a vote between the globals/admins. Did any admins other than Tmoe read the report?
We could have a vote to apply TWC and DNT but every staff member has the right to apply those if they feel it's necessary.
 
<3 n4n0
STEVE
Former OMM
Situations like this annoy the hell out of me. Why? Because hindsight is an amazing gift.

The report was handled fine with all the information available. We cannot ban off pure coincidental information. Staff handle hundreds - if not thousands - of reports a month and you don't hear anything about the numerous cases of staff being proactive to prevent a possible scam quit.

Users fall through the cracks, but I can assure you we take reports seriously; however, that doesn't mean we can just ban off coincidental evidence.

So, consider this retroactively accepted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top