There's actually studies where they prove being gay isn't genetics. E.g, identical twins. While they sort of prove that they might be able to identify which one is gay after some changes they're the same when they are born, so you are not born gay.
In any case, even if it's fully genetic, when you're "accepting" gay people you're telling them that they have a genetic defect/mental problems and you'd rather say you love them for who they are than fix their problem. Imagine if they did this for other genetic defects or mental issues. "Oh, how blessed you are to have schizophrenia. You're perfect just the way you are - I accept you but will not attempt to assist you." Or about "Have autism? We're not gonna fix you, go on Sythe and argue about being gay on someone's obituary."