I'm obviously an ironman so a lot of what you said doesn't affect me whatsoever. I think Runescape would be better off with less bots, but some bots would are needed for bringing down prices of supplies. It's pretty clear that the botting problem is out of control. You watch any of Sir Puggers videos and you see that they are literally everywhere. I think Jagex would be able to add cooler stuff to the game as well if they didn't have to consider the need to counter bots.
I've been a botter since 2009 probably, but it was only in the interest of leveling and providing gold for my own account. Nowadays, I bot strictly ironman accounts. I think this is the best way to go considering the fact that it has literally no affect on the economy or Jagex. Ironman constantly have to compete with bots for content like Skeletal Wyverns. It's quite annoying and to be honest I'd much rather have gold farmers doing that because at least it's a real person you can interact with. Plus, at least the gold farmers actually need the money. I imagine a lot of the big farmers are from first world countries where they could get an actual job and make money.