• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

The thread disproves god entirely

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dancin jesus
  • Start date Start date
*views thread against after a couple days*
EEK... Some people shouldn't be allowed to have an opinion. This thread is filling up too much with unintelligible drivel.
Hell is an infinite punishment. Crimes committed on Earth are finite crimes. Tell me how an unlimited punishment is fair retribution for limited crime, please.
I have a vague understanding of infinity.
I have no idea what hell is like in comparison to our current state.
I don't know to what extent our mortal lives influence our eternal lives.
I don't think it wise to presuppose what is right or wrong - just or unjust - fair or unfair - based solely on the immediate situation nor on the popular idea of well-being.
So it's difficult for me to answer that which I find to be asked under false pretenses.
If God is ALL-knowing, then he should have this power.
Well... I cannot argue with that. Oh wait, I just did in my previous post. :/
If you know all things, that doesn't entail a knowledge of things that do not exist. That'd be some sort of simultaneous knowledge and everything and nothing.
Time is a dimension. If we think of a four dimensional universe, then knowing the future is no more difficult than looking "forward". I would assume that God, creator of everything that the universe contains, is capable of seeing in the higher dimensions.
No doubt a correct assumption.
But your assumptions concerning the 4th dimension are wrong. We are not 3-dimensional entities with free-reign over the 4th. Such would create a disorderly and chaotic time structure (I know you're likely to agree, you just feel God is different). We are somehow in a set progression, or something of the kind... I obviously don't understand how that'd work, being a superset of the 3rd dimension.
So you're basically saying time ("the 4th dim.") is constant, unlike the 3rd, therefore God can view it (which he wouldn't even need to do, having crated it) without disturbing the workings of the universe. Otherwise he'd have to manipulate the state of the universe (it not being constant and therefore not being independent).
I'm saying it's not a constant structure (which seems even more perplexing and less likely to exist without a supernatural event than what I think) and is in fact expanding during our progression. Now... I have as much evidence as you do towards time being a constant, so we can leave it at that.
But it time weren't constant, God wouldn't know what we were going to do without doubt.
And if it is constant, than God achieved nothing more than pretty much playing back a movie he constructed. Even for a non-theist God, that'd seem pointless.
Do you have any idea how many parts of Christianity were borrowed from other religions? Jesus was a "blood sacrifice"? Doesn't that sound like the religions of the ancients? What about consuming the body of Christ?
Wrong-o.
It describes such things in the beginning of the Bible. People worshiping false idols and other such religious acts.
And animal sacrifices were done by "Christians"... which ended after the crucifixion.
So these Christian ideas came from nowhere. It is in fact other religions that borrowed and twisted Christian practices.
Did you know that if you were raised a Muslim, you would probably follow Islam with equal devotion that you now show towards Christianity? The same goes for Judaism, Hinduism, etc. This just shows that people's "faith" is nothing more than a desire to avoid letting go of something that they've had since their youth.
Wow, I didn't know that!
I find it remarkable that you do. But anyhow, we're not talking about the faith of other's, we're talking about our own. And I can't speak for everyone, but I certainly don't believe what I want to be true. Otherwise I would no doubt believe that sex and partying is the way to heaven.
And hold on, Jesus was crucified. Yes, it's painful, but it's not so painful that it can equal the suffering borne by absolutely everybody else in existence! What about the others who were crucified? Some were even crucified upside down! I think that others have experienced more pain than Jesus has.
Wrong... :/
The pain was felt in Gethsemane, not the cross.
That's funny, because I remember reading in several places that you BURN FOR ETERNITY. It was very clear and non-ambiguous.
And how else to you expect to describe something not of this realm? Why would something such as fire exist in a supernatural state? And if it did, would it still be the same "fire"?
Basically hell is not a place where anyone would want to go. Whether it's torturous or not is irrelevant, and frankly, I find it to be relative. I'm certain everyone would be tormented to be eternally in a place far inferior to the joyous state of the paradise they could've earned. Even if that place was no different than our current state -- which most don't consider to be torturous, but that's not on an eternal scale.
Actually, heaven is nothing but a place where all Earthly desires are gone, where brothers, sisters, wives, friends all disappear, and all you are is just a strong love of God. For eternity. What a party, eh?
Wrong again. I'm fairly certain the Bible was never that explicit.
And even so, what I said concerning the state of hell applies to heaven as well. It is beyond surreal and couldn't be described even if you saw it with your own eyes (aside from the fact that it's not likely to be composed of visible matter ;))
Lol, wanna hear something funny. My friend one day walked up to a priest (i don't know the religion, probably catholic) and asked him -
Friend: "If got made everything, what made him?"
Priest: "We must not ask these kinds of things."

LOL? Owned priest of god!
Not owned. I agree with him, such questions are irrelevant. It doesn't matter if there is a perpetual chain of God and sub-Gods... focus on your belief in our creator.
By the way, did you ever notice that priests say that god made "the heavens" and they say that science is fake.
No one ever said science is fake.
I also love the way you deliberately chose to ignore my other post.
Nah. I think he's probably still waiting for your response to him pointing out the invalidity in story of the shepards, which is as much proven as God's existence. Yet you selectively choose to believe in that story instead of God. And you say Christians are blind? Try to use your head.
 
I've seen many threads here that debate the agrument "Does god exist." Well I'm going to settle this argument once and for all. Admins you can ban me all you want, I could care less, I shouldn't be banned for stating my beliefs. from evilbible.com

Christians consider the existence of their God to be an obvious truth that no sane man could deny. I strongly disagree with this assumption not only because evidence for the existence of this presumably ubiquitous yet invisible God is lacking, but because the very nature Christians attribute to this God is self-contradictory.

It is taken for granted by Christians, as well as many atheists, that a universal negative cannot be proven. In this case, that universal negative is the statement that the Christian God does not exist. One would have to have omniscience, they say, in order to prove that anything does not exist. I disagree with this position, however, because omniscience is not needed in order to prove that a thing whose nature is a self-contradiction cannot, and therefore does not exist.

I do not need a complete knowledge of the universe to prove to you that cubic spheres do not exist. Such objects have mutually-exclusive attributes which would render their existence impossible. For example, a cube, by definition, has 8 corners, while a sphere has none. These properties are completely incompatible: they cannot be held simultaneously by the same object. It is my intent to show that the supposed properties of the Christian God Yahweh, like those of a cubic sphere, are incompatible, and by so doing, to show Yahweh's existence to be an impossibility.

What did God do during that eternity before he created everything? If God was all that existed back then, what disturbed the eternal equilibrium and compelled him to create? Was he bored? Was he lonely? God is supposed to be perfect. If something is perfect, it is complete--it needs nothing else. We humans engage in activities because we are pursuing that elusive perfection, because there is disequilibrium caused by a difference between what we are and what we want to be. If God is perfect, there can be no disequilibrium. There is nothing he needs, nothing he desires, and nothing he must or will do. A God who is perfect does nothing except exist. A perfect creator God is impossible.

But, for the sake of argument, let's continue. Let us suppose that this perfect God did create the universe. Humans were the crown of his creation, since they were created in God's image and have the ability to make decisions. However, these humans spoiled the original perfection by choosing to disobey God.



What!? If something is perfect, nothing imperfect can come from it. Someone once said that bad fruit cannot come from a good tree, and yet this "perfect" God created a "perfect" universe which was rendered imperfect by the "perfect" humans. The ultimate source of imperfection is God. What is perfect cannot become imperfect, so humans must have been created imperfect. What is perfect cannot create anything imperfect, so God must be imperfect to have created these imperfect humans. A perfect God who creates imperfect humans is impossible.

The Christians' objection to this argument involves freewill. They say that a being must have freewill to be happy. The omnibenevolent God did not wish to create robots, so he gave humans freewill to enable them to experience love and happiness. But the humans used this freewill to choose evil, and introduced imperfection into God's originally perfect universe. God had no control over this decision, so the blame for our imperfect universe is on the humans, not God.



Here is why the argument is weak. First, if God is omnipotent, then the assumption that freewill is necessary for happiness is false. If God could make it a rule that only beings with freewill may experience happiness, then he could just as easily have made it a rule that only robots may experience happiness. The latter option is clearly superior, since perfect robots will never make decisions which could render them or their creator unhappy, whereas beings with freewill could. A perfect and omnipotent God who creates beings capable of ruining their own happiness is impossible.



Second, even if we were to allow the necessity of freewill for happiness, God could have created humans with freewill who did not have the ability to choose evil, but to choose between several good options.

Third, God supposedly has freewill, and yet he does not make imperfect decisions. If humans are miniature images of God, our decisions should likewise be perfect. Also, the occupants of heaven, who presumably must have freewill to be happy, will never use that freewill to make imperfect decisions. Why would the originally perfect humans do differently?



The point remains: the presence of imperfections in the universe disproves the supposed perfection of its creator.





Pwn3d


discuss.

If your going to argue with me don't bring up the "you have to much time on your hands" garbage, that has nothing to do with the existance of god. If I ask you the question to prove the bible and/or god, give me a logical answer, not "look around you, god has to be real." When I look around me, I see how HUMANS built our "beautful" society.


Wow, I'm not a perfect Christian, thats for sure. But I personally believe God made us be able 2 choose right from wrong and wrong from right. Like we he let Adam and Eve sin, I'm sure he knew that would sin. I'm not sure he wanted them to sin, but it led to new events in the future, which all led to Jesus dying for our sins. Now u can see my not make everyone perfect, well then how would we learn of God's true grace and mercy and power? If he didn't let us stumble and fall, I think we wouldn't grow to love him more. I know some of you may have had your own experiences involving God, bad or good. But God to me seems to let us learn and have more trust n him, like when I was 7 my house got flooded and then my dad had money issues, I hated God for letting my dad loose clients and money and the strain it put on me, my mom and dad, that i didnt see him at all and that made em hate my dad too. Im older now and im not perfect by any means, but I look back now and I see even from the pain n suffering my family went threw, I respect my dad alot for not leaving us i na time of need and God always blessed us with food, even when things were very "tight". I'm not saying thats always how it is or even that my life is the best now, but its better and with suffering God also blesses me. I think God always has a plan. Laugh at me, idc. But God made us perfect with the choice to be good or to do wrong and we are not perfect because us "man" made wrong choices, that God let us make. So we wouldn't just know God and all his grace right when we came to be, but threw struggle and confusion. Im not saying I understand it all, but I know God always has a reason.
 
So you're saying it's fair for God not to create Earth and not to give us life? You think he should have just said, "Well, you would've been good, go on to heaven.... Well, you might've been bad, I think I'll bottle you up and send you through this neat little tube down to hell forever and all eternity.

An omniscient being knows everything before it happens, and has no reason for a "test". This includes the actions a person will take, and ultimately where they will go when they die, assuming there is an afterlife.
 
You started with presuppositions again. You first started with the presupposition that a God exists, and went from there with more. Start with NONE and try giving some examples.
Ok the world isn't millions of years old like its told to be. The universe hasn't always been here. If it wasn't always here there had to be a beginning, such as a all "powerful being". You can not create something from nothing, but being all powerful you are able to have always been there and do so. So the universe always being there is ruled out, on the other hand having a being who can do the impossible do so is not.
 
That's not an explination...
 
rofl@ cruel__machine's post. Ur my new hero (next to the kid that goes "i like turtles!")
 
Because you certainly can't believe in something which has been proven, right?

Holy shit, you suck at debating.

I also love the way you deliberately chose to ignore my other post.

:cool:

You can believe anything you want. I could believe that you are emotionally stable. Although that's a tad more far-fetched than the notion of an omnisceint being who watches over us. My point is, anyone can believe anything they want, it's a matter of opinion. Please, for the love of all that is decent in this world, back your opinion up with some proof if you want to persuade anyone to your point of view!

Direct me to any post you would like me to address and I will. I have replied to all the ones I have seen.

An omniscient being knows everything before it happens, and has no reason for a "test". This includes the actions a person will take, and ultimately where they will go when they die, assuming there is an afterlife.

That's like saying, "Well, we looked into the future and saw you commit murder, so we think we'll throw you into an electric chair if that's fine and dandy with you."
 
I have a vague understanding of infinity.
I have no idea what hell is like in comparison to our current state.
I don't know to what extent our mortal lives influence our eternal lives.
I don't think it wise to presuppose what is right or wrong - just or unjust - fair or unfair - based solely on the immediate situation nor on the popular idea of well-being.
So it's difficult for me to answer that which I find to be asked under false pretenses.

The Bible explicitly states that if you are bad during this life, you WILL burn in Hell FOREVER.

So, can that be justified? Infinite punishment for a finite crime?

Cruel__Machine said:
Well... I cannot argue with that. Oh wait, I just did in my previous post. :/
If you know all things, that doesn't entail a knowledge of things that do not exist. That'd be some sort of simultaneous knowledge and everything and nothing.

Yet I didn't say that God had an infinity of knowledge in some particular areas, I said that he was all-knowing. All encompasses everything. If I throw away all my apples, they're all gone. I have no more left.

Cruel__Machine said:
No doubt a correct assumption.
But your assumptions concerning the 4th dimension are wrong. We are not 3-dimensional entities with free-reign over the 4th. Such would create a disorderly and chaotic time structure (I know you're likely to agree, you just feel God is different). We are somehow in a set progression, or something of the kind... I obviously don't understand how that'd work, being a superset of the 3rd dimension.
So you're basically saying time ("the 4th dim.") is constant, unlike the 3rd, therefore God can view it (which he wouldn't even need to do, having crated it) without disturbing the workings of the universe. Otherwise he'd have to manipulate the state of the universe (it not being constant and therefore not being independent).
I'm saying it's not a constant structure (which seems even more perplexing and less likely to exist without a supernatural event than what I think) and is in fact expanding during our progression. Now... I have as much evidence as you do towards time being a constant, so we can leave it at that.
But it time weren't constant, God wouldn't know what we were going to do without doubt.
And if it is constant, than God achieved nothing more than pretty much playing back a movie he constructed. Even for a non-theist God, that'd seem pointless.

Yet the first three dimensions shift, move, etc, and God can see those. God being outside the universe, he can see all dimensions regardless of their movements/shifts.

Cruel__Machine said:
Wrong-o.
It describes such things in the beginning of the Bible. People worshiping false idols and other such religious acts.
And animal sacrifices were done by "Christians"... which ended after the crucifixion.
So these Christian ideas came from nowhere. It is in fact other religions that borrowed and twisted Christian practices.

What you say is incorrect. There were many other religions before Christianity that sacrificed animals to please the gods, erase their sins, etc. The "Jesus is our blood sacrifice" part was likely chosen because of the appeal to the common man of sacrifices.

Cruel__Machine said:
Wow, I didn't know that!
I find it remarkable that you do. But anyhow, we're not talking about the faith of other's, we're talking about our own. And I can't speak for everyone, but I certainly don't believe what I want to be true. Otherwise I would no doubt believe that sex and partying is the way to heaven.

Yet there are so many other people who argue as you do, except for their own particular faiths! Have you not noticed this? Most people who fervently believe in their faith have been born into it. If you were born into another faith, chances are that you would be fervently defending that faith right now, assuming you still were raised the same way, were allowed to come onto Sythe, etc.

Cruel__Machine said:
Wrong... :/
The pain was felt in Gethsemane, not the cross.

First, that was Jesus's choice to go into meditation/prayer there. He did not have to expand on his ordinary human fear of death.

Second, I think that the pain felt through meditation/prayer in one night would not equal the pain and suffering of all humans for all of human existence. If it did, I have my doubts that Jesus's mind would not have cracked. After all, he was human.

Cruel__Machine said:
And how else to you expect to describe something not of this realm? Why would something such as fire exist in a supernatural state? And if it did, would it still be the same "fire"?

Well, yes. If Hell is real, I doubt very much that it's an actual place that people could travel to when still alive.

Cruel__Machine said:
Basically hell is not a place where anyone would want to go. Whether it's torturous or not is irrelevant, and frankly, I find it to be relative. I'm certain everyone would be tormented to be eternally in a place far inferior to the joyous state of the paradise they could've earned. Even if that place was no different than our current state -- which most don't consider to be torturous, but that's not on an eternal scale.

An interesting thought, but it says specifically in the Bible that Hell entails physical pain and anguish.

Cruel__Machine said:
Wrong again. I'm fairly certain the Bible was never that explicit.
And even so, what I said concerning the state of hell applies to heaven as well. It is beyond surreal and couldn't be described even if you saw it with your own eyes (aside from the fact that it's not likely to be composed of visible matter ;))

I'd have to look up the verse, which I cannot do since I seem to have misplaced my Bible... :/

Well, it was something about God being the light, and nothing else mattered, etc. Yes, I agree that Heaven is doubtfully an actual place (assuming that it exists), but that wasn't my point.

Fallen Soul said:
Ok the world isn't millions of years old like its told to be. The universe hasn't always been here. If it wasn't always here there had to be a beginning, such as a all "powerful being". You can not create something from nothing, but being all powerful you are able to have always been there and do so. So the universe always being there is ruled out, on the other hand having a being who can do the impossible do so is not.

The world IS millions, actually billions, of years old. Look up radiometric dating...

The beginning of the universe isn't necessarily an all-powerful being.

The questions that apply about the universe's existence still apply to God's existence (where did it come from, etc.)

Mahan said:
Wow, I'm not a perfect Christian, thats for sure. But I personally believe God made us be able 2 choose right from wrong and wrong from right. Like we he let Adam and Eve sin, I'm sure he knew that would sin. I'm not sure he wanted them to sin, but it led to new events in the future, which all led to Jesus dying for our sins. Now u can see my not make everyone perfect, well then how would we learn of God's true grace and mercy and power? If he didn't let us stumble and fall, I think we wouldn't grow to love him more. I know some of you may have had your own experiences involving God, bad or good. But God to me seems to let us learn and have more trust n him, like when I was 7 my house got flooded and then my dad had money issues, I hated God for letting my dad loose clients and money and the strain it put on me, my mom and dad, that i didnt see him at all and that made em hate my dad too. Im older now and im not perfect by any means, but I look back now and I see even from the pain n suffering my family went threw, I respect my dad alot for not leaving us i na time of need and God always blessed us with food, even when things were very "tight". I'm not saying thats always how it is or even that my life is the best now, but its better and with suffering God also blesses me. I think God always has a plan. Laugh at me, idc. But God made us perfect with the choice to be good or to do wrong and we are not perfect because us "man" made wrong choices, that God let us make. So we wouldn't just know God and all his grace right when we came to be, but threw struggle and confusion. Im not saying I understand it all, but I know God always has a reason.

It all comes down to this: Start with no presuppositions, look at ALL of the evidence, and try to see what reasons there are for God's existence.
 
i wanna say i am christian, but thing how everyhting (before world corruption) everything was in sync like we drink water hye water was there we needed to eat hey there was edible food you know everything just truned out to be right the sun was there we are the only planet thats livable on i dunno sound like theres a bigger force around
 
You can believe anything you want. I could believe that you are emotionally stable. Although that's a tad more far-fetched than the notion of an omnisceint being who watches over us. My point is, anyone can believe anything they want, it's a matter of opinion. Please, for the love of all that is decent in this world, back your opinion up with some proof if you want to persuade anyone to your point of view!
My other post is a supreme example of the ignorance going on in the religion of Christianity. The Bible started out with sheep herders claiming to receive visions from divine forces. They were, as the gospels describes, preaching Heaven, Hell and God. The stories which they shared travelled from man to man, land to land, in a timespan of over half a century, till finally someone with a (by todays standards) basic education wrote them down. Now, when a story travels from mouth to mouth, person to person, land to land - it will inevitably get altered just a little bit each time. How many significant changes do you think was made? A pretty damn lot, if you ask me.

There were 40 significant people who wrote down the stories, and over 36.000 Bible verses were later added together, into one book - the Holy Bible.

Oh, and if anyone wants, I have 101 contradictions from the Bible, saved in a notepad. I can send them to you, if you would happen to be interested.

America said:
Direct me to any post you would like me to address and I will. I have replied to all the ones I have seen.
Here you go: http://www.sythe.org/showpost.php?p=2082683&postcount=359

shredderbeam2 said:
The world IS millions, actually billions, of years old. Look up radiometric dating...

The beginning of the universe isn't necessarily an all-powerful being.

The questions that apply about the universe's existence still apply to God's existence (where did it come from, etc.)
You quoted with my name, when it in fact was not me, but Fallen Soul who wrote that? And Earth has been estimated to be around 4.6 billion years old. 1 billion = 1000 million. Yeah, that's quite different from the Bible's claim of Earth being created just 6000 years ago. :D
 
i wanna say i am christian, but thing how everyhting (before world corruption) everything was in sync like we drink water hye water was there we needed to eat hey there was edible food you know everything just truned out to be right the sun was there we are the only planet thats livable on i dunno sound like theres a bigger force around

Life evolves to fit what it's given. If Earth was 75% land, and 25% water, with tempatures around 200 degrees, I'm sure life would adapt.

Personal Jesus said:
You quoted with my name, when it in fact was not me, but Fallen Soul who wrote that?

Oops, sorry, just fixed that.

Personal Jesus said:
Oh, and if anyone wants, I have 101 contradictions from the Bible, saved in a notepad. I can send them to you, if you would happen to be interested.

I'd like it. :)
 
My other post is a supreme example of the ignorance going on in the religion of Christianity. The Bible started out with sheep herders claiming to receive visions from divine forces. They were, as the gospels describes, preaching Heaven, Hell and God. The stories which they shared travelled from man to man, land to land, in a timespan of over half a century, till finally someone with a (by todays standards) basic education wrote them down. Now, when a story travels from mouth to mouth, person to person, land to land - it will inevitably get altered just a little bit each time. How many significant changes do you think was made? A pretty damn lot, if you ask me.

Could you please direct me to your sources on this one? I seem to have lost the page I had open to Made Up History 101.

There were 40 significant people who wrote down the stories, and over 36.000 Bible verses were later added together, into one book - the Holy Bible.

Oh, and if anyone wants, I have 101 contradictions from the Bible, saved in a notepad. I can send them to you, if you would happen to be interested.

Send it to me through Sythe mail. I'm not going to open a notepad.


Are you sure I didn't reply? I'll check later because I gotta go, but I'm pretty sure I did. Maybe it didn't post because of lag. If it didn't post I'll edit this post and respond. ;|
 
Could you please direct me to your sources on this one? I seem to have lost the page I had open to Made Up History 101.
Look at the page 18.

America said:
Send it to me through Sythe mail. I'm not going to open a notepad.
As you wish.

America said:
Are you sure I didn't reply? I'll check later because I gotta go, but I'm pretty sure I did. Maybe it didn't post because of lag. If it didn't post I'll edit this post and respond. ;|
Nope, no reply.

shredderbeam2 said:
I'd like it. :)
Sending it in a second.

EDIT: Give me your mails so I can send them to you, Sythe only allows 5000 characters in a message.
 
Look at the page 18.

As you wish.

Nope, no reply.

Sending it in a second.

EDIT: Give me your mails so I can send them to you, Sythe only allows 5000 characters in a message.

You still didn't tell me who you heard this cute little shepherd story from..
 
You still didn't tell me who you heard this cute little shepherd story from..
The priest at our local church, and the gospels.

If you want the Bible contradictions, PM me your mail, and I'll send them to you in regular text format.
 
:/

"Faith is a cop-out. It is intellectual bankruptcy. If you can only accept a principle through faith, then you are saying that it cannot be taken on its own merits." - Dan something, former evangelist, 1992.

If your reasoning tells you something is false, why would you believe in it nonetheless?

Well you see all of gods work so basically only part of Christianity is faith. But with everything god proves to us there should be no doubt in your mind of the things unseen. I am talking about the day to day things that are there and people take for granted.
Maybe you should consider googling radiometric dating flaws.
Exactly All the athiest quit arguing with me I noticed they give LITTLE explanation on things as apposed to before. No the world is not that old. IN FACT it cannot be old. All of the atheist throw out the first law of thermodynamics(Simple terms: Matter cannot be created nor destroyed.)but they leave out the second law of thermodynamics.

Second law of thermodynamics. In any closed system, things become disordered. If an automobile is driven for years and years without repair, for example, it will become so disordered that it would not run any more. Getting old is simple conformity to the second law of thermodynamics. In space, things also get old. Astronomers refer to the aging process as heat death. If the cosmos is "everything that ever was or is or ever will be," as Dr. Carl Sagan is so fond of saying, nothing could be added to it to improve its order or repair it. Even a universe that expands and collapses and expands again forever would die because it would lose light and heat each time it expanded and rebounded.

The atheist's assertion that matter/energy is eternal is scientifically wrong. The biblical assertion that there was a beginning is scientifically correct.
 
Back
Top