I kindly request you to reread what I wrote. I am not against him nor defending him, I don't even know how his server operates. I was merely replying to Pikachu and stating if Titanite was or wasn't allowed to advertise his server.
No I'm not.
I don't know where you get that idea from. They have been reported and the reports have been dismissed. The reports were also discussed among staff.
As Titanite mentioned, this is not the case.
We could definitely further explain when a server is considered open-trading.
I do believe the difference lays in the consumer to consumer interaction. Yes, this could be added to the rules. I don't believe it has been an issue before, and as you might know the Sythe rules have been curtailed a while ago in the hope to make everything clearer. The downside is that certain rules could be interpreted in different ways.
To reply to your Eldo/PA paragraph: on Eldo/PA consumers do actually get in contact with each other. They can talk with each other via a chat system on those sites. This is not the case in Alex and Achilles server.
Back on topic of commission sales: what's the difference of you listing names for other people and the way Alex/Achilles are doing it?
If I had a name I wanted you to sell for me, you would put it on your list that you show to people given they have POF. Alex/Achilles automated this process, but are essentially doing the same thing. Are you suggesting it's open-trading just because they dedicated a Discord channel to displaying these names?