I can agree, I was one of the people who despised EoC and never gave it a chance. In around 2015 is when I gave Rs3 a try again and enjoyed it a lot more. I agree 100% that EoC wasn't the thing that ruined the game, it helped bring a lot of awesome things to the game. Which made RS in a whole a lot more enjoyable for me personally. As for the cosmetics I kind of like that part. Gave people more creativity with their characters and as a person who enjoys fashionscape, it appealed to me once they started adding higher quality stuff

.
Raids not being a skill like Dunge is a huge bonus in a lot of ways, I agree 100% with that as well. After reading your last paragraph, I can agree with and understand why you gave them credit now. What they made is incredible and there is a whole lot of potential. As someone who doesn't really play RS at all anymore, I'm still really curious to see what they can bring to the table in Raids.
After reading everything and seeing that you like both games and seeing your reasons I can agree with you. Even though there are aspects from dunge, they still did an amazing job and it has a ton of potential. I wish conversations could go like this when talking about Rs3 and 07 XD.