New Spoiler

[imgspoiler="{URL}"]{TEXT}[/imgspoiler]

This would be an awesome quick addition in my opinion. Add the possibility for members to have an image used as a spoiler.


*for people who might not understand... It's the same thing as a spoiler but with an image beside of

Spoiler: this

example

Example of a way to use it :
Beside having this boring square:

Spoiler: about me

bla bla bla

You would be able to click on a way cooler 'about me' title and then the text would appear.

---

I think with this addition, the threads can look a whole lot different (with graphics).

**we would need to remove the click to show or hide beside the image Tho.

Edit : I found a live example : http://www.everythingplaystation.co.uk/post45.html#p45

Edit 2: Infos for Matthew/Richard/... To add the option for members if needed : https://www.phpbb.com/community/viewtopic.php?f=438&t=2219876
* I know you guys are using vBulletin but maybe it will help for something.

 

[whaatitdo]

I definitely like the idea. I'm fairly sure though, others have thought of this and recommended it. I would support, but the amount of content in one post would be heavy, I'm not sure if that's a good thing or bad, but posts and threads will be loaded (with images).

 

I definitely like the idea. I'm fairly sure though, others have thought of this and recommended it. I would support, but the amount of content in one post would be heavy, I'm not sure if that's a good thing or bad, but posts and threads will be loaded (with images).

Signatures and threads are already loaded with links.
By adding this feature, people will change their threads and will remove links.. To add some new links.
+
People uses spoiler already mostly for large pictures or tons of pictures to show.

So I dont think its a problem


*I did not find any thread about this suggestion.. But maybe there is one that I didnt see 0.0

 

Sounds like a cool and fun feature. It would brighten up the forums and would be neat. Also seems like an easy addition. Support.

 

[Rodogs7]

Support, this'd be great for selling services/products!

 

It would definitely reduce load times and be easier on the eye for GFX-heavy threads if made use of.

 

[n4n0]

Edit 2: Infos for Matthew/Richard/... To add the option for members if needed : https://www.phpbb.com/community/viewtopic.php?f=438&t=2219876

Not a bad idea but I want to comment on this part directly; sythe uses vbullletin, not phpbb.

 

[Naxious]

I support this, would be a great feature and load screens easier

 

Not a bad idea but I want to comment on this part directly; sythe uses vbullletin, not phpbb.

Right, but I linked the website anyways because it might help for something. Its a HTML code which can be used in a lot of boards.


Im sure its possible to create this spoiler in vbulletin. It looks like a simple addition.

If needed, I can search online for something like it using vbulletin. But im sure Matthew is already able to implement it without

 

[Lorenzo]

I am going to offer support as well. It's not a major change and would be a nice feature to have.

 

How would someone know that the picture is a spoiler in itself? It would be obscure.

 

How would someone know that the picture is a spoiler in itself? It would be obscure.

Well its the person's choice to use a picture as a spoiler so he would make sure people know its clickable if he uses it.

Sure, we could use something like the "live example" ^ ive shown above with the "click to hide or show" transparent banner on the picture... But that wouldnt be great for people wanting to design their own button.

* Its like saying...: How do people know "vouches" is clickable and have a link in a signature?

Well the GFX Designer finds a way. It will be the exact same thing. And if no use of a GFX Designer, people will let others now (or people will see by themselves when their mouse will be on the picture ... Cause their mouse will change.)

 

Well its the person's choice to use a picture as a spoiler so he would make sure people know its clickable if he uses it.

Sure, we could use something like the "live example" ^ ive shown above with the "click to hide or show" transparent banner on the picture... But that wouldnt be great for people wanting to design their own button.

* Its like saying...: How do people know "vouches" is clickable and have a link in a signature?

Well the GFX Designer finds a way. It will be the exact same thing. And if no use of a GFX Designer, people will let others now (or people will see by themselves when their mouse will be on the picture ... Cause their mouse will change.)

Let's take Zippy's thread for example. http://www.sythe.org/graphics-marke...gp-karma-arts-artist-year-x2-2500-orders.html

Hypothetically, let's say he uses image spoilers. When first viewing the page without looking at the comments, would I know there is a drop down within the image? If we have to depend on someone to notice a change in their mouse, it's not going to be that effective.

Because of the obscurity, I don't think it's use would be effective as a regular spoiler would. Given that it doesn't affect me, I see no problem with this if probable.

 

[Tyler]

I agree with ghast's opinion on that there's no reason you cant use a regular spoiler, as its used to tell people there's going to be a large picture/wall of text anyways but I'm inclined to support this.

 

[Carbon]

Support, I like the idea that RSGOD gave. I feel like it would be very beneficial for some threads.

 

Let's take Zippy's thread for example. http://www.sythe.org/graphics-marke...gp-karma-arts-artist-year-x2-2500-orders.html

Hypothetically, let's say he uses image spoilers. When first viewing the page without looking at the comments, would I know there is a drop down within the image? If we have to depend on someone to notice a change in their mouse, it's not going to be that effective.

Because of the obscurity, I don't think it's use would be effective as a regular spoiler would. Given that it doesn't affect me, I see no problem with this if probable.

Its the exact same thing with links... How do we know the picture has a link? What youre saying is that if we dont know, it would not work? But links do work.. Why? Because, as I explained before, the owner of the links makes sure others know they can click on it and be redirected somewhere. It is the EXACT same thing with this spoiler.

If the only reason to not have this feature is because people dont know, well I would suggest maybe adding a small arrow in the bottom right of the picture-spoiler. This arrow will have a gray-ish transparent background and will be facing up (when the spoiler is not shown) and down (when the spoiler is shown).

I agree with ghast's opinion on that there's no reason you cant use a regular spoiler, as its used to tell people there's going to be a large picture/wall of text anyways but I'm inclined to support this.

Pictures are auto-re sized now so it wouldnt matter

 

[n4n0]

Right, but I linked the website anyways because it might help for something. Its a HTML code which can be used in a lot of boards.


Im sure its possible to create this spoiler in vbulletin. It looks like a simple addition.

If needed, I can search online for something like it using vbulletin. But im sure Matthew is already able to implement it without

phpbb and vbul use different coding. It may be able to be ported to VB as is, but that would most likely require it be re-written from the ground up (don't quote me on this, Govind may be able to offer better insight) - Regardless, unless you find one that's made for VB, and easily implemented, even if this does get accepted it'll likely go on the end of an already long list of additions/work that needs to be done.

For sake of ease and expedience, I'd recommend you try to find a version for VBul

 

Example of the arrow suggestion I posted above:

Shows to other users that there is something below the picture.


Click on it and it will become that:

 

Its the exact same thing with links... How do we know the picture has a link? What youre saying is that if we dont know, it would not work? But links do work.. Why? Because, as I explained before, the owner of the links makes sure others know they can click on it and be redirected somewhere. It is the EXACT same thing with this spoiler.

If the only reason to not have this feature is because people dont know, well I would suggest maybe adding a small arrow in the bottom right of the picture-spoiler. This arrow will have a gray-ish transparent background and will be facing down (when the spoiler is not shown) and up (when the spoiler is shown).

I assume you're talking about hyperlinked pictures. There is little to no obscurity with linked images for many reasons. I think image spoilers won't be effective as a regular spoiler because it's unconventional, and really holds no purpose when the option is already available. I am not against this. "Given that it doesn't affect me, I see no problem with this if probable."

 

I assume you're talking about hyperlinked pictures. There is little to no obscurity with linked images for many reasons. I think image spoilers won't be effective as a regular spoiler because it's unconventional, and really holds no purpose when the option is already available. I am not against this. "Given that it doesn't affect me, I see no problem with this if probable."

People who just want to use spoilers because they want to hide something and use it normally, sure there is no use to a pic as a spoiler. But Im suggesting this for people in the market, gfx designers, people who wants creative threads, etc.

It can turn a thread into almost a website! Thats the cool thing about it. Live example:
http://darasims.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1262&page=23

Its not really "beautiful" but it shows you one way to use the imgspoiler.

I am not against this. "Given that it doesn't affect me, I see no problem with this if probable."

Yea I know but I just wanted to tell you what I see in this and my opinion about it

phpbb and vbul use different coding. It may be able to be ported to VB as is, but that would most likely require it be re-written from the ground up (don't quote me on this, Govind may be able to offer better insight) - Regardless, unless you find one that's made for VB, and easily implemented, even if this does get accepted it'll likely go on the end of an already long list of additions/work that needs to be done.

For sake of ease and expedience, I'd recommend you try to find a version for VBul

I see Govind is reading this thread and it has been quite some time. Ill wait for his reply.