It is true a pin that has been used will appear as "invalid payment window" if you change the country. Yet on the appropriate country it will say "invalid pin" I think this is useful but there are a few downfalls such as, what if by mistake a non working pin is given, if it is 2 humans doing the trade then there could be compensation such as another pin etc.
I'm saying "program" because I'm coding in in serverside languades, it will be a website.
Does anyone know for certain if all used PINs say "Invalid PIN" in every window?
Sounds like a great idea, just one flaw:
Scamming WILL happen.
On PayPal, they will open a dispute and claim their money back, stating they never received the pin/it was invalid.
You say in a real trade, there is the same risk.
Not really, because if the buyer is going first and you make them Claim and Cancel, they can't open another claim against you, meaning no scams can happen.
With this, you are defenseless until you check PayPal, then you have to go through the process of providing proof that the PIN was sent and that your system shows that the PIN was valid at the time of being sent.
Other then that, it sounds like a perfect idea for PIN sellers, there is just that one risk of using it lol.
I had a thought, would there be some way of making sure the person purchasing the pin was paying the correct amount? Just thinking of that FireFox addon that can edit pages...
All in all, though, this sounds like a really great idea.
PayPal offers no buyer protection for digital goods. Because the sales will go through the PayPal IPN notification system, all you have to do is prove to Paypal that you are running a digital goods service and all disputes will be immediately closed.
Touche.
Then this looks like a good future for PIN selling.
Good luck mate.
Also, are you planning on just letting any PIN seller use this?
I would suggest you take a 4-9% fee out of each PIN sold, or rent it out.
If it turns out to be what it sounds like, it would be well worth paying for/giving a small cut of what the person selling gets.
Just an idea to get you some money for making it.
I'm definitely going to charge for this, I'm trying to decide on the fees now. I was thinking a one-time fee of around $10 to set up a server for the PIN seller, and then maybe around forty or fifty cents commission for every PIN sold.
Sounds good, but think hard on the commission price you choose.
Please, if you think it's too high/low let me know. I want this to be affordable, yet still make me something for my trouble.
Well for one, you need to have a PBP PIN option and an SMS PIN option.
Like, the seller tells you which they want to sell, or both.
And then there needs to be a separation between the two, like "Click here to purchase an SMS PIN" and "Click here to purchase a PBP PIN".
Because the prices are different, plus I think the PIN's # of numbers/letters are different.
Also not to mention SMS are $12.00USD and PBP are $8.00USD
I think you should take $0.80USD from each SMS sale, seeing as they are a higher price, and sellers will sell a bit higher to get a profit.
I also think you should take $0.50USD from PBP because they cost less and they are more common. They are sold more, which means more sales come in from then, meaning more money even if it's only 50 cents a sale.

