Sigh.. It's uncanny to see shift in the entire premise of the thread, yet lack to show burden of proof when challenging my question. Zorro said you cannot change your sexual orientation at the bottom of page 4, yet cannot provide undoubted proof of that. Logical reasoning is out the question for him. Is it odd that I choose not to further a debate that serves no interest for the premise of the thread? It's odd that you feel I have an obligation to continue something I don't have to. You've done this before in another thread.
Change does not imply choice. The fact that someone now has cancer doesn't mean they chose to have cancer. For sexuality to change, it implies a sexual disposition in the first place. You seem to reject the existence of sexual dispositions, so therefore you cannot believe that sexuality can change. It is impossible for something to change without there being something to change from. You can't have it both ways, there is no shift in the debate, these are just consequences of the premises you hold. Unfortunately every premise you hold contradicts one another.
Instinct vs Impulse
This is what your argument revolves around. It's instinct to get an urge to procreate. Instinct behaviors change in reaction to different environments to accommodate our need for survival. The urge to kiss someone of the same sex is impulsive. The urge to stick something up my poop shoot is impulsive. Impulsive behaviors do not serve to extend our life expectancy like our instincts do. What would you classify the urge to search for food? Instinct.
Even if I take your false dichotomy, impulsive behaviours do not imply a choice. Your whole case rests on the case that homosexuals choose to be gay; I accept they choose to commit homosexual acts, but not that they chose to be attracted to men, to the same extent that heterosexuals chose to be attracted to women. You are arguing for the existence of choice here, the burden of proof is entirely on you. All your evidence so far is the case about Ravi, non-scientific, and equivocating between unnatural and abnormal.
Are you implying that evolution and the genetic transfer of diseases would have no effect on the inner structure of the human body today? There are useless organs we don't need, but who is to say they didn't serve a purpose in a past time? It's ignorant for you to assume that because x doesn't make sense, it's possible that y doesn't make sense. Keep using that circular reasoning to try and disprove the obvious. That's like me saying, "Because good people are dying, that means God isn't real".
What are you talking about? I'm not saying it doesn't make sense, I'm saying you have no evidence to back up your belief, furthermore, in contradicts my day-to-day experience. All I ask is you provide evidence, other than Ravi's unexpected erection, which only serves to further my point.
Until there is proof of not being able to change your sexual orientation, this discussion is an utter waste of my time. #BurdenOfProof
> Brings up repeated points that were already addressed
> I can't be mad
Logic.
You can't prove a negative. I am not claiming that homosexuality is not a choice. I am saying that we have no reason to believe it is a choice. You are making the claim, thus the burden of proof is on you to prove that sexuality can change, and the corollary claim that sexuality is a choice.
(1) You have no evidence to support the fact that sexuality can change. The default position is we don't know, and you have failed to satisfy your burden with Ravi's unexpected boner.
(2) You have no evidence to support the fact that sexuality is a choice. Even if sexuality can change, this does not necessarily mean it is a conscious choice. No one chooses their height, yet for some magic reason your height changes.