How Jagex will do it.

This was not posted by a mod?

Also, if you'd randomize the packets how is the client going to read the packets?

 

Thread should be called "how jagex thinks they will do it"

you guys dont need to freek out just dont bot tomorow bots will be fine I'm guessing by the 26th (wednesday)

 

Bold claim. Jagex might be onto something, and its about time.

 

Flash would make me quit I think. Or damn close.

 

It's more probably 'clusterfuck', as in, bot clusterfucker. but hey, that's just my opinion.

 

Nice post. I'd say the first option.

 

if jagex did this, botting sites could just update eventually

 

Some interesting points and facts stated.

I heard something about Runescript, the langauge in which Jagex uses to program with which Java then translates.

This most likely will not be the solution to how they stop all bots, however it could be a method:

Source: http://jagex.wikia.com/wiki/Runescript


However Wolfdogs' theory seems possible too.

Only time will tell.

 

I've never seen you post in the RS section.

Regardless: That makes sense, would also help ban people (When it failed to grant a connection).

 

Your ideas are very good and the more evidence I see the less likely the switching the client option becomes. The only problems I see with your post is that, like you said, it only will effect reflection bots. However, Jagex mods were quick to correct the post on the original page saying it will effect BCEL based clients as well.

So I think at this point we have ruled out three things:

1. Switching to a non-java client -Jagex is requiring a new Java update no point in doing this if they were going to switch to a non-Java client. http://services.runescape.com/m=news/change-to-required-java-version

2. Obfuscation: They have tried this, literally thousands of times with every update...it is not a hard hurtle to get over for an experienced coder.

3. Encryption -- I have seen a lot of posts about this. It is pointless because even if there is encryption between server and client the information most be in an unencrypted form before it is compiled by the JVM...Also my classguard post would also be an unlikely alternative since the since the executing JVM has to somehow be able to read the data it wants to execute...it can't do this if it is encrypted.

I still think the most likely method is mixing up item/object IDs...and after reading mercatres post and hearing this had already been attempted on randoms I would not be surprised in the least if they didn't try something similar to this. We'll see...in the mean time please post more suggestions/comments.

 

Very true, I would have done the same but remember they are focusing making the game available to as many people as possible on as many OSs as possible. Java is very well known for its slogan "write once read anywhere" and I think that Jagex is afraid if they move away from Java because they fear will lose people over speed and compatibility problems.

 

This is very interesting to read.
I think they will re-write the client.

 

Wouldn't mind it at all if they got rid of bots, they ruined the game. There is no point anymore for non botters because it's nearly impossible to pass them statistically, and theres not point for botters because they dont even play the game.

I think changing the item id's would drastically change the amount of successful botters, especially for simple skills such as woodcutting.

 

I bot, but I made a post on the Runescape forums a few months ago, suggesting they change item ID's every few hours, and it got a lot of support and feedback, some of which were from Jmods.

But thinking about it now, I can't really see how item ID's would affect that much botting-wise. Someone up above said it too, about a lot of scripts not using item ID's, but names instead. This update would break kiko's dungeoneering bot, cause there are a lot of things you can't right click and get a name for, that you have to interact with, but a lot of bots would be unaffected, right?

We'd have to go the route of RID, using color and shape recognition, if we want to bot dungeoneering again, I think. ;( Sucks, too. Kiko's so close to releasing party support.

 

I don't have much know how in the program department, but I'm not exactly sure that Jagex can fix the botting problem at its current rate. They claim to have "already banned 1.5 million bots".. Thats a pretty large number.. if even 10% of those are p2p (much more likely that its a higher number than that) then they're losing roughly $150,000 a MONTH?

$1,800,000 a year, because people want to bitch about the economy of a pixelated game and complain solely because they are either scared to bot or they can't afford/parents won't buy them paid bots?

They aren't fixing shit in my opinion. This is simply a clever ruse to keep the "legitimate players" happy in the meantime while they figure out ways around bots to buy time.

Why put so much effort into making frost dragons nearly impossible for bots if they were planning this? Unless they were intended to be harder to kill upon release, which I highly doubt since the best thing they drop are bones that won't exceed 25k at the most without bots.

My ass. If Jagex had the ability to do this they would've done it long ago before botting became the "problem" that it is today, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out how to keep reflection out of a game like Runescape. I mean for fucks sake, they created the game. If infact the creators of these bots used in the game that they (jagex), themselves created are smarter and know more about how to operate the scripting and can continue to find ways around Jagex's methods of keeping them out, then maybe they should hire these bot creators to help them develop the game instead of the idiots they have working on it right now.

This is merely my opinion on it.

OT: How will they do it? They probably won't, as to how they could? I'm not sure.

If they truthfully want to stop goldfarming, they should buy these companies out, returning the hundreds of billions tied up in the websites to the players or destroying it. Botting? Will always be an issue because people just want those stats.

 

{The project, code-named the ‘ClusterFlutterer’.........................permanently preventing “reflection” bots from working again.}
-MMG



even though jagex is known for stretching the truth; they have started to be more open about the anti-bot wars, so you have to take that into consideration somewhat

 

I agree with wolfdog, however I doubt botting will die, people will start producing bots like AI (robotzindisguise)

 

Even so those bots have limits RID is amazing no doubt but it has it's disadvantages to.

Running multiple RID bots takes up a huge amount of processing power and RAM because you have to run each in a separate VM.

Also, for a computer it is much more difficult to interpret visual information than it is using reflection/bcel. This limits what color recognition bots like RID can do. You will for example never see an RID dungeneering bot because color recognition algorithms can only go so far and with a skill this complicated and with that many branching possibilities one variable misinterpretation can lead to the bot preforming completely differently.

 

After RT5 it wouldn't be hard to rewrite it to other languages, Jagex already have an downloadable client which doesn't use Java.