Lots of people are saying logos should be simple. This is just a silicon valley and start-up trend (specifically of 1990-2010). Logos go from complicated to simple to complicated over time; A bit like rounded edges and square edges. (For example look at BP's current and past logos.) However true artwork is timeless. I think if the piece is done right it will be great.
Since we are a game based site I think a nicely designed fantasy-world logo with complex but subtle detail is desirable. This is thematic foreshadowing for a rich and rewarding end-user experience.
Take for example Diablo III's logo:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/de/archive/8/87/20120518214637!Diablo_III_logo.png
This I feel is masterfully created-- achieving a sort of simplicity at first glance while also incorporating rich fine detail into the lettering and background.
Compare that to, for example, something simple like the microsoft logo:
http://img2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20131205222356/fictionalcrossover/images/8/85/Microsoft.png
Which just says to me "boring user end experience" (and that impression is not incorrect.)
I like the direction the logo is heading. After it's fully inked it will probably need some revision but I think we can work with it. Keep the letters on separate layers so it can all be moved around and scaled. For example it might be desirable to have a larger S and smaller YTHE like in the current logo.
Interested to see how it comes out.