- Joined
- Sep 14, 2012
- Sythe Gold
- 0
- Messages
- 68
every website i go on or everywhere i go i see adverts it isn't just fast foods but the adverts overall.
Your entire argument hinges on the preconceived notion that disallowing advertisements of a certain thing villianizes it and makes people not want it. Fast food is cheap and easy. Health food is incredibly expensive in comparison and of the case were the opposite then we would have healthier citizens but we are no longer an agrarian society that relies on subsistance agriculture to feed itself. That means that we heavily rely on processed food because we are all in some form or fashion live on a hectic shedule. It really is difficult to come home from an 8 - 12 hour work day and have the will to stand in the kitchen for another hour and make a healthy dinner, then you factor in the cost of fresh produce and good quality lean meats. A healthy lifestyle is difficult for the modern person. So villianizing a business for a societal flaw is wrong.
Until they put an age restriction on buying fast food (lol) I highly doubt they will start banning the commercials. The commercials aren't even that bad. They almost always advertise their "healthy" selections in commercials.
Will power. It is honestly not that hard compared to real addictions.
The government shouldn't have to control everything. You are saying that us, as citizens, have to let the government come in and control advertisements because we are by an far much to weak to resist the temptations of a commercial. Which is completely insane. I believe in strong government and governmental control, but I also disavow censorship because it hurts some people's feel goods.
Fast Food and fatty foods is an addiction. I don't know where your source is but it has already been proven that in processed foods there are chemicals that your brain becomes addicted to but with any other drug it takes willpower to break that addiction.
Here are three reliable articles:
http://www.thatsfit.com/2010/03/30/fast-food-is-like-heroin-studies-find/
http://atvb.ahajournals.org/content/25/12/2451.short
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21999689
In the end the government can't be there to stop a citizen from living their life, and by taking advertisements away from television do you really think people are going to forget about fast food or even cut down on it? No. I could go to a town so small it doesn't even have stop lights and it still have a couple of fast food joints. Fast Food is an immutable part of our society that is deeply interwoven now.
They can change the channel...Fair enough let people live their lives as they wish. I'd want people to do that. But why should they sit there and watch 15 minutes of advertisements about the fattiest most unhealthiest foods when they could be watching advertisements for other things.
They can change the channel...
Banning fast foods is like dealing with the effect of a problem; if you don't deal with the cause, the problem will never be solved.
Now, we obviously can't change our genes, but we can change the environment, and it starts at a young age. It starts with educating people about their eating habits, teaching people self-control.
Nobody is going to change the channel every time a fast food advert comes on TV. Mostly because there are so many of them on so many channels; secondly if people are watching their favourite TV show they're not going to skip to another channel in fear of missing when their TV show comes back on.
Nobody, certainly not me insinuated that we ban Fast foods. Businesses are businesses and there are many fast food businesses. I don't disagree with fast food businesses at all because as many have already said it's down to people's own minds at to whether they want to go out and buy fast food or notI'm just saying that adverts could be limited in terms of how frequent they're played. I'm not sure how it works in the USA but in England they're shown an awful lot; mostly KFC, McDonalds and Burger King. All foods which are very unhealthy, they don't even show their healthy menu's which is a part of the problem too.
Now this is something I very much agree with. Thing is, nobody is doing anything about this. Okay, maybe I started my argument wrong with titling is "fast food adverts are destroying out future", as the quote above is basically my point. We need to change people's attitudes about fast food and all these adverts seem to be doing is enforcing into people's brains more that eating fast foods is a normal thing, which it shouldn't be.
I do agree with most of what you said as you've bought up some very good points and are on the same wave length as me (for the most part). I sometimes have trouble wording my arguments as many people have 'laid into me' for my mistakes. But what I said I agree with is the main point I'm trying to portray ^_^
You are assuming that the US and UK have not made efforts to stop obesity. This is just not the correct method, you can not ban a certain product from being advertised unless it is againt one of the 3 rules I stated in my post aboe: 1. If the commercial is promoting a substance that directly harms a person's body (Alcohol) 2. If the commercial is promoting a product that can directly effect other in public (Being Drunk, Second Hand Smoke) 3. If the product has an age limit or something of that nature (Alcohol, Buying Cigs, etc.)
Even witht these 3 main rules, Alcohol commercials are still being shown on certain networks (as long as "Please drink responsibly" is included). Alcohol is obviously more dangerous than fast food and if you can't completely ban advertisment of Alcohol, it is not justified to ban or limit fast food commercials.
As for your assumption that no efforts have been made to prevent obesity. Currently in the US, if your food contains a certain amount on calories and is distributed widely, you must show the calories of that food. (At mcdonalds' there is usually a calories poster somewhere in the resturant, most likely in a non-noticable place, but it exists.) As for kids, many schools have been transfering to healthier food for school made lunches. Michelle Obama has also made many programs involving child hood obesity.
In conclusion, if you think that the commercials should be banned/limited because of the health disadvantages you are not creating a solution to childhood obesity. Whether or not someone sees a fast food commercial on TV will not make them get up and go outside and get excersise. It merely prevents SOME of them from going out and getting McDonald's. The problem is, McDonalds advertisments don't make too much of a difference, fast food resturants are already publicly known, not airing commercials for them will not prevent anyone from eating some McNuggets. We need to actually do someting to STOP childhood obesity completely, as well as making the current generation healthier. This idea is not solving any problems involving obesity. We need to actually convince kids/citizens to be healthier, rather than shielding them from the unhealthy things.
Thanks,
Anet390/Andrew
Now this is something I very much agree with. Thing is, nobody is doing anything about this. Okay, maybe I started my argument wrong with titling is "fast food adverts are destroying out future", as the quote above is basically my point. We need to change people's attitudes about fast food and all these adverts seem to be doing is enforcing into people's brains more that eating fast foods is a normal thing, which it shouldn't be.
Nobody is going to change the channel every time a fast food advert comes on TV. Mostly because there are so many of them on so many channels; secondly if people are watching their favourite TV show they're not going to skip to another channel in fear of missing when their TV show comes back on.
This entire thread has gone on longer then necessary. You're also exaggerating this to a mythical extent.
And I'm not exaggerating anything at all...
You're just reading way too deep into my opinion...
I was just asking what other people think.\
And about my source? my source for what? Someone in a previous post said that fast food wasn't an addiction and they seemed clued up about it so I went with it but I said that people crave it, because the reality is they do... I'm not saying anyone's opinion is wrong at all. I'm just giving my opinion but you keep drawing to the fact of the government. I just said they can play apart in helping the situation, which they can. I didn't say to control people's lives or anything or the sort which you keep insinuating I'm talking about..
This is a stickied thread, you should have known about this.Spamming the SFA with rubbish comments and opinions is prohibited. Only properly thought out rational arguments are allowed in this forum.
We don't care if you like bush, or you think global warming is man made.
This forum is about reason, not emotion. If you want to bash your blind opinions against the blind opinions of others then do it in the spam forum. That is what it is for.
You have been warned.
If your argument is the regulation of ads will decline the rate of (childhood)obesity then you need to post sources of that information. Furthermore, are you saying the FDA isn't appropriately doing their jobs already?Nobody, certainly not me insinuated that we ban Fast foods. Businesses are businesses and there are many fast food businesses. I don't disagree with fast food businesses at all because as many have already said it's down to people's own minds at to whether they want to go out and buy fast food or notI'm just saying that adverts could be limited in terms of how frequent they're played. I'm not sure how it works in the USA but in England they're shown an awful lot; mostly KFC, McDonalds and Burger King. All foods which are very unhealthy, they don't even show their healthy menu's which is a part of the problem too.