[Denied] Hide the information on ban evader reports

So this suggestion and bare with me,

current with ban evader report it would like one of the following:
Lost Ranger
Kaylewhileimplaying
Dvy
Slingysling

Basically we are saying to anyone who is ban evading here how we caught you don't do it again, we basically making it much easier to ban evade next time around,

My suggestion is as following:

Step 1:
Have format for a report:
Current profile
Previous profile

Everything else in a delete post.(evidence)

if the user chooses to pardon, we can make the evidence public assuming they pay back any debt he or she may hold if it point of controversy at the pardon stage, only counter argument I can see to this is how are people going to caught people who are ban evading? there archive of ways to caught them

 

100% support, this should have been like that.

 

Support, I feel like this has been suggested in the past already. I've had the same idea as well. 100% support.

 

I was actually going to suggest something like this a couple weeks back but was too lazy to type it up.

I agree 100%, kinda aids the ban evader so they know what not to do the next time.

 

Good Suggestion @Pikachu. I support this suggestion & template.

 

support for this +1

 

Support. Unless someone can argue the other way.

 

[Laptop65]

No support, things should be transparent and it should be clear why someone was banned and the evidence that led to it. Years ago "private bans" were a thing but these days the staff would prefer things to be more transparent rather than the admins quietly removing someone from the site overnight and nobody knows why.

It's like banning me for ban evading and not showing me the evidence, what if the evidence was wrong? What if it's some silly plot to get rid of a user? Transparency is always helpful in these situations.

 

[Jibby Jibby]

I support this, however i think there might be a small issue. Sometimes i find helpfull information on previous ban evader reports, to report a new ban evader.

only counter argument I can see to this is how are people going to caught people who are ban evading? there archive of ways to caught them

Am not sure if you meant that in this sentence, since it was a described a little obscure.

But this is indeed really annoying, cause ban evaders know what not do to next time. Like this kid below.

SirCattington Damn son you’re good!

I’ll be back soon lol. It’s easy. I’ve got like 100 accounts... mo long, Koreanjesus, koi, obamallama, karma, bobby. Who will be next mr detective?

Thanks for calling me on my shit early, I’ll change my patterns going forward.

Bye bye!
Mar 19, 2020 Delete Report

 

I support

Regarding my quote, I mean we need fail safe for people to be able to see the information if they are disputing,
I am not sure what the best action would be for this, but I am sure somebody come up with one

 

[bababablacksheep]

Support

Can we not had some kind of hidden tool rather than deleting the post?

 

Indecisive. On one hand I agree but on the other hand I highly doubt most ban evaders read the reports on them. Most of them either trollpost on it, or probably don't even read them. The ban evader reports I make however mostly contain the same information anyways. It's already quite obvious that when one of your older accounts is on your audit you're basically screwed, no matter what information is being provided. Unless Hahanerd handles it ofcourse, he even asks me to provide proof of reports I make on people asking if they are proxy camping.

 

[Superfluous]

Staff thoughts: @Laptop65 and @Wortel made good posts. Transparency is important, and we're not going to hide pertinent information or move back towards private reports. Thus this suggestion is denied, but consider it noted @Pikachu.

Personal thoughts: Also, for what it's worth, the info Wortel often provides is useful but we can usually tell whether people are evading a ban or not without it. I think changing our approach on these reports would actually catch very few incremental users.