• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

[Denied] Feedback threads accompanying news posts

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Sythe Gold
9,135
Messages
18,939
Vouch Thread
Click Here
Discord Unique ID
247909953925414913
Discord Username
.superfluous.
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
I think we should create a feedback thread for all news posts that are not about promotions (e.g. rule changes or clarifications) where users are encouraged to ask questions. Staff can then answer them and potentially refine any changes that were made. Basically just make big changes more of a conversation and less of a directive. I feel like people would be more likely to ask questions when a feedback thread already exists vs. throwing a question into a news post thread where most of the content is "nice" or "this is dumb."

For example:
New community repayment forum
Further Changes to the Accounts Market
Modernizing sythe rules and updating the bump rule
A lot of updates
An Update on Community Repayment
 
Last edited:
Pokémon Master
STEVE
Some like it hot
The Glizz
May the 4th Be With You
CoolHam
Pool Shark
March Madness
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
Halloween 2015
Halloween 2020
Halloween 2021
Halloween 2022
Halloween 2023
Valentine's Day 2025
Valentine's Day 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2021
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Christmas 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2021
St. Patrick's Day 2022
Summer 2022
Christmas 2021
SytheSteamer
Nitro Booster
Detective
I saw Matthew
Support. More community involvement on this is a plus imo. I'm sure Sythe users have great ideas that could be beneficial and this is a good avenue to hear them. Good suggestion Super.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbh
<3 n4n0
Extreme Homosex
Gohan has AIDS
Lawrence
Poker Chip
Potamus
Two Factor Authentication User
Support. Could easily just make a thread in the community general section (potentially sticky it) and then just at the end of every news post simply link the thread with something like
"Questions? Comments? Post here to discuss this weeks changes!" or something along those lines
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbh
I 100% support the idea, but how exactly would we make this happen and how is it any different to what we currently have, where a new rule gets implemented and a post is made about it and the community post's their reply's. So basically after announcing the new rule would they just post please leave your feedback and your thoughts on this update?
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbh
Typhlosion
Umbreon
Milotic
Lairon
Politoed
Chansey
Le
Wubba Lubba Dub Dub
Why is there BACON in the SOAP!?
Detective
The Mortyest Morty
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
TOKI! AM'S YOU WEARINGS MY PANTS?
Discord Verified
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
I 100% support the idea, but how exactly would we make this happen and how is it any different to what we currently have, where a new rule gets implemented and a post is made about it and the community post's their reply's. So basically after announcing the new rule would they just post please leave your feedback and your thoughts on this update?
Yes we would make a thread and people could post their thoughts/immprovements on the thread without having to create a thread themselves.
 
I support for the same reasons mentioned above. I especially agree with what Devil said, more community involvement is indeed a plus.
 
Summer 2019
St. Patrick's Day 2017
Easter 2020
Summer 2021
Two Factor Authentication User
I saw Matthew
Hoover
Rakashrug
CoolHam
Nitro Booster
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Battleship Champion
Christmas 2025
Easter 2023
HamSanta
March Madness
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
The Glizz
No support. I'd understand if users weren't able to make replies on the original thread but this is not the case. I think adding a new location for that feedback would create a convoluted process and make it more difficult for users to provide a new perspective. To encourage people to post meaningful replies, then I'd suggest adding a signature to news posts signifying that users are more than welcome to post feedback/concerns.
 
Last edited:
Former OMM
Pool Shark
Detective
Two Factor Authentication User
Nitro Booster
In Memory of Jon
Rio 2016
Community Participant
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Isn't that what the suggestions section is for? If there's a new rule/change and someone wants to make a change or add feedback to it, they can just post a new thread there.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: tbh
Christmas 2024
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
OG Club
Christmas 2013
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Winter Olympics 2022
March Madness
Easter 2020
Christmas 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2022
Halloween 2022
Christmas 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2023
Valentine's Day 2023
Summer 2023
Easter 2023
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Poképedia
Christmas 2023
Halloween 2023
HamSanta
Easter 2024
PHP Shit Show 2k26
The logic behind the suggestion is great and appreciated. No support as suggested, but support a similar idea. See below.

Super is right. As it stands, people are able to post replies on News threads, but only temporarily as the threads are closed after a short amount of time. Not only that, but any comment/concern/rebuttal to the initial post would typically get buried within the "nice" "thanks" "great work" or usual sh33dy "drink bleach" type comments. I also don't think the suggestions section is proper for questions/comments/rebuttals/concerns regarding news posts, ether. I believe that a rebuttal to a new rule that were posted in the suggestions section would be shot down and locked quickly without the OP feeling like he/she were able to be heard or have a meaningful conversation on the topic.


All of that leads me to the community input section. The section is largely inactive and unused, but it seems like the perfect solution to the problem Super is addressing.

My suggestion: Link the "Community Input" section at the bottom of every Sythe.org News thread with a line similar to, "Do you have questions, concerns, or thoughts regarding these changes? If so, please feel free to start a conversation within the Community Input section!"


TL;DR - a section already exists, here: Community Input. We should just include specific wording within news section posts that identifies the subsection.
 
Last edited:
Verified Hardcore
Hoover
CoolHam
Battleship Champion
Team Fight Tactician
Rupee
Detective
Member of the Month Winner
Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Discord Verified
Nitro Booster
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Shitting Rainbow
St. Patrick's Day 2024
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Users are free to leave feedback on news posts and by creating threads in the feedback section. Adding a dedicated thread for this with every news post isn't really necessary.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top