This is a great idea. But before I get into that, I must criticize it.
- You will not be Lead Market Guru. Someone with hopefully more time at the site than you, although it would be hard to match your obvious knowledge of various scamming techniques, as I believe in what knowledge is presented to me.
- Sythe.org has always turned down various systems of scammer organization and has never incorporated one thing to help catching scammers except for the Trade With Caution sign and the Report A Scammer forums. I can tell you right now, the chance of this being denied is higher than the number of scammers on this site. So basically, sorry, no.
- This could be implemented without creating many ranks and forums, and various other things. All it needs is an educated user to catch a scammer. It's relatively easy to spot any suspicious activity from any user. Again, although it could be more simply put, Sythe will just not bother to create something to cut down on the scammers.
This is a very well thought-out idea, well presented, and cleanly oriented. But it could be much simpler than having Market Guru specialized TWC and other ranks, aside from Lead Market Guru. It can be done simpler without any ranks.
First,
- have a forum (since it involves making forums it won't be made :/ ) to handle various scammer things.
- incorporate the "report a scammer" section into this forum.
- Have various, clean, organized threads that deal with scammer problems as in:
- known sold accounts
- suspicious accounts (suspicious of scamming activity)
- known scamming accounts (list of market banned or users banned through the use of this system)
This would need many people as a community to incorporate, but it can be done. The only problem with these is that Sythe won't do anything about it, as stated before. Again, this is a well-polished and seemingly successful idea, but it would need revising in various areas and fine tuning in others, to even be considered for incorporation.
Sorry if my idea hijacked the thread, just giving my 2 cents on the idea.