• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

COLTS7841 - A technical Core - PROLIFIC SCAMMER - BAN IMMEDIATELY

Status
Not open for further replies.
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Again, I see you're trying to take a black/white point of view but this really isn't the case in this situation.

Colts should have never vouched for Racks if the trade was not completed. But because he DID (when he shouldn't have) it mis-lead someone into buying the account from Racks.

As I already said, this is at least equally weighed by the lack of due diligence to contact the original owner IMHO.

Aswell as this, Colts had a week to confront Racks on his selling of an account that wasn't his, and by not doing so it also mis-leads Esky into thinking his purchase would be safe.

This I do not accept. Why would colts be watching the account market? If you rented a house to someone do you then watch the real estate listings to make sure it hasn't been put on the market? Why would you?

But that's just my 2 cents I agree that the account should be returned to Esky, Colts got scammed by Racks and that should not be taken out of Eskys pocket just because he failed to contact the OO before purchase, he clearly wouldn't have purchased the account if there was any visible issue.

I think it's safe to say Esky would have never bought the account if Colts didn't leave a vouch, nor would he have bought it if Colts confronted Racks like he should have.

Since the facts are controversial in this case (i.e. what constitutes due diligence, what constitutes negligence, if the vouch estops colts from recovery) I am going to leave it to a staff vote as a sort of jury case, but that will only happen after we're satisfied on balance that Esky is not Racks.
 
Last edited:
No mootrucks not busy at all, I go to the kitchen there are no cameras
Also this matter is a lot to me so I will spend my time replying
 
lol stealing from work so scumbags on this site don't steal that stolen money.
Make sense?
 
Speak in some hours time
Please don't bump this thread until is time for voting
Thanks all
 
As I already said, this is at least equally weighed by the lack of due diligence to contact the original owner IMHO.

I would have to disagree, vouching for an account you haven't been paid for is stupider than purchasing an account you've seen vouched for being as Esky is clearly a newer member (given he's not Racks).


This I do not accept. Why would colts be watching the account market? If you rented a house to someone do you then watch the real estate listings to make sure it hasn't been put on the market? Why would you?

I can somewhat agree with this point, however at the same time Racks was even advertising the account sale in his signature which makes it even more questionable, I honestly do think Colts was aware that Racks was trying to re-sell he just didn't care as he thought he was going to get paid. However this is just an assumption.

Since the facts are controversial in this case (i.e. what constitutes due diligence, what constitutes negligence, if the vouch estops colts from recovery) I am going to leave it to a staff vote as a sort of jury case, but that will only happen after we're satisfied on balance that Esky is not Racks.

Sounds good, just giving my 2 cents, Esky shouldn't be held liable.
 
Last edited:
Two Factor Authentication User
Stay a while and listen
Twitter
Tier 1 Prizebox
Dolan Duck
Member of the Month Winner
Creamy
Baby Yoda
Chansey
Dragon Claws
Garchomp
Hey... this isnt a fun rank
Lawrence
Nitro Booster
Penguin
Pikachu
Tier 2 Prizebox
Tier 3 Prizebox
Tier 4 Prizebox
Tier 5 Prizebox
Tier 6 Prizebox
Well I think this is pretty cut and dry... I dont see why people are arguing about it..... So let me inject some actual brains into this conversation.

If I sell account ABC to @Sythe in 4 payments of 80m, Sythe then gives me one payment. Sythe now owns 1/4 of the account, the 3/4 of the account still needs to be paid off. Lets say Sythe not sells the account ABC to @Shin for 320m. Sythe has successfully sold the account to Shin, but only owned 1/4 of the account and scammed 3/4 of it from ME.

@Colts7841 was paid some some % of the account from Racks, it is COMPLETELY ridiculous that Colts would get 100% of the account back, because he doesnt own 100% of the account (Racks did pay him for some % of it). @EskyBoy owns the % of the account that Racks paid to Colts, and got scammed the 1-(%x100) of whatever was paid. If Colts wants the account (and he is entitled to recovering it since he was not paid the full amount), he ows EksyBoy whatever Racks paid him for the account. He cannot keep the account in addition to what Racks paid him.

Let me hopefully break this down to help people that dont get it.

1. Colts sold the accounts to Racks for 200m (4 payments of 50m).
2. Racks paid Colts 50m for the first payment (25%).
3. Racks sells the account to Esky for 300m.
Note: Esky forfeits the extra 100m ontop, he got merched, it happens.
4. Racks does not pay Colts the rest, so Colts recovers the account.
5. Colts owes Eksy 25% of the original sale price to Racks, whatever Racks paid him. Colts is now whole, he has his account and nothing more. Eksy is the real victim here, and isnt repaid in full, but at least is paid something.

Racks is banned for scamming the price he sold the account to Esky (minus whatever he paid to Colts, which Colts will give to Eksy).

Tada! Case closed. Thanks everyone for reading. Now on to the next person Gun scams.
 
Last edited:
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
read posts 1-50 and 140 onwards. fuck you guys for posting so much in so little time.

as i see it:
  • racks scammed colts by not paying for the account in full
  • as a result, colts was right to recover the account
  • racks scammed esky by convincing him to buy someone he, racks, didn't really own
  • colts isn't liable for racks' actions but forwarding the payment of 80m that racks paid him to esky offsets some of esky's losses
i vote colts sends esky 80m and keeps his account. if not that then colts keeps his account and esky gets nothing. this is essentially what would happen if racks had recovered the account he sold to esky; in either case, esky was dealing with an untrustworthy seller, and that's no fault of colts'
 
Last edited:
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Well I think this is pretty cut and dry... I dont see why people are arguing about it..... So let me inject some actual brains into this conversation.

If I sell account ABC to @Sythe in 4 payments of 80m, Sythe then gives me one payment. Sythe now owns 1/4 of the account, the 3/4 of the account still needs to be paid off. Lets say Sythe not sells the account ABC to @Shin for 320m. Sythe has successfully sold the account to Shin, but only owned 1/4 of the account and scammed 3/4 of it from ME.

@Colts7841 was paid some some % of the account from Racks, it is COMPLETELY ridiculous that Colts would get 100% of the account back, because he doesnt own 100% of the account (Racks did pay him for some % of it). @EskyBoy owns the % of the account that Racks paid to Colts, and got scammed the 1-(%x100) of whatever was paid. If Colts wants the account (and he is entitled to recovering it since he was not paid the full amount), he ows EksyBoy whatever Racks paid him for the account. He cannot keep the account in addition to what Racks paid him.

Let me hopefully break this down to help people that dont get it.

1. Colts sold the accounts to Racks for 200m (4 payments of 50m).
2. Racks paid Colts 50m for the first payment.
3. Racks sells the account to Esky for 300m.
Note: Esky forfeits the extra 100m ontop, he got merched, it happens.
4. Racks does not pay Colts the rest, so colts recovers the account.
5. Colts owes Eksy 25% of the original sale price to Racks, whatever Racks paid him. Colts is now whole, he has his account and nothing more. Eksy is the real victim here, and isnt repaid in full, but at least is paid something.

I also originally conceived it this way, but its not how rent-to-own agreements go. There is a risk on the side of the seller when giving someone possession of an asset which has not yet been paid off. For example the account could be banned for botting or RWT or it could be stolen while in possession of the rent-to-owner. The compensation for this additional risk the seller is taking on is that if the buyer doesn't complete the contract, the amount already paid is forfeit. In other words the risk on each side is balanced by the risk on the other. Afaik this is standard for these contracts unless it is explicitly written otherwise. Equivalent to losing your deposit.

Because accounts are an indivisible whole the idea of owning fractional amounts of an account is difficult. The only way you could do it is through an entity which owns the entire account, which itself is comprised of share or stakeholders. Then these stakeholders would take turns through some predetermined means. We're not going to setup such a thing to resolve this dispute. The only other solution to fractional ownership is to sell the account to a third party then split the funds as a result of that sale. (An idea that hasn't been floated yet incidentally.)
 
Last edited:
Two Factor Authentication User
Stay a while and listen
Twitter
Tier 1 Prizebox
Dolan Duck
Member of the Month Winner
Creamy
Baby Yoda
Chansey
Dragon Claws
Garchomp
Hey... this isnt a fun rank
Lawrence
Nitro Booster
Penguin
Pikachu
Tier 2 Prizebox
Tier 3 Prizebox
Tier 4 Prizebox
Tier 5 Prizebox
Tier 6 Prizebox
The compensation for this additional risk the seller is taking on is that if the buyer doesn't complete the contract, the amount already paid is forfeit. In other words the risk on each side is balanced by the risk on the other. Afaik this is standard for these contracts unless it is explicitly written otherwise. Equivalent to losing your deposit.

If this is true, than in all respects the account has been the equivalent of banned by Jagex (resold) and then Colts should not be able to recover it. He went into this contract with increased risk, and he took the risk and it didnt pull off. Colts should then not be able to screw Eksy out of the acc. He took the gamble and lost, he doesnt get a win now for it.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
If this is true, than in all respects the account has been the equivalent of banned by Jagex (resold) and then Colts should not be able to recover it. He went into this contract with increased risk, and he took the risk and it didnt pull off. Colts should then not be able to screw Eksy out of the acc. He took the gamble and lost, he doesnt get a win now for it.

Changing the facts of the case to determine the outcome, interesting lol...

So I take out insurance against hail damage on my car, and it hails the next day. Your argument is that it might just as well have caught fire, for which I had no insurance, therefore I shouldn't get my hail payout.
 
Last edited:
Two Factor Authentication User
Stay a while and listen
Twitter
Tier 1 Prizebox
Dolan Duck
Member of the Month Winner
Creamy
Baby Yoda
Chansey
Dragon Claws
Garchomp
Hey... this isnt a fun rank
Lawrence
Nitro Booster
Penguin
Pikachu
Tier 2 Prizebox
Tier 3 Prizebox
Tier 4 Prizebox
Tier 5 Prizebox
Tier 6 Prizebox
There is a risk on the side of the seller when giving someone possession of an asset which has not yet been paid off. For example the account could be banned for botting or RWT or it could be stolen while in possession of the rent-to-owner. The compensation for this additional risk the seller is taking on is that if the buyer doesn't complete the contract, the amount already paid is forfeit

No I simply added reselling to your own list as quoted above
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top