- Joined
- Apr 21, 2005
- Sythe Gold
- 5,470
- Messages
- 8,074
- Discord Unique ID
- 742989175824842802
- Discord Username
- Sythe
Again, I see you're trying to take a black/white point of view but this really isn't the case in this situation.
Colts should have never vouched for Racks if the trade was not completed. But because he DID (when he shouldn't have) it mis-lead someone into buying the account from Racks.
As I already said, this is at least equally weighed by the lack of due diligence to contact the original owner IMHO.
Aswell as this, Colts had a week to confront Racks on his selling of an account that wasn't his, and by not doing so it also mis-leads Esky into thinking his purchase would be safe.
This I do not accept. Why would colts be watching the account market? If you rented a house to someone do you then watch the real estate listings to make sure it hasn't been put on the market? Why would you?
But that's just my 2 cents I agree that the account should be returned to Esky, Colts got scammed by Racks and that should not be taken out of Eskys pocket just because he failed to contact the OO before purchase, he clearly wouldn't have purchased the account if there was any visible issue.
I think it's safe to say Esky would have never bought the account if Colts didn't leave a vouch, nor would he have bought it if Colts confronted Racks like he should have.
Since the facts are controversial in this case (i.e. what constitutes due diligence, what constitutes negligence, if the vouch estops colts from recovery) I am going to leave it to a staff vote as a sort of jury case, but that will only happen after we're satisfied on balance that Esky is not Racks.
Last edited:





























































