I have both on my main... i've honestly never used overloads they're just rotting in my bank. prayer makes every day things so easy. with SS you can finish any slayer task without banking. i love having 99 pray
yeah but why waste like 200m for 99 just for looks, i mean seriously you would hardly were a skillcape anyways unless like skilling and that many people have it anyways so... why not just pick the one that is more useful
if you want my opinion on herblore... just wait til the double xp weekends. what i did after i got 92. i spent about 130m for 99 herblore using double xp weekends
Both are fairly useless after 95 for pray and 96 for herb so just for looks I would choose prayer even though it is more common, the emote is just so much better and I prefer the white cape over the green.