I'm going to apologize in advance for the wall of text, but it is very necessary if we are going to be nitpicky on every single detail here.
To Techie and the wider moderation team - if we're going to open dialogue and reevaluate here, then I'd like to bring to attention the actual numbers for Callisto and the Hitpoints XP, since Glacier has again understated the amount of hitpoints experience gained (shock) for his own benefit.
Talking Point 1) 3528713 HP XP gained (Levels 79 - 89, 18811 XP just shy of level 90) (On spreadsheet already under All Skills Table in XP Difference column) (Also verifiable on wiseoldman.net) 6428 Callisto kills 1330 Hitpoints XP per Callisto kill Total HP XP gained divided by HP XP gained per Callisto Kill: 3528713 / 1330 = 2,653.1676691729323308270676691729 Max possible solo kills = 2654 (rounded up as an extra kill would be required to account for the fractional amount) Average loot per Callisto Kill (Per the wiki) 146,329.52 Maximum Possible Kills multiplied by average loot per Callisto KC: 2654 x 146,329.52 = 388,358,546.08 GP Owed = 388,358,547 GP (Rounded up to account for a whole GP being required to account for the excess fractional amount).
Talking Point 2) Techie you've made an estimate on the amount of service completed. Initially, I would have been happy to let it slide and continue with the proposed compensation, but now that we have reached another argument with Glacier, I'd like to point out some very big flaws in this line of thinking.
You've stated that for Slayer, it would have been 65 hours at EHP. Runecrafting has also been mentioned as a 40 hour task. Glacier is simply not an EHP player. Not even close to it. How can I make this assumption? Simply by going off the evidence presented to us. If you look at the bank video I provided, the money had already been stolen and it was just full of wildy rag gear and barebones basics like abyssal whip. No combat potions, no teleports, no end game gear.
I had provided for this - but Glacier himself stole that money and farmed Callisto instead. Considering he eventually admitted that at least 300m of the 560m provided to him was stolen off of the account (you know when he miraculously claimed his younger brother took it off the account after previous conflicting claims of "it's all in the bank" and he was "buying skills in GP") and I've provided calculations to you already about how he still hasn't paid back the full amount of the initial theft, it would have been impossible for him to have trained using expensive EHP methods.
There is also the prior evidence of him sending screenshots of him making super attack potions for Herblore, Motherlode mine for mining and and Barbarian Fishing for fishing all of which are low efficiency methods - not close to EHP. Are we going to assume that he would get EHP slayer rates doing standard slayer with a whip? No, it'd probably take significantly longer than this. There wasn't even barrage runes in the bank since he had ice sacks for gp farming callisto.
We can also see he used Guardians of the Rift as his runecraft method. Again not even close to EHP. The same would go for Agility, he didn't even enter the Hallowed Sepulchre, so there was no chance he was getting EHP rates (I know this since the collection log has no sepulchre loot). Those few agility levels alone would have taken upwards of 20 hours using the methods available outside of sepulchre.
Surely the suggestion isn't that Glacier would be achieving EHP rates with a barebones bank, no gear, no supplies and matching rates that even the most hardcore of content creators such as Lake, Boaty and Autumn Elegy struggle to maintain.
As a matter of fact, looking at the remnants in the bank, the screenshots Glacier himself has shown (Motherlode Mine, Afk Barbarian Fishing, Super Attack potions) - He showed these, not me. These are very low cost, low efficiency and low xp rate methods compared to what is available. Going off of all of the above, I am arguing that him even being halfway close to EHP rate is entirely unreasonable. It's simply not possible for him, given what he himself has shown to us in screenshots.
Talking Point 3) The membership time. Techie, you've stated that there is no repayment for this as it's a relationship between myself and Jagex. I would have agreed with this had it not been for the fact that I did not put membership on the account, I simply provided Glacier twelve bonds on the account to use at his own discretion. To which he CHOSE to not progress the job and gold farm Callisto instead. He willingly chose to redeem bonds whenever it suited him to ultimately use for his own purposes instead of servicing the account. I didn't top up the membership balance - he did. This was not an agreement between myself and Jagex. It was a choice Glacier chose to make himself in redeeming bonds. If we wanted to gold farm he should do this on his OWN accounts with his OWN money, not mine.
Talking Point 4) Techie you've mentioned that the team don't hand monetary evaluations for account damage/value unless the ToS has an agreement for staff to review. Does this imply that in every single service agreement on Sythe, there needs to be a clause for what the persons on the account should NOT be doing? For example, If I paid for a mining service, do I need to explicitly state not to go PKing? Surely common sense needs to be applied here for a case such as this, as it would in this hypothetical mining example. Just some food for thought here.
Talking Point 5) Finally I'd like to address not only the admin and moderation teams but the entire community. Glacier has proven mutliple times, between his constant story changes, outright lies, moderation impersonation and blatant disregard for any presented facts or verdict that doesn't suit him that he's an untrustworthy scammer. It's beyond debate at this point. So considering the irrefutable fact that he has indeed scammed me on the work and since attempted to scam me on the amount to be repaid, why are we giving him any grace at all? He's done nothing but waste my time, the moderation team's time and the entire community's time stonewalling the process at every turn. It would be remiss of me to tell moderation how to do their jobs (you guys do this everyday and I'm thankful for the community that's been built) however I believe it sets a poor precedent going forward if we keep on bending the knee to this kind of behavior as it will embolden scammers in the future if they think they're going to still be rewarded regardless.
I will be reporting my own post to post some sensitive evidence to further my case. This will be the update wiseoldman link showing what Glacier achieved in the timeframe. I am also linking two videos, proving that EHP was not exactly in the gameplan here for slayer. Glacier's own screenshots in the second video will also be indicative of this for the other skills. You can see in the video that the unlocked tasks and the kill log shows that he focused on high value, low xp efficiency mobs. Again - not close to EHP. We're looking at 15-20k xp per hour at BEST doing these methods for slayer. From that video, you'll be able to see that even looking at Slayer, he wasn't prioritizing doing the job - his unlocks (exclusively money making options) and chosen tasks show that he was using my account for himself to profit rather than completing the task. (Please check the report I make on this post.)
