Training Weapon

[Emperor Nero]

I just got 75 attack to use a BGS that I bought. Is it unreasonable to stop using my whip and start using my BGS to train? Whip takes 6 - 8 hits to kill an rock crab, BGS takes usually 4. What weapon is ideal for training? I am going to 70 defense and 70 strength now. Thanks.

 

[Chivava]

The ideal weapons for training is;
Well thats atleast what i am using, tho im using Chaotic Rapier as of now.

Attack Chaotic Rapier/Longsword/Maul<Whip
Strength Chaotic Rapier/Longsword/Maul<Saradomin Sword
Defence Chaotic Rapier/Longsword/Maul<Whip

 

[rape.exe]

Depends on what overall gives you the best xp/hr. If the BGS' longer timed hits give you more xp/hr than what you get from using your faster whip but takes longer for a kill, stay with the BGS', vice versa.

 

[Emperor Nero]

I will be training at the moss giants and have no access to chaotics... Forgot to add that in.

 

[&#924;XD3000]

I'd say whip is more effictive for training than BGS is.

 

[bloodymager]

The ideal weapons for training is;
Well thats atleast what i am using, tho im using Chaotic Rapier as of now.

Attack Chaotic Rapier/Longsword/Maul<Whip
Strength Chaotic Rapier/Longsword/Maul<Saradomin Sword
Defence Chaotic Rapier/Longsword/Maul<Whip

did you mean to use > ?

i train with chaotic rapier, but a whip + dragon defender is good enough if you don't have the dungeoneering requirement.

 

[Som3guy]

I'd say a whip would be your best bet, I believe the attack speeds gives you a better xp/hour.

 

[CreativeNub]

Whip should be way better xp/hr then BGS, I would try to get some more accurate info if I were you.

 

[Emperor Nero]

Whip should be way better xp/hr then BGS, I would try to get some more accurate info if I were you.

I don't know what you mean, I wasn't making any claims. I was just asking opinions to make sure that I was doing the thing that would get me the most exp/h.

 

[Stogie]

Tbh , Whip is way better BGS is like rubbish I don't like it tbh and that whips more faster.

 

[Eternity Gaming]

Whip is so much better than BGS, but try to get them chaotics. That will speed up your training so much.

 

[Emperor Nero]

Chaotics are hard to get without IDunge and I don't got any cash or GP to get Idunge.

 

[Ortho]

A bgs would only be good if you're botting and you're 1-hitting the mobs almost every time. When botting, there is usually a bit of delay between fighting mobs, so the bgs's slow speed wouldn't really make a difference

For the most part, I'd use a whip or a rapier for the best dps

 

[&#9829;Z&#9829;]

sara sword?

whip + dragon defender. not sure how sara sword would stand with it though

 

[DoubleJRBacon]

sara sword for strength, whip for attack/defence

dragon scim for str if you're a pure

ranging guild for range if you're a pure or poor main.

 

[Zerkerfist]

I personally don't like the BGS for training. Its too slow. I would stick with a whip for training your defence, and either use a D scim + dragon defender for strength training, or an SS if you want.

 

[runepwnage]

Whip or a scim.

 

[Falmar]

Whip/ss.
the best option is rapier

 

[Chivava]

did you mean to use > ?

i train with chaotic rapier, but a whip + dragon defender is good enough if you don't have the dungeoneering requirement.

Hehe yeah, i didnt notice it.
However for Moss Giants i would recommend Saradomin Sword or Whip.

 

[TheBailey]

I would have thought whip+dragon defender would beat bgs in the long run though.