• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Staff Feedback

Steam Account Verifier
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Community Participant
Do you all seriously think that the actual topic of the eBook played no role in the number of copies sold? He invested days into creating a lengthy, professional piece of writing, so stop acting like you received nothing for your "donated" money when you knew exactly what the fuck you were buying. Also, he even said he didn't buy a laptop with the money (not that it would have mattered if he did, it could have been used for school). Why can't you just take his word for it and leave him be?

Hopefully you're all happy with yourselves. He resigned.
 
Today is the day you people who couldn't leave well enough alone drove one of the best administrators out of his position. Congratulations.
 
-sigh-
well you got what you wanted, I cant believe how fucking ridiculous this got to a point that Finn had to justify how he used the money he had received via sales, actually come to think about it, Finn seemed to have to justify pretty much every single thing he ever did, all he got was criticism, yet has had huge influence on some if not all of the most substantial changes here on sythe.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Detective
Heidy
Hopefully you're all happy with yourselves, drove him to resignation.

He was a good admin, but if he feels leaving is the right decision for him, so be it. No one asked him to leave; they only asked him to acknowledge a fault.
 
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
I'd like to submit a formal complaint about JohnK.

I dislike the way he is handling the competitions here on Sythe.org

My first issue has to do with the Connect Four Tournament that he hosted. The 64 slots quickly filled up and even after, there were users still wanting to participate. In the first round, a few users were banned - therefore unable to compete. He chose to give their opponents first-round byes. If this were truly a community event, which is meant to bring members of Sythe closer together - why did he exclude members such as myself who were more than willing to take the spots of the aforementioned?

I made it clear that if a user is banned or resigns the places wouldn't be filled. When you run a 64 player tournament, you'll understand why.

Additionally he excluded Sythe Freestyle Rap competition located here: http://sythe.org/showthread.php?t=1226899

As you can see in that thread, I was one of the first entries into the contest. Unfortunately JohnK took it upon himself to once again exclude me from the community's festivities for some unknown reason, possibly because he has a bias against me. It is a freestyle competition, where we submit our art. I believe it's quite unfair that he chose to censor my speech and disallow me the opportunity to win with his reason being that my entry was a joke.

Weird Al Yankovic has created many covers of songs and parodies and satires. I would put my creation in the same category. Although it does not have the same theme or niche as most of the other entries do, I feel my piece of work deserves the same chance of winning this competition as the others do.

Sigh. I thought I made this clear with you already. No, I don't have a biased against you; due to the number of entries and polls being limited to 25 options, I just choose not to include what I felt were troll or inappropriate entries - I told you this a number of times last night. To anybody wondering what the entry was - http://sythe.org/showpost.php?p=9608985&postcount=31
 
Nobody forced Finn to resign, he simply stated because of university. Second I bought the Facebook ebook, saw something was incorect, and then pmed Finn (with the solution to), no achknowledge of it being changed ect, so in my eyes all of them will be wrong if anybody purchased after me. Then see the macbook thread, which annoyed me as I thought the same which then led me to believe he didn't care as long as he got the money; If he didn't change it the guide would become useless in one place? All it would of taken is a pm saying "changed it".
 
Nobody forced Finn to resign, he simply stated because of university. Second I bought the Facebook ebook, saw something was incorect, and then pmed Finn (with the solution to), no achknowledge of it being changed ect, so in my eyes all of them will be wrong if anybody purchased after me. Then see the macbook thread, which annoyed me as I thought the same which then led me to believe he didn't care as long as he got the money; If he didn't change it the guide would become useless in one place? All it would of taken is a pm saying "changed it".

Admins get loads of PMs every day, hey may not have had the chance to read it.
 
Admins get loads of PMs every day, hey may not have had the chance to read it.

He achknowledged it on his thread when I posted its incorect in my feedback for it, then said pm me, so I did; not like he didn't expect it coming. Besides, if its something your selling, you make sure its correct..
 
Finn was a great admin. Although he showed a lot of sarcasm and bashed others, he always had a point. Talk to him for a month and the way you view things would be different, and you’d have Finn to thank.

If Finn made a mistake, it's that he carelessly publically stated that he had bought a macbook, which of course aroused suspicions, as people believed that he bought it withthe donation money. However, I believe Finn to be a person of morals and proper standards, that he would never do such a thing.

In addition, if he did, he would have not come announcing it in public and kept it to himself. He is not nine years old.

It was just all bad timing, and could have been avoided had Finn's excitement over his macbook had not clouded his judgement. That was Finn's one and only fault.
 
I'd first like to say how disgusting, libellous and offensive I find the remarks that have been made here without asking me about the situation at hand. Not only do the aforementioned posts have nothing at all to do with the way in which I fulfil my role, but they make a number of false allegations.

The notion that I have bought a ''shiny new MacBook'' with money that I EARNED by writing two long & well-received eBooks is completely and utterly false. Had anyone asked me about this before assuming I had bought my new laptop with funds I made, I would have explained the situation; instead, and, as ever, feedback has been made baselessly. My mother paid for my MacBook with my own money. When my grandmother died in 2003, she left behind a small amount of money to be used to cover some of the expenses which would be incurred during my time at university, which my mother has kept in a bank account under her control since my grandmother's death, seeing as I was 10 when she died. As I've said, the amount she left was small, and my mother and I agreed that I should buy a competent laptop with it for university. My old laptop simply was not adequate - not only was the mousepad well and truly broken, but the screen was becoming increasingly disconnected from the body of the laptop. To make matters worse, the fan was broken and so the laptop could not be moved at all - instead, it had to remain on my desk at all times - HARDLY suitable for university, where moving your laptop around in order to take it with you to seminars and lectures, for example, is necessary. Furthermore, I didn't make nearly enough money to buy the MacBook, and the money that I did make has so far been used to buy various necessary items for my place of accommodation - namely cutlery, plates, bedding, and various other essentials. This weekend when I arrive, I'll be able to buy the assortment of textbooks I need from a second hand bookstall.

Now, given that this feedback has absolutely nothing to do with the quality of my site administration, and also given that what I spend the money I have EARNED has NOTHING to do with anyone but me, I would not usually respond to such character assassination attempts. However, given that many of the aforementioned comments are not only completely off-the-mark but also libellous, I felt the need to clarify. I am offended & shocked by the assumptions some of you have drawn and would advise those that have jumped to conclusions to reevaluate the way they act - some very grave remarks have been made here.

Although I hope I have dispelled the false and baseless assertions made above, I would say that, in future, you have absolutely no right to comment on the way in which I spend my money.

You seem to be under the misconception that people are spending five, ten, fifteen, thirty dollars for a fourteen page eBook you wrote because they simply want to read it and be more informed about your Sythe career. While I'm sure this is part of the reason people bought the eBook, the number of people who would of bought it from you would have been significantly less if you were not in need of financial aid. I fully sympathise with your real life situation, however, I'm sure that they were just a little concerned about how their money - given to you out of the goodness of their hearts because of your real life situation - was being spent.

I respect you as a staff member and it is sad to see you go, considering all that you've done for the site. I really hope that the criticism on how they believed you to spend your money was not the cause of your leave.

Do you all seriously think that the actual topic of the eBook played no role in the number of copies sold? He invested days into creating a lengthy, professional piece of writing, so stop acting like you received nothing for your "donated" money when you knew exactly what the fuck you were buying. Also, he even said he didn't buy a laptop with the money (not that it would have mattered if he did, it could have been used for school). Why can't you just take his word for it and leave him be?

Hopefully you're all happy with yourselves. He resigned.

Nobody is saying that it played no role in the number of copies sold and nobody is denying the effort put into it. Realistically though, how many of those copies do you think were bought because people wanted to help him, an administrator who has contributed greatly to Sythe, when he was in a difficult situation? Do you really think people would be spending five to thirty-five dollars (I believe FireZ spent something around this mark for it) for a 14 page eBook? Many hardcopy books with hundreds of pages sell for only five or ten dollars. The authors of the aforementioned books have poured hundreds of days into writing them. They know "what the fuck they were "buying", but clearly the members who complained bought it with the intent of helping Finn out. Do you think they would have bought it otherwise? If I told someone I was in need of financial aid and my friend bought a slip of paper with a joke on it for 100$ in order to aid me, do you really think he'll be amused to find out I spent it on a shopping spree? Sure, they knew "what the fuck they were buying" but that doesn't mean they don't have a right to be irritated if they believed that Finn was not in a situation of financial difficulty afterall or that he was, but opted to spend the money on a shopping spree, especially if they bought the book with the intention of helping out. Granted, this wasn't the case and Finn didn't spend it on the Macbook, but he could have cleared it up easily and resolved the situation by simply saying it was a gift. The people posting criticism as to (what they believed) Finn had done were not in the wrong at all.
 
Detective
Top Striker
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Sythe Awards 2010 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Heidy
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
I paid 50m for his ebook. I'm content with my purchase FTR. I really could care less what he did with my 50m gp.
 
I paid 50m for his ebook. I'm content with my purchase FTR. I really could care less what he did with my 50m gp.

Exactly this.

I think the thread should stick to staff feedback, not discuss why Finn resigned.
 
Lumpy Space Princess
Le
Pokémon Trainer
Two Factor Authentication User
Whilst I appreciate that debating is something you guys might enjoy, it would be great if more of you could post some feedback on the other staff members!
 
Christmas 2014
Halloween 2014
Easter 2015
Homosex
Whilst I appreciate that debating is something you guys might enjoy, it would be great if more of you could post some feedback on the other staff members!

On that note, Giverny has been doing an excellent job lately, and her activity has nearly tripled within the past few weeks. :)
 
Sin has been doing an absolutely amazing job lately. I also love the anon feedback idea, that will help people get to post if they are scared about it.
 
I'd like to congratulate the whole staff team on clearing the report a scammer section. It is completely empty and by the looks of the new updates it's going to stay empty.
 
Kudos to the entire staff for dealing with RaSc and spam reports. I have never seen it so empty great job!
 
Runescape Gamblingrunescape gambling
Back
Top