• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

[Denied] Section for Auctions?

Status
Not open for further replies.
<3 n4n0
Baby Yoda
Candy Man
CoolHam
Easter 2023
Extreme Homosex
Gohan has AIDS
Green eggs and spam
Heidy
Homosex
Hoover
Lawrence
Nitro Booster
Penguin
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Potamus
Shitting Rainbow
St. Patrick's Day 2026
Summer 2026
Tier 1 Prizebox
Two Factor Authentication User
Valentine's Day 2026
How'd you enforce sales tho?

Assume: someone "auctions" a max main
Max bid ends at 10$
Seller decides not to sell for that

Is it a scam?

Scenario 2:
Sellers friend keeps over bidding
Wins the auction
Winner pulls back, having inflated price highly
Runner-up should pay way overpriced due to friend outbidding ?
 
Extreme Homosex
Heidy
Pokémon Trainer
Potamus
How'd you enforce sales tho?

Assume: someone "auctions" a max main
Max bid ends at 10$
Seller decides not to sell for that

Is it a scam?

Scenario 2:
Sellers friend keeps over bidding
Wins the auction
Winner pulls back, having inflated price highly
Runner-up should pay way overpriced due to friend outbidding ?

Agreed. It is vulnerable for manipulation.

A good way to mitigate this would be conduct auctions with a sealed bidding approach (everyone submits sealed bids and no one will know the bid of others).

However, given that Sythe forums is public, I do not see how this can be conducted in that manner.
 
Agreed. It is vulnerable for manipulation.

A good way to mitigate this would be conduct auctions with a sealed bidding approach (everyone submits sealed bids and no one will know the bid of others).

However, given that Sythe forums is public, I do not see how this can be conducted in that manner.
if done "invisibly" a user can post then delete the faster he can I suppose? and at the end of the date, the Owner of the Auction can ask a mod to post the highest offer?
 
<3 n4n0
Baby Yoda
Candy Man
CoolHam
Easter 2023
Extreme Homosex
Gohan has AIDS
Green eggs and spam
Heidy
Homosex
Hoover
Lawrence
Nitro Booster
Penguin
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Potamus
Shitting Rainbow
St. Patrick's Day 2026
Summer 2026
Tier 1 Prizebox
Two Factor Authentication User
Valentine's Day 2026
if done "invisibly" a user can post then delete the faster he can I suppose? and at the end of the date, the Owner of the Auction can ask a mod to post the highest offer?
A lot of effort
Also - if email notifications are enabled you can read deleted posts in your email

& - unnecessary busywork for mod team
 
Community Development Team Member
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
Member of the Quarter Winner
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
HamSanta
Verified Ironman
May the 4th Be With You
Detective
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
March Madness
Top Striker
Pokémon Trainer
Halloween 2023
Valentine's Day 2024
Christmas 2024
Easter 2026
if done "invisibly" a user can post then delete the faster he can I suppose? and at the end of the date, the Owner of the Auction can ask a mod to post the highest offer?

Removes the whole point of an auction for the seller imo. U want to have 2 or more people bid against eachother to raise the prize. That wont happen then.
 
Christmas 2024
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
OG Club
Christmas 2013
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Winter Olympics 2022
March Madness
Easter 2020
Christmas 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2022
Halloween 2022
Christmas 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2023
Valentine's Day 2023
Summer 2023
Easter 2023
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Poképedia
Christmas 2023
Halloween 2023
HamSanta
Easter 2024
PHP Shit Show 2k26
How'd you enforce sales tho?

Assume: someone "auctions" a max main
Max bid ends at 10$
Seller decides not to sell for that

Is it a scam?

Scenario 2:
Sellers friend keeps over bidding
Wins the auction
Winner pulls back, having inflated price highly
Runner-up should pay way overpriced due to friend outbidding ?

Having a "reserve" system in place would alleviate the issue surrounding scenario #1. You could also create rules that would prevent issue #2 (IE - only the winning bid is binding).


With that said, I'm not sure that an auction section is worth the time or effort. Buyers are free to make offers below the asking price on accounts that are for sale on Sythe.
 
Last edited:
No support from me sorry man, we auction off scam users mini ranks and that's a shit show already
 
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
I saw Matthew
OG Club
Discord Verified
SytheSteamer
WoW Classic
Member of the Month Winner
Photography Competition Winner
In Memory of Jon
May the 4th Be With You
Member of the Quarter Winner
Two Factor Authentication User
Detective
Carrot
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
No support from me sorry man, we auction off scam users mini ranks and that's a shit show already
This. I think it’s mostly a postfarming charade and the only reason it’s going well is because the auctioneer is a staff member. This opens up for a whole new market I don’t think Sythe is ready for.
 
This. I think it’s mostly a postfarming charade and the only reason it’s going well is because the auctioneer is a staff member. This opens up for a whole new market I don’t think Sythe is ready for.
Exactly. With most people being auto bumpers (why I haven't gone to 300 yet) and the odd auction on mini ranks, it just has no real appeal
 
PHP Shit Show 2k26
If staff found a way to moderate this, this would be super super addition to the forums.
 
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Verified Ironman
I saw Matthew
Member of the Month Winner
Detective
Discord Verified
Toast Wallet User
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
March Madness
May the 4th Be With You
Nitro Booster
Two Factor Authentication User
Staff of the Quarter Winner
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poképedia
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Been suggested few times in the past.

[Denied] Auction forum
We currently allow auctions but will not be adding additional 'auction forums'. If you are to create an auction thread, you mustt post a clear TOS. Users found backing out of the agreement or manipulating auctions (friends posting, fake bidding, etc) will be given a TWC.

Auction
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top