• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Society without taxation requested by sythe

  • Thread starter Thread starter wombakage
  • Start date Start date
W

wombakage

Guest
It's irrelevant to the issue at hand.

Syllogistic reasoning does not need to prove that its conclusions do not lead to undesirable conclusions, only that its conclusions follow from its premises.

If you have a problem with the method of reason, then you should take it up with Aristotle.

On the topic of how to run a society without insane thugs running around stealing 40% of your income, start a new thread and we can discuss it further.



So yes, how can a society function without taxation? Is it a voluntary contribution with benefits? Is it Anarchy?
 
You're asking all the wrong questions. You should begin by asking why you're giving your freedom and money away despite the fact that you've never signed a contract and you'll never meet the people benefiting from your enslavement.
 
Stop being such a text book Libertarian. Your response is similar to reactionary, theistic responses to those doubting the existence of God. Why not engage his questions? They pertain to modern societies. Many people have no conception of how society could function without the state and its innumerable welfare elements. Perhaps explain how a society could function without taxation? Whilst in agreement with your sentiments, I grow tired of reading the same, regurigtated posts about ideology when the thread is concerned with practicality.

For the original poster:

Anarchy is the absence of the state (i.e. no government). You ask how society can function without taxation. How can't it? Private sectors, for example, provide services that the state has provided (and likely to a better standard)

I was trying to teach him to question his views. Pragmatism is tough to apply to concepts that haven't been practiced without spending a huge amount of time.

I'll try to make my argument more accessible by addressing a few pros and cons.

Let's first look at the function of government. The idea is that we sacrifice our own freedom and resources for the betterment of society as a whole.

Let's look at just a few of your sacrifices.
You're must pay 40% of your income to support the government. If you don't pay, you'll be imprisoned.
You must sacrifice your privacy, in that the government is able to tap into your phone lines, internet history, anything (see Patriot Act).
You must be prepared to sacrifice your property at any time (see asset forfeiture).
You must sacrifice the very freedom to do with your own body as you will (see drug restrictions, anti-SSU laws, incarceration based upon family consent, conscription).
You can't even own your own gun without the government knowing about it.

The penalty for failure to submit to any of these is removal of property, imprisonment, even death, all of which fly directly in the face of the Constitution.

John Locke, the proponent of "life, liberty, and property," the man whose ideas the Constitution was founded upon, would be ashamed of the country in which you live. You can be killed for failure to kill others, removing your right to life. The government prevents you from doing with your body as you will, removing your right to liberty. The government can seize your property without cause, and places restrictions on what you can do with your own land, removing your right to property.

Now that you're aware of a small fraction of your sacrifices, ask yourself what the government does for you.

I encourage anyone to list a few of the government's services and I'll show you that these services would be better rendered (and rendered with less cost to you) without the government.
 
Detective
Top Striker
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Sythe Awards 2010 Winner
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Heidy
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
Would it turn into survival of the fittest? Not that most would run around wishing to hurt each other, but think about it.

Start taking away "freebies" that people are used to and they might have to become desperate.


We can give people things 100x faster then we can take them away.
 
Pool Shark
Village Drunk
<3 n4n0
Battleship Champion
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
So yes, how can a society function without taxation?
The Government can own their own companies and they could become Monopolies. The Government is in place to prevent Monopolies from existing, however, so that they can't take advantage of U.S. Citizens.

A recent example of this would be United and Continental Airlines, who are wishing to merge to create the largest airline in the world. This must first be approved by the Government, however. See below:
http://www.bizjournals.com/kansascity/stories/2010/05/03/daily5.html
Is it a voluntary contribution with benefits?
If it wasn't, then how do we have such things in society as police/fire departments, courts, grants, banks, a set minimum wage, and the like?
Is it Anarchy?
What do you mean by this?
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
So yes, how can a society function without taxation? Is it a voluntary contribution with benefits? Is it Anarchy?

Ok let's do a thought experiment.

100 years ago there was no income tax in the US.
(This was the most productive era of the most productive country in history.)

So it's fairly well established that you do not need an income tax to have law and order.

Next imagine that parliament only sat for 1 day a year.
Would the system collapse? Hardly, it would just mean no new bills were passed, which would prevent all the disaster you see before you.

Next imagine that the money you are paid in is gold and silver, as dictated by your constitution. Now you have honest banks and no banking crisis, you keep what you earn and you can save and invest it anyway you wish. You would also pay much less for housing, as there would be orders of magnitude less bubble-driven speculation in real-estate.

Next imagine that the US private rail network had not been effectively nationalized by the US highway building scheme. You would catch privately managed rail or other transport to and from work, without congestion (for this is unprofitable), and using as little energy as possible.

Next imagine that central planners never zoned cities, and the courts never created the mercantilist case-law which disallows class action suits against large industry on the grounds of pollution. Cities would be built in accordance with market forces, you would probably commute 10 minutes to work and not two hours. The level of security of your suburb would be in accordance with the amount you are willing to pay for security, which itself is a function of the amount you need to secure.

Next imagine that guns were not all but outlawed, and people open carried. Shop keepers would have cheap easy self-protection, and due to equal deterrence (both parties have guns, neither is willing to try their luck) crime would quickly drop.

Next imagine that all the regulations that exist today were wiped out. You no longer have to attend a government school, you can either choose to go to a technical college, or take up a trade, or work part time and pursue your own interests.

Essentially if you bother to think about it for even five minutes, you will quickly realize that the extent to which your life is basically terrible is the extent to which your political masters are feeding off you.

Then its only a short leap to realise that the common law... the legal system itself ... which makes this all possible emerged in a similar manner to other emergent standards (such as the english language) and that it was never necessary to have a government in the first place. Civilization comes before government. And this is perfectly obvious in your everyday life, because you don't cower in terror everytime you lose sight of a police officer. You have a natural expectation that your basic interaction with other human beings is going to be a trade relationship, and they have the same expectation.
 
Next imagine that guns were not all but outlawed, and people open carried. Shop keepers would have cheap easy self-protection, and due to equal deterrence (both parties have guns, neither is willing to try their luck) crime would quickly drop.

Playing devils advocate here. What makes you certain that more guns means less crime? What evidence is there that criminals will be less violent in their actions because homeowners are armed. Who is to say they won't parade into dwellings in groups rather than as individuals.

For arguments sake, my questions pertain to our current societal circumstances. Not the idealogical libertarian model. Hence, there would not be private security as you mentioned. Merely the removal of all gun laws and restrictions.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Playing devils advocate here. What makes you certain that more guns means less crime? What evidence is there that criminals will be less violent in their actions because homeowners are armed. Who is to say they won't parade into dwellings in groups rather than as individuals.

For arguments sake, my questions pertain to our current societal circumstances. Not the idealogical libertarian model. Hence, there would not be private security as you mentioned. Merely the removal of all gun laws and restrictions.

Empirical evidence.

[youtube]qyoLuTjguJA[/youtube]

I have actually done significant research on the connection between gun control and crime. The evidence fits the thought experiment; Gun bans only take the weapons out of the law abiding public -- which leads to a significant increase in crime.

Why else would police need guns, if guns don't stop crime?

As to the escalation of violence to gangs vs gangs over your house. It is unlikely. But even if that happened in the current system, what you'd find is that the police are either too corrupt or too cowardly to protect you anyway. (The police have no duty to protect: http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/28/politics/28scotus.html) So in a very real sense you already live in this relatively lawless environment, where the police only do three things: turn up late and ask for stories from witnesses, take your guns, and seize your property.
 
Empirical evidence.

[youtube]qyoLuTjguJA[/youtube]

I have actually done significant research on the connection between gun control and crime. The evidence fits the thought experiment; Gun bans only take the weapons out of the law abiding public -- which leads to a significant increase in crime.

Why else would police need guns, if guns don't stop crime?

As to the escalation of violence to gangs vs gangs over your house. It is unlikely. But even if that happened in the current system, what you'd find is that the police are either too corrupt or too cowardly to protect you anyway. (The police have no duty to protect: http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/28/politics/28scotus.html) So in a very real sense you already live in this relatively lawless environment, where the police only do three things: turn up late and ask for stories from witnesses, take your guns, and seize your property.

Police need guns to fight fire with fire. Otherwise, it'd be a foolish attempt.

Is the increase related to the mentality of the criminals? Being that less armed homeowners makes it less dangerous?

Why would a private security company be any less cowardly? Humans are humans irrespective of their employer. Everybody wants to go home to their wife and family at the end of the night.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Police need guns to fight fire with fire. Otherwise, it'd be a foolish attempt.

These are good questions.

Is the increase related to the mentality of the criminals? Being that less armed homeowners makes it less dangerous?
Partially yes. There's a reason that disabled and elderly people are much greater break-in targets than say a sharehouse with four adult males living in it. It pertains to the balance of power.

Consider that a robber is trying to use physical force or the threat thereof to seize your property. If their physical force is less than yours then they will not bother. (Who would rob a military base or a police station? -- You'd have to be nuts, it's a suicide mission.) If the balance of power is equal (as in you have a firearm and they have a firearm) then you are leaving the winner up to chance.

The consequence of armed property owners is that the criminals migrate elsewhere to easier targets. Eventually, if everyone becomes armed, the pure biological incentives to be a parasite shift, and the number of overall thieves go down. This coincidences with an increase in production (higher standards of private property lead to more production) which means there are more honest jobs available anyway.

Why would a private security company be any less cowardly? Humans are humans irrespective of their employer. Everybody wants to go home to their wife and family at the end of the night.
Simply because they have skin in the game.

Malls and universities have private roads and private security right now, almost everywhere in the world. Why is this? Because the police will not protect their customers to the extent their customers need protection.

Hiring a security agency usually entails a form of insurance. Whereby if the security agency fails to protect your property then they pay for the lost property. Now the security agency is responsible for the loss of your property, they have every incentive to hire the right people for the job and use the right equipment, and to do the job properly.

This is why, generally speaking, malls and universities are safer than say street corners.
 
Civilization comes before government. And this is perfectly obvious in your everyday life, because you don't cower in terror everytime you lose sight of a police officer.

What came before civilization? Myths

When was the time that myths, governance, and civilization co-existed?

That one time a few centuries ago when one man with a staff inside a building in Italy commanded countless ships and controlled not only the nation; but both worlds.

Your imaginations would play out to look like the Sierra Leone, Rwanda, or even ancient China; people don't behave like you'd imagine when anyone can build thrones out of bayonets.
 
I believe what you are stating. However, are there any case studies on this; ie nations that have attempted to implement it?

No matter the caliber of the security force, they are a reactive unit. They cannot be preventative beyond the measures of a fence etc. So, why would they be any more intimidating. The only intimidating factor I can see is the time in which they arrive. The increase in response time may indeed lead to more sophisticated robberies that are less wing-it and more planned. Surely the criminals would adapt to the conditions.

The criminals could possibly adapt and they themselves enhance their weaponry and tactics. If all sorts of guns are readily available, the criminals would likely arm themselves with what they think to be most sufficient.
 
What came before civilization? Myths

When was the time that myths, governance, and civilization co-existed?

That one time a few centuries ago when one man with a staff inside a building in Italy commanded countless ships and controlled not only the nation; but both worlds.

Your imaginations would play out to look like the Sierra Leone, Rwanda, or even ancient China; people don't behave like you'd imagine when anyone can build thrones out of bayonets.

Evidence to support your claims? The burden of proof is on the shoulders of the accuser.
 
Evidence to support your claims? The burden of proof is on the shoulders of the accuser.

You're.. asking for evidence? As if I'm making these up as I go?

I have two words for you, really, one, but i'll give you two sets of ones should you fancy them:

1. Rodrigo Borgia
2. Sixtus V
 
Police need guns to fight fire with fire. Otherwise, it'd be a foolish attempt.

Is the increase related to the mentality of the criminals? Being that less armed homeowners makes it less dangerous?

Why would a private security company be any less cowardly? Humans are humans irrespective of their employer. Everybody wants to go home to their wife and family at the end of the night.

Private security is for the sole purpose of protection. Police just watch over a broad variety of things. Police in fact do help. Even though they barely are engaged in actual conflicts they maintain order. Private security are paid lotsa money not to be cowardly, policemen are paid to be alive.


Joe schmoe if he sees a burglary is not going to whip out a 9mm and bust a cap. He might hit a bystander and killsome one. I understand that this could occur with police


Sythe are you advocating vigilanties?
 
You're.. asking for evidence? As if I'm making these up as I go?

I have two words for you, really, one, but i'll give you two sets of ones should you fancy them:

1. Rodrigo Borgia
2. Sixtus V

No. Evidence that his theoretical societies would end up in shambles similar to that of African nations.

I don't need a history lesson.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
Your imaginations would play out to look like the Sierra Leone, Rwanda, or even ancient China; people don't behave like you'd imagine when anyone can build thrones out of bayonets.

I think you mean they build shit out of shit.

If you would but stop and think about the matter instead of spewing forth a knee jerk reaction, you'd realise that a centrally planned state is ridiculously inefficient. So much so that were an anarcho-capitalist society to be realized, no one would dare invade.

Does it not occur to you that the reason public schools are used is because endoctrination is all that holds together the shitweb of mercantilist religion which forms the basis of taxation and conquest?

And frankly, you are not helping. It's fine to sit on the sidelines, but you are actively aiding criminals in your intellectual endeavors here.

If you can't agree that no-state would work, then let us agree that a minimal state would work. Then we can decide where to proceed if ever we get that far.
 
Private security is for the sole purpose of protection. Police just watch over a broad variety of things. Police in fact do help. Even though they barely are engaged in actual conflicts they maintain order. Private security are paid lotsa money not to be cowardly, policemen are paid to be alive.

Yes. However, human's have uniform characteristics that are not malleable in nature. All humans have sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems. All humans will experience and element of fear.

As I previously stated, all security measures are reactive rather than proactive. One cannot, currently at-least, expect a crime to occur and be on guard at said location.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
As I previously stated, all security measures are reactive rather than proactive. One cannot, currently at-least, expect a crime to occur and be on guard at said location.

No longer the case. The miracle of the free-market (what's left of it) brings you automatic monitoring of video cameras:
http://www.vitamindinc.com/

It will not be long before suspicious behaviour (such as grouping or fleeing of people) can be headed off before violence precipitates.
 
Police need guns to fight fire with fire. Otherwise, it'd be a foolish attempt.

Is the increase related to the mentality of the criminals? Being that less armed homeowners makes it less dangerous?

Why would a private security company be any less cowardly? Humans are humans irrespective of their employer. Everybody wants to go home to their wife and family at the end of the night.

Private security is for the sole purpose of protection. Police just watch over a broad variety of things. Police in fact do help. Even though they barely are engaged in actual conflicts they maintain order. Private security are paid lotsa money not to be cowardly, policemen are paid to be alive.


Joe schmoe if he sees a burglary is not going to whip out a 9mm and bust a cap. He might hit a bystander and killsome one. I understand that this could occur with police


Sythe are you advocating vigilanties?
 
Back
Top