• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Pirating? Wrong or Right?

Pirating? Wrong Or Right?

  • Wrong?

    Votes: 41 31.3%

  • Right?

    Votes: 90 68.7%
  • Total voters
    131
Status
Not open for further replies.
lets use music piracy for example. It costs money to rent a studio, it costs money to run that studio. It costs money to hire people to do various things that go along with making that music. You can sell creativity even if its a compilation of sounds and words, you like it otherwise you wouldn't steal it, and you steal it because you don't have it( creativity that is).
 
The_Phoenix_HalfBreed said:
lets use music piracy for example. It costs money to rent a studio, it costs money to run that studio. It costs money to hire people to do various things that go along with making that music. You can sell creativity even if its a compilation of sounds and words, you like it otherwise you wouldn't steal it, and you steal it because you don't have it( creativity that is).
Click to expand...

It's their fault if they expect to make money from it. I'm not required to fork it over so that they can pay off their debts.
 
Piroting is only put-down because people lose profits when they can't sell CD's.
It's possible that they only make 20 bucks because someone buys their CD, rips the songs, puts them on the internet and EVERYONE gets the songs from him instead of the CD.

Oh, Shredderbeam, you simply amaze me.
 
It's wrong, but feels so right when your sitting their watching those movies for free.
 
Shredderbeam said:
If I pirate, the company loses the same amount of money as if I were to not bother myself with them at all - potential money.
Click to expand...

You are simply acting retarded now no offense. I have already stated that if you wanted it and couldn't steal it as you do because pirating is stealing as I have already confirmed as well. you would buy it. because obviously if you steal it by illegally downloading it, you want it. In which you would pay for it. maybe not in the mass amounts that you download but eventually you would buy them all .

Pretty much every attempt at debating this I have answered with a reasoning to which and you are beginning to use the same questions, so this obviously means that the thread is dead now.
 
The Viper000 said:
I voted that it is wrong.

Granted, I have pirated quite a few programs and quite a few songs, but I still don't agree that it is right and can be justified.

If someone makes and produces a song, then they own the rights to that song. If you download it illegally, then you're stealing from them. I don't care if they have 20 billions dollars and use $100 bills to wipe their ass, it is still their product, and thus morally, we should all have to pay for it.
Click to expand...

I agree also. :D
 
deadzone said:
I have already stated that if you wanted it and couldn't steal it as you do because pirating is stealing as I have already confirmed as well. you would buy it.
Click to expand...

No, I wouldn't.

Even if I would, potential money is not the same thing as money lost. Whether I pirate or not, the amount of money that they gain/lose is the exact same - $0.
 
I don't think that there is a right answer to this question. It will be different to everybody depending on the set of morals that they live their life by.
 
deadzone said:
He is not a genius he has lost this debate he is just too arrogant to know when to quit. so I will be the bigger man and step down as I have already proven my point.
Click to expand...

You haven't proven any point. Allow me to repeat myself:

1). I would not buy most software if I was unable to pirate it. Photoshop, language learners, etc. are bloody expensive.

2). Even if I were to buy the software I could not pirate, there is a huge difference between money that the company had, and lost, and money that they could have made, but didn't.

Thanks.
 
I think it's perfectly fine. The people that make these songs/videos or what ever are making millions! So why should they care about a few songs, they richer than most people will ever be.
 
Jay_0x said:
I think it's perfectly fine. The people that make these songs/videos or what ever are making millions! So why should they care about a few songs, they richer than most people will ever be.
Click to expand...

The issue isn't whether they can afford it - its whether music can be considered property or not.

The 1337 Tank said:
dont think its right. they worked like a year to develope a software and u steal it for free.
Click to expand...

The amount of work put into the music is irrelevant. What we are discussing here is whether music is property - whether you can own a concept.
 
My thoughts are that if you have seen it in the movies, You have a right to pirate a copy of the DVD. Why should you pay to see the film twice tbh ?

Well, I think that pirate DVDs should be sold in shops and should be made legall, but then I think we would have all the commotion of crap copys and no refund policys.

Mmm, This is a tough one I think.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Mudkipz
Post
  • Locked
Right or Wrong?
2
Replies
32
Views
647
Mudkipz
Mudkipz
LifeSavers
Post
What's your thought on abortion?
Replies
4
Views
218
.::MaSteR::.
.::MaSteR::.
N
Post
Right and wrong
Replies
3
Views
420
madhacker14
madhacker14
Ermky
Post
  • Poll Poll
Are you Left-Handed or Right-Handed?
2
Replies
32
Views
960
Ermky
Ermky
Yggdrassill
Post
Legalized or Not?
2
Replies
35
Views
540
Eric
E
Runescape Gamblingrunescape gambling
Back
Top