Really you had no reason to contact him? The original owner of the account who has the physical capacity to recover the account regardless of any other factor, he's available, he's a sythe member, he's only a click away. You didn't think once: hey wouldn't it be a good idea to just make sure this account is on the level.Sythe why do you keep saying it my fault for not contacting him?
I had no reason to contact him. The sale itself was rushed (look at the screenshots I provided)
The only thing I had to look out for were if the sale was secure and if Colts was the OO
To both the answers were strong yes's
Please can all other staff and admins give clear inputs/make decisions on this as the voting is currently 2-2
@malakadang im not sure what your decision was
I'm trying to encourage a correct, logical outcome given the facts. Nobody is "flexing", if you don't know the basic law of contracts that's your problem.Can you cucks stop trying to flex your brains in front of the peanut gallery of a Runescape black market forum and just make an honest decision already.
You can clearly see I have contacted him after the sale.What difference is it between prior or post? (Don't answer this, it's meant to be a rhetorical question)
The matter of the fact is I had 100% confirmed he was the OO through exchanged vouches and his selling thread that he was the OO as the stats CLEARLY matched
Also the facts are the ones posted on my report.
Bump this comment please
I can only ask mods/admins to judge this situation with the facts provided. To use their heads and hearts instead of the fucked up real world technicalities. This is gaming forum with a set of market rules. This is not real world assests but instead is virtual goods so your 'laws'; which are being BLOWN OUT OF PROPORTION should be dusted away.
Accounts are ALWAYS recoverable, even with a Middleman/Recovery Test!
Prominently displayed warning sticky should have prompted you to do all due diligence possible including IMHO contacting the readily available original owner of the account.
What about the burden on Esky (due diligence) to chase up the original owner and find out the status of the account? It's in the sticky.I can see both sides of the argument but ultimately it comes down to this:
Colts left a vouch which gives the impression that the trade was COMPLETED... Which means Eskyboy saw this and took it as a sign of purchase, which he rightfully did so.
Racks had an open thread for over a week selling the account which to my knowledge was never challenged or confronted by Colts.
Therefore the burden of the scam falls on Colts, not Esky as it was Colts fault for vouching for a deal that wasn't completed nor confronting Racks for selling an account that wasn't "his".
What about the burden on Esky (due diligence) to chase up the original owner and find out the status of the account? It's in the sticky.
Yes I agree this was at minimum misleading and at the other extreme could be taken to estopp (prevent) colts from recovering the account. However I think if Esky had bothered to contact the readily available original owner he could have avoided falling for this scam. In particular Racks on Racks was not a particularly trusted member, having only joined a couple of months ago. This in conjunction with the sticky should have prompted action.I agree with this point, but you have to understand that by Colts leaving Racks a vouch for the account sale, Esky wasn't in the wrong to assume the account was in any kind of compromised state... Vouches are for successfully completed trades if I'm not mistaken.
You didn't have good reason to believe the seller was the original owner.Why are you interpreting your own rules so twistdly
It clearly says 'IF YOU HAVE GOOD REASON TO BELIEVE'
Which I did.
![]()
No need to contact the original owner before buying an account despite it being listed three times in a three paragraph sticky
Alright, thanks. Appreciate it.I will do shin when I get home
Currently on night shift at work
Won't be back till 8am then I will sleep so will be a while from now
Also I will do the pictures from next time I am home